
give and use kind, specific feedback on garden-and-compost designs to create more possible solutions.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Read two comments about a garden plan. Which one would help a team improve?
Which comment is the most helpful feedback?
Garden engineers, every strong design gets better with feedback. Today two teams swap plans and bottle biomes. We use three sentence starters: I like…, I wonder… and What if….
Kind, specific, helpful. Kind means you respect the team’s work. Specific means you point to one exact part. Helpful means your idea could make the design meet the criteria better.
Worked example 1: feedback for Jamal’s team. Mei’s team said: “I like that your compost bin is next to the garden beds. I wonder what happens to the pea plants after harvest, because no arrow leaves them. What if you add an arrow from old pea plants to the compost bin?”
Worked example 2: a what-if about change. Diego’s team asked: “What if the club adds a worm bin? The worms would help break scraps down faster. But robins might visit to eat the worms.” Jamal’s team used their model to think about how one new species could change other parts of the garden.
| Starter | Our feedback for team ___ |
|---|---|
| I like… | |
| I wonder… | |
| What if… | |
| Criterion this feedback helps |
Visit your partner team’s station. Use the carousel to guide your critique.
Read the feedback your team received.
Which piece of feedback will your team use? Explain how it will help your plan meet the criteria better.
Use your model: if the club removed the compost bin, what would happen to the soil in the garden beds over many years?
Great critique work. Next time is our mid-build checkpoint, so review your notes on plants, food energy and decomposers.
Exit ticket: write one idea you borrowed from another team. Why is it a good idea?
Materials: each team’s plan and bottle biome, critique tables, sticky notes in two colors.
Setup: pair teams. Model one critique with a sample plan first. Give 10 minutes per round and switch.
Listen for: vague praise with no evidence; feedback that is about looks, not science; “more worms is always better” (changes ripple through the system).
Support / stretch: give sentence frames on cards. Stretch: ask teams to predict two effects of adding one new species to the garden.