
analyze plant growth data to decide whether plants need light and water to grow and stay healthy.
Phase 2: Investigate
Check-in. The Recorder checks your team’s four cups and notes any change. Then look at the teacher’s cups that started ten days earlier.
A plant's leaves droop and feel dry. Which cup is it most likely from?
From observations to evidence. Data become evidence when we use them to answer a question. Our question is: do plants need light and water to grow? To answer it, we compare cups that differ in only one way.
Example data. Here are example results like many classes get with bean seedlings after about ten days. Your own numbers will differ a little, and that is fine.
| Cup | Light? | Water? | Day 1 (cm) | Day 10 (cm) | What it looked like |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | yes | yes | 4 | 12 | green, sturdy, new leaves |
| B | no | yes | 4 | 15 | pale yellow, thin, floppy stem |
| C | yes | no | 4 | 5 | wilted, dry, brown edges |
| D | no | no | 4 | 4 | wilted and pale |
Your own team’s table from 2.03 has the same columns. Add today’s heights in the “Later” columns.
Worked example 1: comparing A and C. Jamal compares the two window cups. Cup A got water and grew from 4 to 12 cm. Cup C got no water and barely grew. Only water changed, so Jamal writes, “Water caused the difference. Plants need water to grow.”
Worked example 2: a tricky result. Ava notices Cup B grew the tallest. Does that mean light is not needed? She looks closer. Cup B is pale, thin and falls over. Its leaves are small. A plant in the dark stretches upward, using food stored in the seed. Once that store runs out, it cannot keep going. Ava writes, “Tall is not the same as healthy. Plants need light to stay healthy and keep growing.”
Growth is evidence of new matter. When Cup A grew taller and added leaves, the plant got bigger. Bigger means it has more mass than before. That new matter had to come from somewhere. Where? That is our next investigation.
Use the example data table and your own cups. Talk it over with your team before you answer.
Make a graph to show the pattern.
Make a bar graph of the Day 10 heights for Cups A to D. Below it, write two sentences: what plants need, and the evidence for it.
The garden club has one bed in deep shade. Using your evidence, what advice would you give them?
Plants need water to grow and light to stay healthy. Growing plants gain mass. Next lesson, we test a famous question: does that mass come from the soil?
Exit ticket: what evidence shows that plants need light, even though Cup B grew tall?
Materials: team Four Cups from 2.03, the teacher set started ten days earlier, rulers, graph paper. Rotate team roles today: Materials Manager, Recorder, Tester, Reporter. Each person gets a new job.
Setup: place the teacher cups side by side under a document camera. Keep team cups going; teams record a later height again in 2.07 and 2.09.
Listen for: “the dark plant grew best” (address with color and sturdiness, and the seed’s stored food); “plants get food from water” (water is one material; we will see air matters too). Do not explain how plants make food yet.
Support / stretch: give a graph with axes already labeled. Stretch: ask what would happen to Cup B after a month, and why.