
brainstorm at least three ideas for each of our tools and explain the sky science each idea uses.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Re-read our criteria and constraints chart. Then look at our Wonder Board. Put a check on every question we can now answer. Which questions are still open?
How should we make sure the shadow clock's stick stands perfectly straight up?
Junior engineers, it is time to ideate. To ideate means to come up with lots of ideas before choosing one. Every idea must use science we discovered. Wild ideas are welcome, as long as they fit our criteria and constraints. We will choose and build in the next phase.
Brainstorm rules. Go for quantity first. Build on each other’s ideas with “Yes, and…” Do not judge ideas yet. Sketch with labels so others can see your thinking. The Recorder writes every idea down.
Worked example 1: three shadow clock ideas. Priya’s team sketched a flat board with a straight stick and painted hour lines. They sketched a “human sundial,” where a family member stands on a spot and becomes the stick. They sketched a stick with a plumb line hanging beside it, so families can see it stands straight toward Earth’s center. Each idea used the daily shadow pattern: long west in the morning, short north near solar noon, long east in the afternoon.
Worked example 2: three sky calendar ideas. Jamal’s team sketched a four-panel poster, one panel per season, with that season’s constellations and daylight hours. They sketched a spinning paper wheel that shows one season at a time. They sketched a booklet with a page called “Why is the Sun so bright?” It explains that all stars give off light, but the Sun looks brightest because it is much closer.
| Idea sketch | Science it uses (gravity, distance and brightness, daily or yearly pattern) | Criteria it meets | A concern or question |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shadow clock idea 1 | |||
| Shadow clock idea 2 | |||
| Shadow clock idea 3 | |||
| Sky calendar idea 1 | |||
| Sky calendar idea 2 | |||
| Sky calendar idea 3 |
Use our science to check the ideas. Talk with your team before each answer.
Fill in your own row of the idea table, then explain your best idea.
Sketch one new idea for either tool. Label the science it uses, and explain why it would work at Night Sky Night.
How confident are you that you can I can explain the science behind my design ideas.
Our idea table is full of science-based designs. Next, in Build, we choose, prototype and test them for the library. First, your 3DX field trip!
Exit ticket: which idea do you think the library families would love most, and which sky pattern does it depend on?
Materials: the criteria and constraints chart, the Wonder Board, sketch paper, colored pencils, the idea table.
Setup: post brainstorm rules. Give each team a timer for two quick rounds: shadow clock ideas, then sky calendar ideas.
Listen for: ideas that break the science, such as hour lines swinging from east to west, or a calendar claiming the Sun is the biggest star. Teams choose and compare designs in Build, where 3-5-ETS1-2 is developed. Keep today on generating ideas grounded in the science.
Support / stretch: give a starter sketch to adapt. Stretch: design a version of the shadow clock that a family could take home and set up themselves.