
write an argument, with evidence and reasoning, that Earth’s gravity pulls objects down toward Earth’s center.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at your Drop Zone table and your globe model. With a partner, list every clue we have about which way objects fall.
A student at a school in Brazil drops a pencil. Which way does it go, compared to the globe?
Now we can explain what you found. When you let go of an object, it starts moving down. Something must cause that change. A push or pull that causes motion is a force. The force that pulls objects toward Earth is gravity. You cannot see it, but you can see what it does.
Putting two ideas together. Idea 1: Earth is shaped like a sphere. We have evidence from ships, the Moon’s eclipse shadow and the North Star. Idea 2: people everywhere see objects fall straight down. Put them together. If Earth is a ball, and everyone’s “down” is straight toward the ground, then every “down” points to the same place: Earth’s center.
Worked example 1: an argument. Here is how Ava’s team wrote theirs.
Worked example 2: judging the evidence. Jamal’s team asked if the evidence was enough. Our drops all happened in one classroom. The globe was a model, not the real Earth. So they asked for more evidence: a video from a pen pal class in another country, dropping a ball with a plumb line beside it. Asking for more evidence is a strength, not a weakness.
Model it. Draw Earth as a big circle. Add four people around it, each holding a ball. Draw an arrow from each ball to the ground. Extend each arrow with a dotted line. Label the place where they meet.
Build and test the argument with your team. Use the arrows to move through the cards.
Write your own argument. Use these sentence starters:
Write your gravity argument. Then add one sentence that says whether the evidence is enough, or what more you would need.
You built a real scientific argument about gravity. Next time, we argue about light: why does the Sun outshine every other star?
Exit ticket: a younger child asks why people in Australia do not fall off Earth. Answer in two sentences, using the word gravity.
Materials: data tables from 4.03, globe models from 4.04, chart paper and markers, the argument sentence starters on the board.
Setup: post the class list of evidence about Earth’s shape beside the Wonder Board.
Listen for: “gravity comes from air pressing down” or “gravity only pulls heavy things.” The 5-PS2-1 boundary excludes the math of gravity; keep the focus on direction toward Earth’s center.
Support / stretch: let some students build the argument by sorting printed claim, evidence and reasoning strips. Stretch: ask what the down arrows would look like on a planet shaped like a long cylinder, and why our evidence rules that shape out for Earth.