
argue from evidence that the Sun looks brighter and bigger than other stars because it is much closer to Earth, and judge whether our evidence is enough.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at your Flashlight Galaxy table. Find the rating for Flashlight B at 2 meters and at 8 meters. What changed, and what stayed the same?
If we could move the Sun as far away as other stars, how would it look from Earth?
Now we can explain what you found. In the Flashlight Galaxy, the same light looked dimmer and smaller as it moved farther away. Stars work the same way. The Sun and all the other stars are very large and give off their own light. The Sun looks so much brighter and bigger because it is much, much closer to us.
How much closer? The next-nearest star after the Sun is more than 250,000 times farther away than the Sun. Imagine one flashlight 5 meters away, across the room, and an identical one more than 1,000 kilometers away. Other stars are even farther. That is why they look like tiny dots, and some look dimmer than others.
Worked example 1: an argument. Here is how Mei’s team wrote theirs.
Worked example 2: different-looking stars. On a clear night, Malik saw some stars that looked bright and many that looked faint. Our flashlight data helps here, too. Stars sit at many different distances from Earth. Distance is one big reason some stars look dimmer than others.
Is our evidence enough? Our flashlight test is relevant, because it tests distance and brightness. But flashlights are a model, not real stars. Scientists add measured distances to stars, like the one above. Ask yourself: does my evidence really connect to the claim? Do I need more?
Build and test the argument with your team. Talk before you tap.
Write your own argument. Use these sentence starters:
Write your distance argument. Then judge it: is your evidence relevant, is it enough, and what more evidence would you want?
You argued, with evidence, that distance makes the Sun our brightest star. Next time, we explain our shadow graphs and the Sun’s daily path.
Exit ticket: write one sentence for the sky calendar that explains to families why the Sun looks so much brighter than the stars they will see at Night Sky Night.
Materials: Flashlight Galaxy tables from 4.05, a flashlight for a quick demo, the argument sentence starters on the board.
Setup: re-run one quick 2 m and 8 m flashlight comparison at the start if students need a reminder.
Listen for: “the Sun is the biggest star” or “bright stars are younger.” 5-ESS1-1 is relative distance ONLY; do not compare star sizes, ages or stages. Planets that look bright at night reflect sunlight; if students raise them, note that they are not stars. Keep numbers relative (times farther), not light-years.
Support / stretch: provide claim, evidence and reasoning strips to sort. Stretch: ask what evidence would be needed to show that a faint star is farther away and not just giving off less light.