
use my model and our data to explain how two of Earth’s systems work together to change the land, and write a CER.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at your 3.05 table. Compare the runoff from bare soil and from grass.
Which tray lost more soil, bare or grass? Give one number or observation from your table.
Spheres team up to change the land. Earth’s surface is always being shaped. Usually two or more spheres are working together.
Hydrosphere + geosphere. Moving water carries soil and small rocks to new places. On our bare tray, water cut a channel and turned the runoff muddy. In a real creek, fast water after storms wears away banks. But the land also shapes the water. Hills and valleys decide where water flows, just like the folds in our paper watershed.
Biosphere + geosphere. Plant roots hold soil together. Our grass tray lost less soil than the bare tray. Along a creek, trees and shrubs keep banks from crumbling. The soil, in turn, holds the water and nutrients the plants need.
Atmosphere + hydrosphere. The air carries water vapor and brings it back as rain or snow. Rain then feeds the creek and soaks into the ground. Without the atmosphere, the creek would not be refilled.
Worked example 1: a CER. Priya writes: Claim: “Plants help hold the land in place when water flows over it.” Evidence: “Our grass tray had a mud rating of 1. The bare tray had a 4 and a new channel.” Reasoning: “Roots from the biosphere grip the soil of the geosphere, so the water cannot carry it away as easily.”
Worked example 2: one part helps both systems. Malik looks at rocks on a creek bottom. Rocks are part of the geosphere. They slow the water, so the water carries less soil away. Rocks also give insects and small fish places to hide. One part helps more than one system work.
Match each investigation to the spheres it showed. Then add arrows to your 3.10 model.
| Investigation | Two spheres | How the land changed | Our evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rain on soil, grass, pavement (3.05) | |||
| Leaf bag (3.06) | |||
| Paper watershed (3.09) |
CER starters: Claim: “The ___ and the ___ work together to ___.” Evidence: “In our test, we saw ___.” Reasoning: “This happens because ___.”
Use your model to explain.
Add two arrows to your 3.10 model that show the land being changed. Then explain how one part of your model helps BOTH spheres work.
The spheres work as a team to shape the land around our creek. Next, we explain what our water graphs tell us.
Exit ticket: describe one way two spheres work together to change Earth's surface. Name the spheres.
Materials: notebooks with 3.05, 3.06 and 3.09 data, 3.10 models, CER organizers, colored pencils.
Setup: Post class data from each investigation so teams with missing data can borrow it.
Listen for: one-way arrows only (water changes land). Push for the return arrow: how does the land change the water? Use the CER and the model arrows as formative checks of 2a and 3a.
Support / stretch: Give a partly filled CER. Stretch: explain how a change in one sphere (cutting down trees) could cause changes in two others.