
give and use kind, specific feedback to find the parts of a fix that do not meet our criteria yet, and explain how evidence shows what to improve.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Read two comments about a rain garden model. Comment 1: “It’s bad.” Comment 2: “I wonder if water runs around the sponge on the left side, because the creek cup was still muddy.” Which comment helps more? Why?
What makes Comment 2 more helpful?
Critique makes designs better. Engineers show their work to others early. Fresh eyes spot problems the builders miss. Good critique is kind, specific and helpful. It is about the design, never the person.
Our protocol (about 6 minutes per team).
Worked example 1: feedback for Priya’s bank. “I like that your grass bank stayed muddiness 2, because it shows roots hold soil. I wonder if the bare edge is where the mud came from. What if you planted to the very edge?” Each part points to evidence or a specific spot.
Worked example 2: using feedback. Diego’s team got three “I wonder” comments. Two were about water sneaking around the sponge. When more than one person notices the same thing, it is probably a real failure point. They will test that spot first.
How evidence guides you. Feedback gives ideas. Test data tells you which ideas matter. Match each comment to your numbers before you decide what to change.
Run the critique circle. Use the arrows to move through each step.
On your own, turn feedback into a plan.
Name ONE part of your fix that does not meet a criterion or constraint yet. Explain how your evidence (data or feedback) shows this, and what you could improve.
You gave and got feedback like real engineers and scientists. Next time, we spread the word with a campaign that reaches the whole community.
Exit ticket: which piece of feedback will you use, and what evidence makes you think it matters?
Materials: team models and build logs; feedback sheets with I like / I wonder / What if boxes; a timer.
Setup: Pair teams. Each team presents, then switches. Model one round with a teacher-made fix first. Post sentence frames.
Listen for: vague praise (“it’s cool”), comments about people instead of designs, and builders defending instead of recording. Coach: “Point to a spot or a number.”
Support / stretch: Allow students to sketch feedback with an arrow on a photo of the model. Stretch: visitors rank which criterion the team is closest to meeting and explain why.