
compare the good and bad effects of energy resources on the environment and explain how technology can reduce those effects.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at your energy trail from 1.08 and your cookie drawing from 1.09. Every resource helps people. Does every resource also change the environment?
Which energy resource has NO effect at all on the environment?
Reading-like explanation: energy and our environment. People need energy to light schools, ring bells and heat homes. We get it from natural resources. Using each one changes the environment in some way.
Technology can help. Engineers design tools that lower the effects. Filters in power plant smokestacks catch some pollution before it reaches the air. Mined land can be filled in and replanted. Some wind farms slow their blades at times when bats fly most. Fish ladders help fish get past some dams. LED bulbs use less electricity, so less fuel is needed.
Worked example 1: comparing two resources. Ava compared coal and wind. “Coal: good, it works day and night. Bad, burning it pollutes the air, and it will run out. Wind: good, no air pollution and renewable. Bad, it stops when the wind stops and can harm birds.”
Worked example 2: an energy CER. Jamal’s claim: “Solar panels on our school roof would help the environment.” Evidence: panels make no air pollution while they work, and sunlight is renewable. A roof does not take up new land. Reasoning: using sunlight means less fuel is burned for our lights, so less air pollution.
| Resource | Renewable? | One good effect | One bad effect | A technology that helps |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coal | ||||
| Natural gas | ||||
| Wind | ||||
| Solar | ||||
| Water |
Compare resources with your team.
Write an energy CER. Sentence starters:
Write your energy CER for our school. Use information from the reading and your table.
Every energy choice is a trade-off, and technology can make the effects smaller. Next time, we bring everything together and brainstorm our machine.
Exit ticket: name one renewable and one nonrenewable resource, and one environmental effect of each.
Materials: the reading (printed or projected), the comparison table, energy trails and cookie drawings from 1.08 and 1.09.
Setup: jigsaw the reading: each team member becomes the expert on one or two resources and teaches the team. Nuclear is on the 1.08 card; add it as a sixth row for early finishers (no air pollution while running; used fuel must be stored safely for a very long time).
Listen for: “renewable means perfect” and “coal is bad, so people who use it are bad.” Keep the talk on effects and trade-offs, and stay respectful of family jobs in energy industries. Keep energy facts general; no statistics.
Support / stretch: give a picture sort of good and bad effects. Stretch: argue for a MIX of resources and explain why.