
measure refraction angles and apply Snell’s law, compute photon energies with E = hf, explain when the wave or particle model of light is more useful, and evaluate claims about how different frequencies of electromagnetic radiation affect matter.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A straw in a glass of water looks bent at the surface. Sketch it, and write one sentence about what you think happens to the light.
A metal plate gives off electrons under dim violet light. What happens under very bright red light?
Light is an electromagnetic wave. Light, radio, microwaves, infrared, ultraviolet, X-rays and gamma rays are all electromagnetic (EM) waves: linked electric and magnetic fields that need no medium and travel at c = 3.00 × 108 m/s in a vacuum. They differ only in frequency and wavelength, with c = fλ. A red laser pointer at 650 nm has f = c/λ = 4.62 × 1014 Hz.
Refraction. Light slows down in matter. The index of refraction is n = c/v; water has n ≈ 1.33, so light travels at 2.26 × 108 m/s in water. When light crosses a boundary at an angle, it bends. Snell’s law gives the angles, measured from the normal (the line perpendicular to the surface): n1 sin θ1 = n2 sin θ2.
Worked example 1. A beam in air hits water at 40°. sin θ2 = (1.00 × sin 40°)/1.33, so θ2 = 28.9°. In acrylic (n ≈ 1.49, typical) the same beam bends to 25.6°. Light bends toward the normal entering a slower medium. The frequency stays the same, so the wavelength shrinks: 650 nm in air becomes 650/1.33 = 489 nm in water.
Total internal reflection. Going the other way, from water into air, light bends away from the normal. At the critical angle the refracted ray skims along the surface: sin θc = n2/n1 = 1/1.33, so θc = 48.8° (acrylic: 42.2°). Beyond it, all the light reflects. Optical fibers trap light this way: a glass core surrounded by cladding of slightly lower index. With a core of 1.48 and cladding of 1.46 (typical values), θc = 80.6°, so light running nearly parallel to the fiber stays inside for kilometers.
When the wave model is not enough. Refraction, interference and diffraction are explained by waves. But in the photoelectric effect, light shining on a metal ejects electrons, and the results defy a pure wave picture: dim violet light ejects electrons immediately, while bright red light ejects none at all from the same metal. Einstein’s explanation: light arrives in packets, photons, each with energy E = hf = hc/λ, where h = 6.626 × 10−34 J·s. One photon gives its energy to one electron. If that energy is less than the metal’s work function W (the minimum energy to free an electron), nothing happens, however bright the light.
Worked example 2. A red 650 nm photon has E = (6.626 × 10−34)(3.00 × 108)/(650 × 10−9) = 3.06 × 10−19 J = 1.91 eV (1 eV = 1.602 × 10−19 J). A 405 nm violet photon has 3.06 eV. Sodium’s work function is about 2.3 eV (approximate). Red cannot eject electrons from sodium; violet can, with at most 3.06 − 2.3 = 0.76 eV of kinetic energy left over. Brighter light means more photons, so more electrons, not faster ones. Which model is “right”? Both: the wave model predicts where light goes, the particle model predicts how it trades energy with matter.
Frequency decides the effect on matter. Photon energy rises with frequency. A 300 nm UV-B photon carries 4.14 eV, enough to alter bonds in DNA, which is why UV causes sunburn and raises skin-cancer risk; NOAA and EPA publish a daily UV Index (3-5 moderate, 6-7 high, 8-10 very high, 11+ extreme). A 2.45 GHz microwave-oven photon carries only 1.01 × 10−5 eV, about 410,000 times less; microwaves heat food by making water molecules rotate, not by breaking bonds. A 28 GHz 5G photon carries 1.16 × 10−4 eV. Radiation that can knock electrons out of atoms (roughly 10 eV and up: far UV, X-rays, gamma rays) is called ionizing. Radio, microwaves, infrared and visible light are non-ionizing; their main absorbed effect is heating, which depends on intensity and exposure time.
Misconceptions. “Radiation” does not always mean dangerous; the word covers sunlight and radio. “More intense microwaves become ionizing.” No: intensity adds photons, it never raises the energy of each one.
Two claims about light. Scientists have argued about what light is for centuries. Claim W: light is a wave. Evidence: it refracts by the amount Snell’s law predicts from a change in speed, and two beams can interfere, adding to bright spots in some places and cancelling to dark spots in others (lesson 4.06). Claim P: light comes in particles, photons. Evidence: in the photoelectric effect, whether electrons come out depends on the light’s frequency, not its brightness, and they come out at once even in dim light. The reasoning that links each kind of evidence to its claim is the heart of the argument: cancellation needs something with crests and troughs; a frequency threshold that brightness cannot overcome needs energy delivered in packets of hf. Modern physics keeps both models and uses whichever is more useful for the question asked.
Question. What is the index of refraction of water (or acrylic), found from measured angles, and at what angle does total internal reflection begin?
Materials.
Procedure.
Data table.
| θ1 in air | θ2 inside | sin θ1 | sin θ2 | n |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20° | 0.342 | |||
| 30° | 0.500 | |||
| 40° | 0.643 | |||
| 50° | 0.766 | |||
| 60° | 0.866 | |||
| Illustrative check: for water (n = 1.33), 40° in air gives 28.9° inside; the critical angle is 48.8°. | ||||
Analysis.
Other routes to the same data. Choose one. All three earn full credit and end in the same value of n and the same critical-angle check. Option A — laser and container or block. The procedure above. Option B — the sample angles. No equipment needed. Use these constructed readings for water: 20° → 15°, 30° → 22°, 40° → 29°, 50° → 35°, 60° → 41°; critical angle about 49°. Complete the table, graph sin θ1 against sin θ2 and answer every analysis question. Option C — PhET Bending Light. Intro screen, Air above and Water below: record five angle pairs with the protractor and find the critical angle by moving the laser underneath. Cite the sim and the date you used it.
Show Snell’s law and E = hf with units.
Lab write-up and claim evaluation.
Report your value of n from the slope with its percent difference from the accepted value, and your critical angle compared with sin−1(1/n). Then state Claim W and Claim P about light, name the evidence for each from this lesson, and explain the reasoning that links them.
Find a published claim about 5G or cell-phone radiation causing harm (a news story, video or website). Evaluate its validity and reliability: who published it, what evidence it offers, and whether it agrees with photon-energy physics and with reliable sources (FCC, FDA, WHO, peer-reviewed studies). Compute the photon energy of the frequency involved and compare it with the roughly 10 eV needed to ionize atoms. Then name the effect radio waves do have when absorbed (heating) and explain why exposure limits are set on absorbed power.
The wave model tells us where light goes; the photon model tells us how it trades energy with matter. Next lesson: the interference evidence, and a CER on both models.
Exit ticket: why can no amount of microwave radiation ionize an atom, while a single X-ray photon can?
How confident are you that you can I can apply Snell's law, compute photon energies and explain when the wave or particle model of light is more useful.
Materials: see the lab list; class 2 lasers stay with the teacher between trials. Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapters on light and quantum physics, and OpenStax College Physics 2e, chapters 25 and 29 (CC BY 4.0); h, c and e from NIST CODATA; the UV Index scale from NOAA and EPA (public domain).
Timing: Poly ran this workshop over two sessions. Period one: refraction lab and total internal reflection; period two: photons, the spectrum and the claim evaluation.
Listen for: angles measured from the surface; “brighter light means more energetic photons”; “all radiation is dangerous”.
Support / stretch: give a protractor overlay and a photon-energy table template. Stretch: find the longest wavelength that can free electrons from sodium.