
show what I know about energy accounting, particle-scale models, power, computational models and energy-converter design.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Back to the phenomenon: in one or two sentences, explain to a visitor why a pumped-storage plant returns less energy than it uses, even though energy is conserved.
Doubling the speed of a cart doubles its kinetic energy.
Energy engineers, this is the unit checkpoint. Part A is multiple choice with data. Part B is a scenario set where several questions share one situation. Part C is short constructed responses, each scored 0–3. Use g = 9.8 m/s2, show units, and keep a calculator handy.
How a 0–3 answer is scored. 3: correct claim, correct calculation or model with units, and reasoning that names the system and the energy flows. 2: correct claim with a small error or incomplete reasoning. 1: partly correct idea with major gaps. 0: incorrect or blank.
Worked example: from 2 points to 3. Question: “A 2.0 kg cart rolls down a 0.50 m drop and leaves at 2.8 m/s. Where did the rest of the energy go?” A 2-point answer: “mgh = 9.8 J, KE = 7.84 J, so 1.96 J was lost to friction.” A 3-point answer adds the system and the particle scale: “For the system cart + track + Earth + air, 1.96 J became thermal energy: friction turned ordered motion into random vibration of particles in the wheels, axle and track, plus a little sound.”
Scenario set data (sample data). Use for questions 6–9. A museum tests three energy converters. Each starts with 8.0 J of input energy; three trials each.
| Device | Useful output, trials 1–3 (J) | Mean output (J) | Runs before repair | Cost (budget points) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P: falling-mass lifter | 4.4, 4.6, 4.5 | 4.5 | 40 | 8 |
| Q: rubber-band car | 3.2, 4.4, 3.8 | 3.8 | 15 | 4 |
| R: band launcher | 4.6, 4.7, 4.8 | 4.7 | 6 | 3 |
Power model data (sample data) for question 10. A small storage pump uses 2.0 kW for 3.0 h with 80% pump efficiency, and later generates with 85% efficiency.
Parts A and B: answer on your own. Your teacher reviews answers after everyone finishes.
Part C: constructed responses, each scored 0–3.
13. A 60 kg skater starts at rest 4.0 m above the bottom of a track. Friction converts 300 J to thermal energy by the bottom. Name your system and zero level, write the energy equation, find the skater's speed at the bottom, and find the MAXIMUM speed possible with no friction. State one limitation of your model. (0–3)
14. Draw a model of a rubber-band car launch at two scales. Label the energy forms before, during and after, at the visible scale and the particle scale, and use it to argue that energy is conserved even though the car stops. (0–3)
15. A team's lifter (input 7.84 J) gave version 1: 4.31, 4.55, 4.41 J and version 2: 4.90, 5.05, 4.85 J of useful output. Evaluate the change quantitatively (efficiencies and spreads), name one criterion besides efficiency they should test, and propose one further improvement with its science reason and trade-off. (0–3)
16. Design an energy converter for a new exhibit that turns gravitational energy into electrical energy to light a small LED. Describe its parts, the energy conversions, where energy is lost, one criterion and one constraint, and how you would measure its efficiency. (0–3)
Finished, engineers. Your results guide re-teaching before Unit 2. Next: the Phase 5 field trip.
Exit ticket: which question was hardest, and which idea from this unit do you want to practice again?
How confident are you that you can I can calculate and model energy in a system at two scales and use measured efficiency to design and improve a device.
Materials: printed checkpoint, calculators, scoring guide for items 13–16.
Setup: about 40 minutes. Item tags: 1–3, 10–13 HS-PS3-1 (1a: 1, 2, 13; 2a: 3, 10, 13; 2b: 12, 13; 3a: 10, 13; 3b: 11, 13); 4, 5, 14 HS-PS3-2 (all four ids through item 14’s two-scale model); 6–9, 15, 16 HS-PS3-3 (1a and 1b: 16; 2a: 8, 16; 3a and 3b: 6, 7, 9, 15; 4a: 15). Answer key notes: item 9 is False; discuss why a gap equal to the spread is not proof. Item 13: v = √(2(2,352 − 300)/60) ≈ 8.3 m/s; maximum ≈ 8.9 m/s.
Listen for: forgetting to convert cm to m; using kW for energy; “energy was destroyed”.
Support / stretch: read items aloud on request and provide an equation sheet. Stretch: for item 16, estimate the LED’s efficiency if it needs 0.06 W for 10 s from a 1.0 kg mass falling 1.0 m.