
Energy In, Energy Out: A Visitor-Center Energy Converter
How can we design a device that converts energy from one form to another as efficiently as possible, and use it to show visitors why stored energy always comes back as less useful energy?
The mystery: A pumped-storage hydroelectric plant pumps water uphill with surplus midday solar power and lets it run back down through turbines in the evening, but it always delivers less electricity than it used. Where is the energy while the water waits, and where does the missing part go?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
explain the client’s request, define the system our converter will work in, and organize the need-to-knows and team roles for the project.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Think of a museum or science-center exhibit you remember. What made you touch it, and what did you learn from it? Write two sentences.
A visitor drops a 1 kg mass that lifts a 0.5 kg load. Which result is physically possible?
Meet the client. A regional power cooperative runs a visitor center beside its pumped-storage plant. School groups and families come every week and ask the same two questions: “If energy is conserved, why does the plant get back less than it puts in?” and “Why not just make it 100% efficient?” The education manager has asked our class for a hands-on exhibit: a small device that visitors can run, which converts one form of energy into another and shows its own efficiency with real measurements.
Your mission. Energy engineers, your team will design, build, test and refine an energy converter, then defend it to the client with data. Options from the design brief: a falling-mass lifter, a rubber-band car, or a rubber-band launcher. All three are tabletop scale and use everyday materials.
Class criteria and constraints for the exhibit converter (set in 1.02, ranked in 1.07). Criteria: (1) the final version reaches a mean efficiency of at least 50% over three trials; (2) its three trials agree within ±5 percentage points; (3) it runs 10 times in a row without repair, because visitors will use it all day. Constraints: input energy no more than 10 J (a falling mass of at most 1.0 kg dropped at most 1.0 m, or a band stretched at most 25 cm); it fits a 60 cm × 40 cm table space; class-kit or household materials only, costing at most 10 sample budget points; two build periods.
Worked example 1: defining the system. Ava’s team chose the falling-mass lifter. They drew a boundary around the falling mass, the load, the spool, the string and Earth. Inside: gravitational energy of two masses, kinetic energy, and thermal energy in the axle. Outside: the hands that reset the device (work done on the system between runs) and the room air that carries thermal energy away. They set the zero of potential energy at the tabletop.
Worked example 2: a need-to-know list. Jamal turned the brief into questions the team must answer before building. How do we measure input energy? How do we measure useful output? Where will energy be lost? What counts as “better”: efficiency, durability or cost? Each question points to a lesson ahead: the ramp lab (measuring energy), the rubber-band lab (losses), and the modeling workshop (calculating and predicting).
Team roles. Teams of three or four rotate weekly: Project Manager (schedule and criteria), Data Lead (measurements, spreadsheet, uncertainty), Build Lead (materials, tools and safety), and Communications Lead (design log, diagrams and the client presentation).
Work as a new team. Discuss each card before answering.
Set up the project pages in your Energy Notebook.
Write the client's problem in two sentences: who needs what, and how we will know the exhibit works. Then draw your chosen device as a system, with the boundary, the zero of potential energy, and arrows for every energy flow you expect.
Add three questions to the class Wonder Board: one about measuring energy, one about losses, and one about what visitors will understand.
We have a client, a brief, criteria and teams. Next phase we investigate: first, how to measure energy on a ramp.
Exit ticket: what is the single most important measurement your team must get right, and why?
How confident are you that you can I can define a system's boundary and explain what the client needs from our energy converter.
Materials: printed client brief (a generic letter from a power cooperative’s education manager), Wonder Board chart paper, role cards, sample devices or photos of a falling-mass lifter, a rubber-band car and a launcher.
Setup: the client is fictional and generic; if a local utility or science center will join by video, adapt the letter. Post the class criteria and constraints and keep them up all unit.
Listen for: systems with no boundary; devices that “make” energy; criteria confused with constraints.
Support / stretch: give a system template with labeled boxes. Stretch: write the energy equation for the chosen device with a separate term for each expected loss.