
Energy In, Energy Out: A Visitor-Center Energy Converter
How can we design a device that converts energy from one form to another as efficiently as possible, and use it to show visitors why stored energy always comes back as less useful energy?
The mystery: A pumped-storage hydroelectric plant pumps water uphill with surplus midday solar power and lets it run back down through turbines in the evening, but it always delivers less electricity than it used. Where is the energy while the water waits, and where does the missing part go?
calculate the work done by a force at an angle, the kinetic and gravitational potential energy of an object, and show with an energy bar chart how energy moves through a pumped-storage system.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. You charge a phone to 100% overnight and drain it to 20% by evening. In two sentences: where did the energy come from, and where is it now? Then answer the prediction below before we see the phenomenon.
A plant uses 100 MWh of electricity to pump water uphill at midday. How much electricity will it deliver when that water flows back down in the evening?
The phenomenon. On a sunny spring afternoon, a region with many solar farms can produce more electricity than its homes and businesses are using. Some of that midday surplus can go into pumped-storage hydroelectric plants, which are built in hilly and mountain country in many parts of the world. Each plant has two reservoirs at different heights. At midday, electric pumps push water up to the upper reservoir. After sunset, when demand peaks and solar output falls, the water runs back down through the same machines working as turbines and generators. No fuel is burned. The question for this unit: where is the energy while the water sits uphill, and why do we get back less than we put in?
Work. A force transfers energy into or out of a system by doing work: W = Fd cos θ, where F is the force, d the displacement and θ the angle between them. Work is measured in joules (1 J = 1 N·m). Only the part of the force along the motion counts.
Worked example. You pull a rolling suitcase 20 m through an airport with a 60 N force on the handle at 35° above the floor. W = (60 N)(20 m) cos 35° = 983 J. Had you pulled horizontally, all 1,200 J would count; pulling at an angle wastes part of your force lifting on the handle, which does no work along the floor.
Three cases to remember. If the force points along the motion (θ = 0°), W = Fd. If it is perpendicular (θ = 90°), W = 0: carrying a box across a room at steady height, your upward push does no work on it. If it opposes the motion (θ = 180°), the work is negative and energy leaves the object: 12 N of friction on a box sliding 3 m does W = −36 J.
Kinetic energy. A moving object has KE = ½mv2. The work-energy theorem says the net work on an object equals its change in kinetic energy. A 1,200 kg car going from rest to 15 m/s gains ½(1,200)(15)2 = 135,000 J. If that happens over 100 m, the average net force was 135,000 J ÷ 100 m = 1,350 N. Speed is squared, so doubling speed quadruples kinetic energy.
Gravitational potential energy. Lifting a mass m a height h at steady speed takes a force mg through distance h, so the work done is mgh, and the Earth-object system stores ΔPE = mgh. Pumped storage runs on this. Take a head (height difference) of 500 m (illustrative numbers). One cubic meter of water has a mass of 1,000 kg, so lifting it stores (1,000)(9.8)(500) = 4.9 × 106 J = 1.36 kWh. An upper reservoir holding 1 × 107 m3 above that head would store about 4.9 × 1013 J, or 13.6 GWh (illustrative numbers). If one kilogram fell the full 500 m with nothing in the way, it would reach √(2gh) ≈ 99 m/s. In the plant, the turbine takes that energy instead, and the water leaves slowly.
Energy belongs to a system. Potential energy is not stored “in the water”. It belongs to the water-Earth system, because it depends on their separation. Always name your system first. If the system is water + Earth, the pump’s push is external work that adds energy. If the system is water + Earth + pump + grid, the energy has only changed form. Energy is conserved: it is transferred or transformed, never created or destroyed.
Energy bar charts. A bar chart shows the energy accounting. The chart below uses illustrative pump and turbine efficiencies of 87% and 86%. Of 100 units of electrical energy used at midday, 87 end up as gravitational potential energy and 13 become thermal energy in the motors and water. In the evening, the 87 units return as 74.8 units of electricity. The round trip is 74.8%. Published estimates for pumped storage are commonly in the 70-80% range.
Common misconceptions. (1) “Holding something heavy is work.” Your muscles use energy, but no work is done on the object if it does not move. (2) “Energy is used up.” It is transformed, mostly into thermal energy that spreads out and is hard to use again. (3) “Pumped storage makes energy.” It only stores energy that was generated elsewhere, and returns less of it.
Work in pairs. Show the equation, the numbers with units, and the answer.
Start your Energy Notebook for this unit.
A 0.50 kg ball is dropped from 2.0 m. (a) Choose the ball + Earth as your system and set the floor as the zero of potential energy. Draw energy bar charts for the moment of release and the instant before it lands, with values in joules. (b) Find its speed just before landing, ignoring air drag. (c) Redraw the second chart if air drag converts 0.40 J to thermal energy.
In 3–4 sentences, explain to a skeptical neighbor why a pumped-storage plant is worth building even though it returns less energy than it uses. Use the bar chart from the lesson.
Energy is conserved, but every transfer leaves some as thermal energy. Next lesson we meet our client and launch the project.
Exit ticket: name the system you would choose to show that a pumped-storage plant does not “make” energy, and say what crosses its boundary.
How confident are you that you can I can calculate work, kinetic energy and gravitational potential energy, and track energy through a pumped-storage system with a bar chart.
Materials: calculators, chart paper for energy bar charts. Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 9 and the energy sections of chapter 8, and OpenStax College Physics 2e, chapter 7 (CC BY 4.0).
Setup: the reservoir numbers are illustrative, as the lesson says. Keep the plant generic; any pumped-storage photo or diagram works for the launch.
Listen for: “holding a heavy box is work”; potential energy “in the water” with no system named; “the plant makes energy”.
Support / stretch: give a units checklist (N, m, J, kg, m/s) and a partly drawn bar chart. Stretch: find the speed water would reach after a 500 m fall and explain why the turbine water leaves slowly.