
plan and carry out an electromagnet and compass investigation, calculate the magnetic field of a wire and a coil, evaluate my data, and argue from controlled evidence that an electric current produces a magnetic field.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A compass sits on the table next to a battery and a coil of wire. Before anything is connected, which way does it point? Write what would convince you that the coil, not the battery, moved the needle.
A straight wire runs north-south just above a compass. What happens to the needle when a current flows north through the wire?
The claim to argue. In 1820 Hans Christian Oersted noticed that a compass needle swung when a nearby wire carried current. The claim you will defend with your own evidence (HS-PS2-5): an electric current produces a magnetic field. Every motor, speaker, hard-drive head and wind-turbine generator depends on it.
Magnetic fields. A magnetic field is the region around a magnet or a current where another magnet or moving charge feels a force. We draw it with field lines that run from a magnet’s north pole to its south pole outside the magnet; a compass needle lines up along them. Field strength is measured in teslas (T). Earth’s field at the surface is roughly 25 to 65 μT depending on location (NOAA’s World Magnetic Model maps it), about 50 μT at middle latitudes.
The field of a straight wire. Field lines around a long straight wire are circles centered on the wire. The right-hand rule: point your right thumb along the current; your fingers curl the way the field circles. The field strength falls off with distance: B = μ0I/(2πr), with μ0 = 4π × 10−7 T·m/A. Worked example: 2.0 A, 1.0 cm from the wire, gives B = (4π × 10−7)(2.0)/(2π × 0.010) = 4.00 × 10−5 T = 40 μT. That is comparable to Earth’s field, which is why a compass near a current-carrying wire swings noticeably.
Coils multiply the effect. Wind the wire into a coil (a solenoid) and the fields of all the loops add up inside it. For a long coil, B = μ0nI, where n is turns per meter. Worked example: 200 turns on a 5.0 cm length (n = 4,000 turns/m) carrying 1.0 A gives B = (4π × 10−7)(4,000)(1.0) = 5.03 mT, about 100 times Earth’s field. Put an iron nail inside and the iron’s atomic magnets line up with the coil’s field, multiplying it hundreds of times more: an electromagnet. Unlike a permanent magnet, it switches off when the current stops.
Evidence from an electromagnet (illustrative).
| Turns of wire | 10 | 20 | 30 | 40 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paper clips lifted, 1 cell | 2 | 5 | 7 | 10 |
| Paper clips lifted, 2 cells | 5 | 9 | 14 | 19 |
Both rows rise roughly in proportion to the number of turns (best-fit slopes through the origin: 0.24 and 0.47 clips per turn), and doubling the cells roughly doubles the clips. Paper-clip counts are a coarse measure: a clip either hangs or it does not, so each count is uncertain by about ±1 clip.
Building an argument that rules out alternatives. A skeptic could say: “The nail was magnetic anyway,” or “Batteries are magnetic.” Controls answer them. With the circuit open, the same nail lifts no clips. A compass beside a straight wire swings only while current flows, and reversing the battery reverses the swing. A coil with no nail still deflects a compass. The only thing that changed in every case was the current. That is how an argument from evidence isolates a cause (CCC.2).
Misconceptions. (1) “Electricity and magnetism are separate forces.” A current makes a magnetic field, and (lesson 3.05) a changing magnetic field makes a current. (2) “Only iron makes magnetic fields.” Any current does; iron concentrates the field. (3) “More turns always means more clips.” Beyond some point the iron saturates and the extra wire adds resistance, lowering the current.
Planning the investigation (HS-PS2-5). A strong plan names five things before any wire is wound. (1) The circuit and source: a 1.5 V cell, a push switch, the coil and, in a refined plan, a 1 Ω power resistor in series to limit the current to about 1 A. (2) The wire’s shape and orientation: a straight section running north-south over the compass, then a coil around the nail. (3) How you will show current is flowing: an ammeter in series, read briefly. (4) How you will detect the field, with which detector and where: a compass under the straight wire, paper clips at the nail tip, or a phone magnetometer app held at a marked spot 5 cm from the coil. (5) Who does what: whether you work alone or as a team, and who switches, reads and records.
Accuracy, precision and refining the plan. Clip counts are precise only to about ±1 clip and cannot show a field too weak to hold one clip. A phone magnetometer reads in microtesla. Sample readings for the coil, with the phone fixed 5 cm away (illustrative): background 48 μT; with 0.25, 0.50, 0.75 and 1.00 A the field rises by 30, 61, 89 and 122 μT. The increase is close to proportional to the current, which matches B = μ0nI, and it falls back to 48 μT when the switch opens. Subtracting the background, measuring current with an ammeter rather than counting cells, and repeating each reading three times are refinements that make the evidence stronger.
Question. Does a current in a wire produce a magnetic field, and how does the field of a coil depend on the number of turns and the current?
Materials.
Procedure.
Data table.
| Turns of wire | 10 | 20 | 30 | 40 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paper clips lifted, 1 cell | 2 | 5 | 7 | 10 |
| Paper clips lifted, 2 cells | 5 | 9 | 14 | 19 |
| Illustrative data; record three trials per row and the compass observations with the circuit open, closed and reversed. | ||||
Analysis.
Other routes to the same data. Choose one. All three earn full credit and end in the same claim-evidence-reasoning argument. Option A — build the electromagnet. The procedure above. A phone magnetometer app held at a fixed distance can replace the clip count with a reading in microtesla. Option B — the sample data in the table above. No equipment needed. Use these constructed compass observations as well: circuit open, needle points north; closed, needle swings about 35° east; battery reversed, about 35° west; bare nail, no clips lifted. Graph clips against turns for both rows and answer every analysis question. Option C — PhET Magnets and Electromagnets. On the Electromagnet screen, record the field meter reading for 1 to 4 loops and for several battery voltages, and watch the compass as you reverse the battery. Cite the sim and the date you used it.
Use the sample data and the plan checklist.
Argue from your evidence, then refine your plan.
Record a 2-minute argument (or write 200-250 words) for the claim "An electric current produces a magnetic field." Use at least three pieces of your own evidence, including a control, explain the reasoning, and answer the counterclaim "The battery itself is magnetic." Then respond to one classmate by supporting, qualifying or challenging their argument. A written post earns equal credit.
Write your investigation plan as you would run it again: the circuit and source, the wire's shape and orientation, how you will show current flows, which field detector you will use and where, whether you will work alone or as a team, and two refinements that would make your data more accurate or precise. Then judge whether your first data set was enough evidence for the claim, and why.
A current makes a magnetic field: our controls rule out the nail and the battery. Next lesson flips the question: can a magnetic field make a current?
Exit ticket: name the single control that most convinced you, and say what alternative explanation it rules out.
How confident are you that you can I can plan an investigation, measure a current and a magnetic field, and argue from controlled evidence that a current produces a field.
Materials: see the lab list; 1 Ω 5 W resistors and ammeters for the refined plan; phones with a magnetometer app are optional. Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 20, and OpenStax College Physics 2e, chapter 22 (CC BY 4.0). Earth’s field values from NOAA’s World Magnetic Model (public domain).
Timing: Poly ran this lab over two sessions. Run the Oersted test, controls and turns data in period one; the argument and plan revision in period two.
Listen for: “the battery is magnetic”; claims with no control; treating clip counts as exact.
Support / stretch: give the five-part plan checklist as a table. Stretch: use the magnetometer data to estimate μ0n for the coil and compare with the turns you wound.