
revise my energy model of the pumped-storage system to show both visible and particle-scale energy, write a claim-evidence-reasoning about conservation, and brainstorm converter designs from the science.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Open your bar charts from 1.01. Circle every bar labeled “thermal”. In one sentence, what is that energy, at the particle scale?
Which pair are BOTH forms of energy at the particle scale?
From three labs to one model. In 1.01 we tracked a pumped-storage day with bar charts. In 1.03 and 1.04 we measured losses on a ramp and a rubber band. In 1.05 we built a computational model. Today we pull these together into one two-scale model, then use it to generate design ideas.
The two-scale rule. At the visible (macroscopic) scale, energy shows up as motion (kinetic), position in a field (gravitational, elastic, electric), sound, light and thermal energy. At the particle scale, all of it reduces to two kinds: the kinetic energy of particles and the energy stored in fields between them. Thermal energy is both kinds at once, random and spread out.
Worked example 1: revising the pumped-storage model. Mei’s first model had four boxes: grid, pump, upper reservoir, turbine. Her revision adds two zoomed-in circles. Circle 1, inside the pump motor’s copper wire: electrons pushed by an electric field, colliding with vibrating copper atoms, which vibrate harder (thermal energy). Circle 2, at the turbine blades: water molecules moving together (ordered kinetic energy) hit the blades, and some of their motion becomes random jostling (thermal energy in the water). She labeled every arrow with sample values from the 87% and 86% efficiencies, so 100 units in = 74.8 out + 25.2 thermal.
Worked example 2: a CER on conservation. Claim: in the rubber-band launch, energy was conserved. Evidence: the band stored 0.6975 J (area under the F-x curve); the cart received 0.2704 J; the band was measurably warmer after quick stretches. Reasoning: 0.4271 J did not disappear; it became random motion of the rubber’s chain molecules (thermal energy), plus sound and vibration. Because the total of all forms stays 0.6975 J, conservation holds. A limitation: we did not measure the thermal energy directly, so this part of the account is inferred.
Worked example 3: from the model to design ideas. Diego asked: where does the model say most energy is lost? In the band, internal friction between chains; on the ramp, spin and rolling friction; in the lifter, axle friction and the landing speed of the falling mass. Each loss is a design lever: a band that is stretched less far, wheels that are light, a bearing that turns smoothly, a falling mass that lands slowly.
Ideate: rules for a design brainstorm. Quantity first, judge later; build on each other’s ideas (“yes, and”); every idea names the loss it targets. Aim for at least eight ideas per team before you sort them.
| Idea | Device option | Which loss it targets | Science reason it should help | Cost / risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||
| 2 | ||||
| 3 | ||||
| 4 | ||||
| 5 | ||||
| 6 | ||||
| 7 | ||||
| 8 |
Revise your model with your team, then check it with these cards.
Write the CER and run the brainstorm.
CER: Is energy conserved in a pumped-storage round trip that returns 74.8%? Use evidence from 1.01 and your own lab data from 1.03 or 1.04. In your reasoning, explain the losses at the particle scale and name one limitation of your evidence. Sentence starters: “I claim that…”, “My data show…”, “This is because, at the particle scale…”.
Ideate: list at least eight converter ideas in the table. Star the three your team will carry into the decision matrix next lesson, and say which loss each targets.
Our model now works at two scales and points to the losses we can design against. Next phase we build.
Exit ticket: which loss do you predict will be the biggest in your team's device, and what evidence supports your prediction?
How confident are you that you can I can model energy at the macroscopic and particle scales and use the model to explain where energy goes.
Materials: models and data from 1.01–1.05, chart paper, sticky notes for the brainstorm, brainstorm table copies.
Setup: model revision in teams (15 min), CER individually (15 min), brainstorm in teams (10 min). The 87% and 86% values are illustrative, as in 1.01.
Listen for: “heat particles”; temperature used as if it were energy; ideas that do not name a loss.
Support / stretch: give a partly drawn two-scale template with zoom circles. Stretch: estimate the temperature rise of a 30 g band that absorbs 0.43 J, using a specific heat of about 2,000 J/(kg·K) as an illustrative value.