
measure the specific heat of a metal with a foam-cup calorimeter, compare it with the accepted value, and explain the size and direction of experimental error.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Our carrier will use ice and water to stay cold. Before the lab: if you drop hot metal into cool water in a foam cup, what two things must you measure to know how much energy the water gained?
You drop 300 g of steel at 88 °C into 200 g of water at 21 °C. Where will the final temperature land?
The idea. If a hot object and a cool object are sealed together in an insulated container, energy leaves the hot one and enters the cool one until they reach the same temperature (thermal equilibrium). If no energy escapes, the energy lost by the hot object equals the energy gained by the cool one. This is the method of mixtures, and it lets you measure the specific heat of a metal with a foam cup and a thermometer.
The equation. For a metal sample (mass mm, starting temperature Tm) dropped into water (mass mw, starting temperature Tw) that settles at Tf:
mmcm(Tm − Tf) = mwcw(Tf − Tw)
Both sides are written as positive quantities: energy lost equals energy gained. Solving for the unknown: cm = mwcw(Tf − Tw) / [mm(Tm − Tf)].
Worked example (illustrative data). A 300 g bundle of steel bolts is heated in teacher-poured kettle water to 88.0 °C, then moved quickly into 200 g of water at 21.0 °C in a foam-cup calorimeter. The mixture settles at 30.0 °C.
Predicting before measuring. Use the accepted value to predict the final temperature first: Tf = (mmcmTm + mwcwTw)/(mmcm + mwcw) = 30.34 °C. The measured 30.0 °C is lower, which is what you expect if some energy escaped: the bolts cooled in the air while being moved, and the cup and thermometer absorbed a little.
Why the result is so sensitive. The water only warmed by 9.0 K. A thermometer error of just ±0.1 °C on Tf moves the answer from 427 to 439 J/(kg·K), a spread of about ±1%. That is why you stir, read the highest steady temperature, use a large mass of metal and a small mass of water, and repeat the trial.
Direction of errors. Energy lost to the surroundings makes Tf too low and your c too low. Hot water clinging to the metal carries extra energy into the cup and makes c too high. Deciding which effect dominated is part of your analysis.
Misconception check. The metal and water end at the same temperature, but they do not change temperature by the same amount: water’s large specific heat means it changes far less for the same energy.
Question. What is the specific heat capacity of aluminum, steel or copper hardware, measured by mixing hot metal with cool water, and how close does it come to the accepted value?
Materials.
Procedure.
Data table.
| Trial | Metal | mm (kg) | Tm (°C) | mw (kg) | Tw (°C) | Predicted Tf (°C) | Measured Tf (°C) | c (J/(kg·K)) | % difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Illustrative | steel | 0.300 | 88.0 | 0.200 | 21.0 | 30.3 | 30.0 | 433 | -4.2% |
| Illustrative | aluminum | 0.150 | 87.5 | 0.200 | 21.0 | 30.2 | 30.5 | 930 | +3.4% |
| 1 | |||||||||
| 2 |
Accepted values (OpenStax College Physics 2e, Table 14.1): aluminum 900, iron/steel 452, copper 387, water 4186 J/(kg·K). The two illustrative rows are not real measurements.
Analysis.
Other routes to the same data. Use the PhET Energy Forms and Changes simulation (Intro screen) to put an iron and a brick block on heaters and watch the energy chunks, then complete the analysis with the provided class data set from your teacher (masses and temperatures from last year’s trials) instead of your own measurements. A simulation does not replace the lab for credit when an in-person make-up session is possible.
Use the illustrative row first, then your own data.
Write the lab conclusion.
Write your lab conclusion (claim, evidence, reasoning) in 150-200 words. Include your percent difference, your ±0.1 °C uncertainty range, and the one error source you think mattered most, with the direction it pushed your result.
Show with your own numbers that the energy lost by the metal is about equal to the energy gained by the water. Explain why the two are not exactly equal, and what that tells you about the system's boundary.
Energy lost by the hot object equals energy gained by the cold one, as long as the system is closed. Next: why it always flows that way.
Exit ticket: name one source of error in today's lab and the direction it pushes the measured specific heat.
How confident are you that you can I can measure a metal's specific heat by the method of mixtures and explain the size and direction of my errors.
Materials: see the lab list. Only the teacher pours from the kettle.
Timing: Poly ran this lab over two 50-minute periods. Run one trial per team and pool class data, or let this lesson span two periods.
Listen for: both sides of the equation written with signs that cancel; reading Tf before it settles; “the water and metal changed by the same number of degrees”.
Support / stretch: give a worked template with the illustrative row. Stretch: include the cup’s own heat capacity in the energy balance.