
Wind to Wire: Connecting a Ridge-Top Wind Farm to Town
How can we use a simulation to design a link that carries a wind farm’s energy to a town with the least waste and the fewest harms, and explain the physics of every step from wind to outlet?
The mystery: During a dry offshore wind event, reaching for a doorknob gives a sharp spark, while on a ridge nearby the same wind turns turbines that send electricity to a town 40 km away. How do charges and magnets push on each other without touching, and how does moving air become current in a distant outlet?
use Coulomb’s law with vector addition to predict the force between charges, and compare electric and gravitational forces between the same two objects.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Describe a time you got a shock from a doorknob, a car door or a sweater. What was the weather like? Write two sentences, then make the prediction below before we peel any tape.
Two T strips of tape are peeled the same way and hung near each other. What will they do?
The phenomenon. During a dry offshore wind event, when warm, very dry air pours down from the mountains toward the coast, you walk across a carpet, reach for a doorknob and feel a snap. On a ridge a few kilometers away, rows of wind turbines turn the motion of the same air into electricity for a town 40 km down the valley. The two scenes share one idea: electric charges push and pull on each other without touching, and moving charges and magnets are linked. This unit builds the model that explains both, starting with the force between charges.
Charge. Matter is made of protons (charge +e), electrons (charge −e) and neutrons (no charge), where e = 1.602 × 10−19 C. Charge is conserved: rubbing a balloon on hair does not create charge, it moves electrons from one object to the other. Charge is also quantized: every object carries a whole number of electron charges. A balloon with −50 nC of charge carries 3.12 × 1011 extra electrons. Dry air matters because humid air leaves a thin film of water on surfaces that lets charge leak away, so on a very dry day charge builds up on you instead of draining off.
Three ways to charge. By friction, two different materials touch and electrons move to the one that holds them more tightly. By conduction, a charged object touches a neutral conductor and shares its charge. By induction, a charged object is brought near a conductor without touching; the conductor’s mobile electrons shift, and if the far side is grounded and then disconnected, the conductor keeps a charge opposite to the charged object. Insulators cannot share charge freely, but their molecules polarize, which is why a charged balloon picks up neutral bits of paper.
Coulomb’s law. The size of the force between two point charges is
F = k|q1q2| / r2, k = 8.99 × 109 N·m2/C2
Like charges repel and unlike charges attract; the force acts along the line joining them. It is an inverse-square law: double the distance and the force falls to one quarter.
Worked example 1 (illustrative charges). Two rubbed balloons each carry −50 nC and their centers are 0.10 m apart. F = (8.99 × 109)(50 × 10−9)2 / (0.10)2 = 2.25 × 10−3 N, a repulsion. A 3.0 g balloon weighs (0.0030)(9.8) = 0.0294 N, so the electric push is about 8% of its weight: enough to see the balloons swing apart.
Worked example 2: electric versus gravitational. In a hydrogen atom the electron and proton are about 5.29 × 10−11 m apart. The electric attraction is ke2/r2 = 8.24 × 10−8 N. The gravitational attraction is Gmemp/r2 = 3.63 × 10−47 N. The ratio is about 2.3 × 1039. Both are inverse-square laws, so the ratio does not depend on distance. Gravity dominates planets only because large objects are almost exactly neutral, while mass has no negative version to cancel it.
Worked example 3: adding forces as vectors. Forces from several charges add as vectors, not as plain numbers. A +1.0 μC charge sits at the origin. Charge A (+2.0 μC) is 0.30 m above it and charge B (−3.0 μC) is 0.40 m to its right.
FA = (8.99 × 109)(1.0 × 10−6)(2.0 × 10−6)/(0.30)2 = 0.200 N, pointing straight down (A repels). FB = (8.99 × 109)(1.0 × 10−6)(3.0 × 10−6)/(0.40)2 = 0.169 N, pointing right (B attracts). The components are perpendicular, so Fnet = √(0.1692 + 0.2002) = 0.261 N at tan−1(0.200/0.169) = 49.8° below the +x direction.
Gravity in the same form. Newton’s law of gravitation has the same inverse-square shape: Fg = −Gm1m2/d2, with G = 6.674 × 10−11 N·m2/kg2. The minus sign is a bookkeeping convention: masses are always positive, so the product is always positive and the minus sign marks the force as always attractive. In Coulomb’s law written with signs, Fe = kq1q2/d2, a positive result (like charges) means repulsion and a negative result (unlike charges) means attraction. Two 1.0 kg masses 1.0 m apart attract with only 6.67 × 10−11 N. Two protons attract gravitationally but repel electrically 1.24 × 1036 times harder, at any distance.
Common misconceptions. (1) “The bigger charge pushes harder on the smaller one.” No: by Newton’s third law the two forces are equal in size and opposite in direction. (2) “Use the sign of the charges in F = kq1q2/r2 to get the direction.” Use magnitudes for the size and decide direction from like/unlike, then draw it. (3) “Neutral objects feel no electric force.” A neutral object can be attracted after it polarizes. (4) Forgetting to square r, or leaving microcoulombs and centimeters unconverted.
Question. How many kinds of charge does peeled tape carry, and how do charged and neutral objects interact?
Materials.
Procedure.
Data table.
| Pair brought together | Attract / repel / none | Distance when motion first seen (cm) |
|---|---|---|
| T and T | ||
| B and B | ||
| T and B | ||
| T and paper bits | ||
| B and paper bits | ||
| T and finger |
Analysis.
Other routes to the same data. Choose one. All three earn full credit and answer the same analysis questions. Option A — sticky tape. The procedure above. Option B — the sample observations. No equipment and no internet needed. Use this constructed set: T and T repelled from about 6 cm; B and B repelled from about 5 cm; T and B attracted from about 8 cm; both T and B attracted paper bits from about 2 cm and attracted a finger from about 3 cm. Answer every analysis question from these rows, and explain why the T-B attraction is felt from farther away than T-T repulsion in this sample. Option C — PhET Balloons and Static Electricity. Rub the balloon on the sweater, record what happens as it approaches the wall and the second balloon, count the charges moved, and answer the same questions. Cite the sim and the date you used it.
Work in pairs. Convert μC, nC and cm to SI units before you calculate.
Start your Grid Notebook for this unit.
Two rubbed balloons hang from threads. (a) Define the two-object system and say which force acts between them and why. (b) Each carries −50 nC and their centers are 0.10 m apart: calculate the force and say whether it attracts or repels. (c) Each balloon has a mass of 3.0 g. Calculate the gravitational force between them and the ratio of electric to gravitational force. (d) Explain why that ratio would stay the same if they hung twice as far apart.
Write three questions for the unit Wonder Board: one about the doorknob spark, one about the ridge-top wind farm, and one about how they might be connected.
Charges interact through an inverse-square force much stronger than gravity, and it can push or pull. Next lesson we meet our client and the wind farm.
Exit ticket: why does gravity, not the electric force, hold the Moon in orbit, even though the electric force is about 1036 times stronger between two protons?
How confident are you that you can I can use Coulomb's law with vector addition and compare electric and gravitational forces.
Materials: matte tape, combs, paper bits, latex-free balloons, goggles. Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 18, and OpenStax College Physics 2e, chapter 18 (CC BY 4.0). Constants from NIST CODATA (public domain).
Timing: Poly ran this launch over two sessions. In one 50-minute period, run the tape lab and worked examples 1 and 2; assign the vector sum as homework, or let the lesson span two periods.
Setup: the phenomenon is generic: any dry, windy day and any wind farm photo work. On humid days the tape effect weakens; run Option B or C.
Listen for: “the bigger charge pushes harder”; using signs to set direction on a diagram; unconverted μC and cm.
Support / stretch: give a unit-conversion card (1 μC = 10−6 C, 1 nC = 10−9 C). Stretch: find where on the line between two charges the net force on a third charge is zero.