
argue from mixing data that thermal energy flows from hot to cold toward a uniform distribution, explain entropy at a conceptual level, and use 1 − Tc/Th to show why no engine is 100% efficient.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A glass of iced water sits in a warm room. Describe what happens to the ice, the water and the room air over an hour. Has anyone ever seen the reverse happen on its own?
You pool every team's mixing data from 2.03. In how many trials do you expect the metal to have ended WARMER than it started?
A pattern you have never seen broken. Pour 0.20 kg of water at 80 °C into 0.20 kg of water at 20 °C and you get 0.40 kg at 50 °C. The hot water lost 25,116 J and the cold water gained the same 25,116 J, so energy was conserved. But nobody has ever watched a cup of 50 °C water separate on its own into a hot half and a cold half. That would also conserve energy. Something beyond energy conservation decides the direction. In your mixing lab the same thing happened: the metal always cooled and the water always warmed, never the other way.
The second law of thermodynamics. In words: thermal energy flows spontaneously from a hotter object to a colder one, never the reverse, and an isolated system moves toward a more uniform distribution of energy. This is the claim of HS-PS3-4, and your mixing data are evidence for it: in every trial the temperatures converged.
Why, at the particle level. When fast (hot) and slow (cold) particles collide, energy is shared randomly. There are vastly more ways to share energy evenly among trillions of trillions of particles than to keep it concentrated, so random collisions almost certainly spread it out. Entropy is a measure of how many microscopic arrangements match what we observe; the second law says the total entropy of an isolated system does not decrease. For a transfer of heat Q at absolute temperature T, the entropy change is Q/T. Worked example: 1000 J flows from an object at 350 K to one at 300 K. The hot object loses 1000/350 = 2.857 J/K; the cold one gains 1000/300 = 3.333 J/K. The total change is +0.476 J/K. Reverse the flow and the total would be negative, which the second law forbids.
Heat engines. A heat engine (a car engine, a steam turbine, a geothermal plant) takes in heat Qh from a hot source, does work W, and must reject heat Qc to a cold sink: W = Qh − Qc. Efficiency is e = W/Qh. In the diagram, e = 250/1000 = 25%.
No engine is 100% efficient. If an engine turned all of Qh into work with nothing rejected, entropy would leave the hot source and none would arrive anywhere else, so total entropy would fall. The best any engine can do between absolute temperatures Th and Tc is the Carnot efficiency:
emax = 1 − Tc/Th (temperatures in kelvin)
Worked example 1: between 800 K and 300 K, emax = 1 − 300/800 = 0.625, or 62.5%. Real engines reach well under their Carnot limit because of friction and non-ideal cycles. Worked example 2: a geothermal power plant generates electricity from steam that rises from hot rock underground. With illustrative temperatures of 200 °C for the steam and 40 °C for the cooling water, Th = 473.15 K, Tc = 313.15 K and emax = 1 − 313.15/473.15 = 33.8%. Low-temperature sources have low limits, whatever the engineering.
Common mistakes. Using Celsius in the Carnot formula (1 − 40/200 = 80% is wrong). Treating “energy is conserved” as the same claim as “heat flows hot to cold”; they are two different laws. Thinking a refrigerator breaks the second law: it moves heat from cold to hot only because work is done on it, and it dumps even more heat out the back than it removes from inside.
Arguing from evidence. In this lab you make a claim about the direction of heat flow using your own mixing data and the class’s pooled data, answer a counterclaim, and support or rebut classmates’ arguments. A strong argument cites specific temperatures, names the system and its surroundings, and explains why energy conservation alone cannot decide the direction.
Use your own and the pooled mixing data.
Make and defend your argument.
Argument from evidence (recorded 2-minute talk or written post of about 250 words; equal credit). Claim: in an isolated system, thermal energy moves toward a more uniform distribution. Use at least three temperature readings from your lab or the pooled class data as evidence, explain the reasoning at the particle level, and answer this counterclaim: “Energy conservation already explains the mixing result, so no second law is needed.” Then respond to two classmates, one supporting and one challenging.
Energy is conserved, and it spreads out. Those two laws together explain why our carrier can only slow the warming, never stop it.
Exit ticket: in our Cool Carrier, which way does thermal energy flow, and what can the design change about it: the direction or the rate?
How confident are you that you can I can argue from mixing data that heat flows from hot to cold toward uniform temperature, and explain why no heat engine can be 100% efficient.
Materials: pooled class data from 2.03 on the board or a shared sheet, discussion protocol cards.
Setup: argument drafting 20 min, peer responses 15 min. Recorded and written arguments earn equal credit. The geothermal temperatures are illustrative.
Listen for: Celsius in the Carnot formula; “cold moves”; conservation and the second law treated as the same claim.
Support / stretch: give a claim-evidence-reasoning-rebuttal frame. Stretch: compute the Carnot limit for a heat engine running between the lamp box (38 °C) and ice water (0 °C) and comment on why nobody runs one.