
design, build and refine a device that converts one form of energy into another within constraints, measure its efficiency across iterations, and justify my design choices with data and trade-offs.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Write your version 3 efficiency and its spread from your iteration log. Does it meet criterion (1)? Criterion (2)?
If version 2 of a car averages 44% efficiency and version 1 averaged 40%, but each version's three trials spread over ±6%, the data show version 2 is better.
Today you present to the client. Your team built and tested versions 1 and 2 in lessons 1.07 and 1.08. Today you run the final trials of version 3, finish the design report, and defend your converter to the visitor-center staff (your teacher, visitors or a recorded panel). The challenge below is the brief your work answers.
Class criteria and constraints for the exhibit converter (set in 1.02, ranked in 1.07). Criteria: (1) the final version reaches a mean efficiency of at least 50% over three trials; (2) its three trials agree within ±5 percentage points; (3) it runs 10 times in a row without repair, because visitors will use it all day. Constraints: input energy no more than 10 J (a falling mass of at most 1.0 kg dropped at most 1.0 m, or a band stretched at most 25 cm); it fits a 60 cm × 40 cm table space; class-kit or household materials only, costing at most 10 sample budget points; two build periods.
The design challenge (HS-PS3-3). Design, build and refine a device that converts one form of energy into another within given constraints, and measure how well it does it. Choose one:
Worked example, Option A (illustrative numbers). A 1.00 kg mass falls 0.80 m: input energy mgh = (1.00)(9.8)(0.80) = 7.84 J. It lifts a 0.50 kg load 1.00 m: useful output (0.50)(9.8)(1.00) = 4.90 J. Efficiency = 4.90/7.84 = 62.5%. The rest went to friction in the axle, the kinetic energy of the falling mass when it lands, and the stretch of the string.
Worked example, Option B (illustrative numbers). The band stores 1.8 J (measured from its force-stretch graph, as in lesson 1.04). The 0.25 kg car leaves at 2.4 m/s: ½(0.25)(2.4)2 = 0.72 J, an efficiency of 40%. It then coasts 4.1 m to a stop, so the average resisting force was 0.72 J/4.1 m = 0.176 N. After the team replaced a rubbing axle with a straw bearing and added a larger drive wheel, the car left at 2.9 m/s: 1.051 J, or 58%. That is iteration with evidence: change one thing, measure, compare.
Criteria and constraints. Class criteria might include efficiency, distance traveled or load lifted, repeatability across three trials, and cost. Constraints might include a mass limit, a maximum size, only recycled or everyday household materials, and a build-time limit. Rank the criteria: if efficiency matters most, a heavier but smoother axle may be worth it.
Break the device into parts. Every energy converter has a source (the falling mass, the band), a transfer path (spool, axle, wheels) and an output (the lifted load, the moving car). Draw an energy-flow diagram with arrows for the useful path and for each loss. Test and improve the part with the biggest loss first.
Measuring well. Measure input energy directly (height and mass, or the area under the band’s F-x graph). Measure output energy with the methods from lesson 1.03 (video timing for speed, a meter stick for lifted height). Run three trials of every version and report the mean and spread. Two versions are only different if their difference is bigger than the spread.
Trade-offs. A wider drive wheel may raise speed but add mass. A stronger band stores more energy but may snap. State the trade-offs you accepted and why, using your ranked criteria.
Rehearse your defense with these checks.
Finish and submit Stage 3 and Stage 4 of the task below.
Final report paragraph: using your iteration log, explain which change raised efficiency the most, what it cost you against the other criteria, and where the remaining lost energy goes at the particle level.
Task: Design, build and refine a device that converts one form of energy into another within the class constraints (Option A falling-mass lifter, Option B rubber-band car or Option C rubber-band launcher; all three are described in the lesson and earn equal credit). Measure the input and useful output energy for at least three versions, with three trials each, and compute the efficiency of each version with its spread. Your report must include ranked criteria and constraints, a labeled sketch and an energy-flow diagram showing the useful path and every loss, an iteration log (what you changed, why and what happened), a graph or table comparing versions, a particle-level explanation of where the lost energy went, and a trade-off discussion. Wear safety goggles whenever bands are stretched or masses are dropped, and keep falling masses over a soft landing.
Choose where your measurements come from. All three earn full credit and are the same difficulty.
Route 1 — build and measure. Your own device, at least three versions, three trials each.
Route 2 — the illustrative data set in this lesson. No materials needed. A falling-mass lifter was run three times per version; on every run a 1.00 kg mass fell 0.80 m, so the input energy was mgh = (1.00)(9.8)(0.80) = 7.84 J, and the useful output was a 0.50 kg load lifted the height shown. These are constructed teaching numbers, not real measurements.
| Version | What changed | Load lifted, trials 1-3 (cm) | Output energy, trials 1-3 (J) | Mean output (J) | Efficiency |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | As first built: wooden axle turning in a hole punched in cardboard | 88.0, 92.9, 90.0 | 4.31, 4.55, 4.41 | 4.42 | 56.4% |
| 2 | Drinking-straw bearings added at both ends of the axle | 100.0, 103.1, 99.0 | 4.90, 5.05, 4.85 | 4.93 | 62.9% |
| 3 | Spool diameter doubled, string rewound in a single layer | 111.0, 114.3, 108.2 | 5.44, 5.60, 5.30 | 5.45 | 69.5% |
Treat these as your three versions. Recompute every output energy and efficiency yourself (output = 0.50 × 9.8 × height in meters), work out each version’s spread as a percentage of 7.84 J, and use the true-or-false check in this lesson to decide whether each change really improved the device. Then write the iteration log from the ‘what changed’ column, explain at the particle level where the missing energy went, and recommend a design with its trade-offs.
Route 3 — PhET Energy Skate Park as the converter. The PhET simulation is at phet.colorado.edu/sims/html/energy-skate-park/latest/energy-skate-park_all.html. On the Intro screen, turn on the bar graph and speedometer. Your device is the track: it converts gravitational energy into kinetic energy. Release the skater from 4.0 m at three friction settings you record, and each time take the speed at the bottom three times. Input is mgh (the sim gives the skater’s mass); useful output is ½mv2. Report the three efficiencies with their spreads, treat lowering friction as your refinement, and answer every part of the task from those numbers. Say clearly which real losses the sim models and which it does not. Cite the sim and the date you used it.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Design and refinement (HS-PS3-3) | Builds a working converter and improves it through at least three evidence-based iterations. |
| Energy measurement (HS-PS3-1, SEP.3) | Input and output energies correctly measured and calculated, with trials and spreads. |
| Trade-offs (HS-ETS1-3) | Ranked criteria and constraints guide decisions; trade-offs named and justified. |
| Energy explanation | Energy-flow diagram and particle-level account of where the losses went. |
| Data communication | Clear tables or graphs comparing versions, with units and uncertainty. |
| Defense | Explains the design and answers questions with reasoning from data. |
You turned measured efficiency into a design decision. Next lesson: the unit checkpoint. Then the 360° field trip.
Exit ticket: which Wonder Board question can you now answer with your own data? Write the question and your answer.
How confident are you that you can I can design, build and refine an energy converter and justify it with measured efficiency and trade-offs.
Materials: devices from 1.07–1.08, meter sticks, balances, phones for video, rubric copies for visitors.
Timing: Poly ran this task over four sessions plus build time. Here, planning and versions 1–2 happen in 1.07–1.08; this lesson is the final trials and the defense. Allow a second period if presentations run long.
Listen for: efficiencies above 100% (a measurement error to find); claims of improvement smaller than the spread; losses named without a particle-level explanation.
Support / stretch: students who cannot build may use Route 2 or 3 in the task for full credit. Stretch: estimate how the efficiency would change if the device were scaled up 10 times.