
explain how analog signals are digitized, compute bit rates, ask testable questions about digital systems, and argue from evidence about when digital transmission and storage are better and when they are not.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Name one thing you own that is stored digitally and one that is not. Which would you rather keep for 50 years, and why?
A station samples ground motion 100 times per second. A vibration at 70 Hz is recorded. What does the digital record most likely show?
The question. An earthquake early-warning system only works because the information from a seismic station reaches a processing center, and then your phone, fast and without errors. Every step uses digital signals. Why digital, and what are the trade-offs?
Analog and digital. An analog signal is a continuously varying quantity, such as a voltage that rises and falls exactly as the ground moves. A digital signal represents the same information as a sequence of numbers, each stored as bits (0s and 1s). To digitize, a device samples the analog signal at regular times and quantizes each sample to the nearest of 2b levels, where b is the number of bits per sample.
Worked example 1: sampling and bit rate. Bit rate = sample rate × bits per sample × channels. CD audio uses 44,100 samples/s, 16 bits and 2 channels: 44,100 × 16 × 2 = 1,411,200 bits/s. One minute is 1,411,200 × 60 / 8 = 10.58 million bytes. Sixteen bits give 216 = 65,536 levels. A seismic station (typical figures, labeled illustrative) might record 100 samples/s with 24 bits on 3 channels (up-down, north-south, east-west): 100 × 24 × 3 = 7,200 bits/s, about 77.8 million bytes a day.
How fast must you sample? You need at least two samples per cycle of the highest frequency you want to keep (the Nyquist rate). A telephone channel that keeps frequencies up to 4000 Hz needs at least 8,000 samples/s. Human hearing reaches about 20,000 Hz, which is why CD audio samples at 44,100 Hz. Sample too slowly and a fast wave masquerades as a slow one (aliasing).
Quantization error. With only 3 bits there are 8 levels; on a 0-1 V range each step is 0.125 V, so a reading can be off by up to half a step, 0.0625 V. Each extra bit halves the step. This is a design choice: more bits mean more accuracy but a higher bit rate.
Why digital wins on noise. Every cable, amplifier and radio link adds a little random noise. An analog signal cannot tell noise from signal, so noise piles up with each copy or relay stage. A digital receiver only has to decide “0 or 1” for each bit; as long as the noise is smaller than half the gap between the two levels, it rebuilds a perfect copy and sends it on clean. Error-detecting codes add check bits so that the rare wrong bit is caught and resent. That is why a digital copy of a copy is identical, while a cassette copy of a copy gets hiss.
Compression. Digital data can be compressed. Lossless compression (ZIP, FLAC) removes redundancy and restores every bit. Lossy compression (MP3, JPEG) throws away detail people are unlikely to notice: a 128 kbit/s MP3 is 11.0 times smaller than CD audio.
The costs of digital. Digitizing loses information between samples and between levels, compressed files can be damaged by a few wrong bits, stored formats become unreadable when software disappears, and all of it depends on power and networks. A good argument weighs these against the benefits.
Speed of delivery. Light in glass fiber (index about 1.47) travels at c/1.47 = 2.04 × 108 m/s, so a 500 km fiber path takes 2.45 ms. Compared with the tens of seconds an S wave needs, transmission is almost instant; the real delays are processing and the time networks take to push alerts to phones.
Misconceptions. “Digital means higher quality.” Not automatically: a low sample rate or few bits can sound worse than good analog. “Digital signals are not waves.” They travel as electromagnetic waves or light pulses; digital describes how information is coded, not what carries it.
Asking questions that can be tested. Arguments about digital systems go nowhere unless the question can be checked. “Is digital better?” cannot be tested as asked. “After 20 copies, does a digital audio file differ from the original by even one bit, and how much hiss does an analog tape copy add?” can: you can compare files bit by bit and measure the noise. A good question names the feature (copy fidelity, storage life, speed, privacy), a measurable outcome and a fair comparison.
Real-life connections. When you email homework, the file arrives as an exact copy because each packet carries check bits. When you copy music, every copy is identical, which is why one leaked file can spread worldwide. When you research online, billions of stored pages are instantly searchable, but some links go dead as sites close. When you post on social media, sharing is effortless, and so is copying your photo without permission. Each is a trade-off between the same features: reliable storage, easy transfer, rapid copying, easy deletion, theft risk and broad access.
Show every bit-rate step: samples per second × bits × channels.
Build your argument, then sharpen the questions.
Evaluate each claim with evidence and one calculation, then give a verdict (supported, partly supported, unsupported): (1) "Vinyl records are better than digital because digital throws information away." (2) “Earthquake alerts are slowed down mainly by the time radio waves take to travel.” (3) "Storing a family's photos only as digital files is safer than prints." Respond to one classmate's verdict that differs from yours. Live or recorded response for equal credit.
Rewrite one of the three claims as a testable question. Say what you would measure, what you would compare, and what result would count as evidence for and against the claim.
Digital wins on noise, copying and checking, and loses on dependence, deletion and theft. Next phase: what is light, the wave our link may ride on?
Exit ticket: name one digital advantage and one digital risk for the county's alert system, and a question that could test one of them.
How confident are you that you can I can compute bit rates and argue from evidence about when digital transmission and storage are better, and when they are not.
Materials: calculators; optional: an audio editor that shows sample rate and bit depth. Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter on electromagnetic waves and information (CC BY 4.0).
Setup: the seismic-station figures are illustrative, as the lesson says. Claims 1–3 work well as a three-corner debate.
Listen for: “digital signals are not waves”; “digital is always higher quality”; questions that cannot be tested.
Support / stretch: give a bit-rate formula card. Stretch: compute how many 16-bit alert codes a 2 bit/s link could send in one hour, with parity.