
use a circuit simulation to model the impact of proposed transmission designs on the energy delivered from a wind farm, evaluate them against weighted criteria and trade-offs, and explain the physics of generation, transformation and loss.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Write your version 2 design in one sentence and its delivered fraction, full-scale loss and matrix total from your design log. Which criterion is it weakest on?
Raising the transmission voltage ten times, for the same delivered power, cuts the line's I2R loss ten times.
Today you present to the commission. Your team modeled the link, tested competing designs and built version 2 in lessons 3.07 and 3.08. Today you finish the design report and defend your recommendation to the county planning commission (your teacher, invited guests or a recorded panel). The brief below is the problem your work answers.
Class criteria and constraints for the wind-to-town link (set in 3.02, weighted in 3.07). Criteria: (1) on our classroom-scale model (a 12 V AC source, a 10 Ω line and a 10 Ω town load) the design delivers at least 95% of the energy sent; (2) at full scale (100 MW over a 40 km line with 10 Ω of resistance) the line loses no more than 2% of the power; (3) low land and wildlife impact; (4) low wildfire and safety risk in high winds. Constraints: a budget of at most 12 sample budget points; the source voltage and the town’s load are fixed; transformer pairs come only in ratios of 1:5, 1:10 and 1:20; every number must be labeled as sourced or illustrative; two build periods.
The engineering problem. Good wind sites are usually ridges, passes and open plains, often far from the towns that use the electricity. Our client, the county planning commission, must decide how a new ridge-top wind farm will connect to a town 40 km down the valley. Your team will model a transmission link from a wind farm to a town, test proposed solutions in a circuit simulator (HS-ETS1-4), and recommend a design that balances energy losses against cost and other criteria (HS-ETS1-3).
A classroom-scale model in Falstad. The Falstad circuit simulator (a free web app) lets you build AC circuits with transformers and read currents, voltages and power. Scale model (illustrative): a 12 V AC source is the wind farm, a 10 Ω resistor is the long line, and a 10 Ω resistor is the town.
Same line, same town, but raising the transmission voltage by 10 cut the line current by about 5 and the fraction lost from 50% to 1.0%. In the full-scale version from lesson 3.05, 500 kV instead of 115 kV cut losses from 7.6% to 0.4% of 100 MW.
Proposed solutions to test. Each changes one thing: (1) a higher transmission voltage; (2) a thicker conductor (lower R, but heavier and costlier towers); (3) a shorter route (lower R, but crossing more sensitive land); (4) local battery storage at the town that smooths demand, lowering the peak current. Model each by changing the matching element in the simulator and record the delivered fraction.
Criteria and constraints. Criteria: fraction of energy delivered, reliability, cost, land and wildlife impact, and wildfire risk from lines in high winds. Constraints: budget, available right-of-way, and safety clearances that grow with voltage. Higher voltage cuts losses but needs taller towers, bigger insulators and wider clearances. A weighted decision matrix makes those trade-offs explicit. Be honest about what the model leaves out: real lines also have reactance, transformers are not ideal, and the numbers here are illustrative.
What the physics must show. Your report explains, with fields, how the turbine’s generator converts kinetic energy to electrical energy (Faraday’s law), how transformers change voltage, and why I2R makes high voltage efficient.
Rehearse your defense with these checks.
Finish and submit Stage 3 and Stage 4 of the task below.
Final report paragraph: explain, from wind to outlet, how energy moves through fields in the generator and transformers, why your design cuts the I2R loss, and one way your recommendation could harm the people or land it serves, with how you would reduce that harm.
Task: Recommend a transmission design to carry energy from a ridge-top wind farm to a town 40 km away. Model a baseline link and at least three proposed solutions (for example a higher transmission voltage, a thicker conductor, a shorter route or local storage), recording the delivered fraction for each. Scale your best result up with I = P/V and I2R for a 100 MW link, labeling every input as sourced or illustrative. Build a weighted decision matrix with at least four criteria (energy delivered, cost, land and wildlife impact, wildfire risk, reliability) and the constraints you must respect. Explain the physics from wind to outlet: Faraday’s law in the generator, the transformer turns ratio, the field’s role in energy transfer and why the loss depends on the square of the current. Name at least one option whose negative consequences outweighed its benefits, and state the limits of your model. 1,000–1,400 words.
Choose where your results come from. All three earn full credit and are the same difficulty.
Route 1 — the Falstad circuit simulator. Build and screenshot every circuit, as in lesson 3.07.
Route 2 — hand calculation. Compute each case with V = IR and the reflected resistance R × n2; show every step.
Route 3 — the sample results set. No device needed. Use this constructed table (ideal transformers, 12 V source, 10 Ω town): baseline 0.600 A, 50.0% delivered; thicker conductor (5 Ω) 66.7%; shorter route (6 Ω) 62.5%; 1:5 pair 96.2%; 1:10 pair 99.0%; 1:10 pair with 5 Ω line 99.5%; 1:20 pair 99.75%. Recompute any three rows yourself to check them, then use the table as your simulation results for every part of the task.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Simulation of solutions (HS-ETS1-4) | Builds a working baseline model with realistic inputs and tests at least three solutions, comparing results with predictions. |
| Trade-off evaluation (HS-ETS1-3, HS-ETS1-4) | Weighted criteria and constraints, correct arithmetic, a rejected option whose costs outweigh its benefits, and a recommendation that follows. |
| Induction and fields (HS-PS2-5, HS-PS3-5) | Explains generation and transformers with Faraday’s law, Lenz’s law and the field’s role in energy transfer. |
| Energy accounting (HS-PS3-1) | Correct I = P/V and I2R calculations with units, scaled from model to grid. |
| Sources and limits | Inputs sourced or labeled illustrative; at least three model limits stated with their effect. |
| Defense | Clear recommendation and reasoned answers to questions. |
You turned a simulation into a recommendation a real commission could use. Next lesson: the unit checkpoint. Then the 360° field trip.
Exit ticket: which Wonder Board question can you now answer with your own model? Write the question and your answer.
How confident are you that you can I can use a simulation to test transmission designs and defend a recommendation with physics and trade-offs.
Materials: design logs from 3.07–3.08, devices for the simulator, rubric copies for guests. Reading: OpenStax College Physics 2e, chapter 23 (CC BY 4.0).
Timing: Poly ran this task over three sessions. Here the modeling and version 2 happen in 3.07–3.08; this lesson is the final report and the defense. Allow a second period if presentations run long.
Listen for: “the simulation proves”; transformers that “make” energy; scale-up with kV left unconverted.
Support / stretch: students without devices use Route 2 or 3 for full credit. Stretch: add the 99% efficiency of each real transformer to the scale-up and report the change.