
measure a ball’s height and final speed on a ramp, compare mgh with its kinetic energy (including rolling energy), and calculate the efficiency with an uncertainty.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Your team’s converter will be judged on efficiency. Before reading anything, write a plan in three steps for measuring how much of a ball’s starting energy is still motion energy at the bottom of a ramp.
A solid ball and a light cart are released from the same height on the same ramp. Which is faster at the bottom?
The question. If a ball starts at rest a height h above the floor and rolls down a ramp, conservation of energy predicts mgh = ½mv2, so v = √(2gh), whatever the mass. Your lab tests that prediction and measures how much of the starting energy shows up as motion at the bottom. That ratio is the ramp’s efficiency, the same idea that decides how much of a pumped-storage plant’s energy comes back.
Measuring speed. Put two tape marks 1.00 m apart on the level floor right after the ramp. Time the ball between them and use v = d/t. A phone video is better than a stopwatch. At 30 frames per second, each frame is 1/30 s ≈ 0.033 s, so count frames between the marks. Human reaction time with a stopwatch is roughly ±0.15 s at each click. For a 0.63 s run, that is about 24% uncertainty, too large to test the model.
Worked example (illustrative numbers). A 0.060 kg ball is released from h = 0.20 m (measured vertically, from the release point to the floor). It crosses the 1.00 m level run in 19 frames, so t = 19/30 = 0.633 s and v = 1.00/0.633 = 1.58 m/s.
Has a third of the energy vanished? No. A rolling ball also spins, and spinning takes kinetic energy too. For a solid ball rolling without slipping, the total kinetic energy is (7/10)mv2, so only 5/7 ≈ 71% of it is in forward motion. The ideal rolling speed from 0.20 m is √(10gh/7) = 1.67 m/s, not √(2gh) = 1.98 m/s. Counting the spin, the ball has (0.7)(0.060)(1.58)2 = 0.1047 J, which is 89% of mgh. The remaining ~11% went to thermal energy and sound from rolling friction and air drag. A cart with light wheels spins very little, so for a cart ½mv2 is close to the whole kinetic energy.
Uncertainty. One frame either way changes t to 0.600 s or 0.667 s, so v lies between 1.50 and 1.67 m/s and ½mv2 between 0.0675 and 0.0833 J. Because speed is squared, a 5% timing error becomes about a 10% energy error. Repeat each height three times and average; use the spread of your trials as your uncertainty.
Graph it. Energy conservation says v2 is proportional to h. Plot v2 against h for four heights. With no losses, the slope would be 2g = 19.6 m/s2 for sliding and 10g/7 = 14.0 m/s2 for a rolling solid ball. The illustrative data below give a best-fit slope (through the origin) of 13.2 m/s2, which is 94% of the rolling ideal. A straight line through the origin supports the model. A slope below the ideal measures the losses.
Common errors. Measuring h along the ramp instead of vertically; timing on the ramp while the ball is still speeding up; letting the ball bounce at the ramp’s foot; using a stopwatch on a short run.
Question. How much of a ball’s starting gravitational potential energy becomes kinetic energy at the bottom of a ramp, and where does the rest go?
Materials.
Procedure.
Data table.
| Height h (m) | Frames over 1.00 m (30 fps) | Time t (s) | Speed v = d/t (m/s) | mgh (J) | ½mv2 (J) | ½mv2 ÷ mgh |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.10 | 27 | 0.900 | 1.11 | 0.0588 | 0.0370 | 63% |
| 0.20 | 19 | 0.633 | 1.58 | 0.1176 | 0.0748 | 64% |
| 0.30 | 15 | 0.500 | 2.00 | 0.1764 | 0.1200 | 68% |
| 0.40 | 13 | 0.433 | 2.31 | 0.2352 | 0.1598 | 68% |
| Rows above are illustrative sample data for a 0.060 kg solid rubber ball. Replace them with your own averages of three trials per height. | ||||||
Analysis.
Other routes to the same data. Choose one. All three earn full credit and end in the same v2-against-h graph, the same fitted slope and the same efficiency discussion. Option A — run your own ramp. The procedure above. A shelf board, a length of vinyl gutter or a sheet of cardboard folded into a channel all work, and a stopwatch will do if you use the longest level run you can measure. Option B — the illustrative data in the table above. No equipment and no internet needed. The four rows (heights 0.10, 0.20, 0.30 and 0.40 m for a 0.060 kg solid rubber ball, timed at 30 fps over a 1.00 m level run) are a complete data set. Compute v, v2, mgh and ½mv2 yourself, graph v2 against h, and fit a line through the origin: you should get about 13.2 m/s2, which is 94% of the rolling ideal 10g/7 = 14.0 m/s2 and well below the sliding ideal 2g = 19.6 m/s2. Answer every analysis question from these rows. For the uncertainty question, use ±1 frame at 30 fps in place of the spread of three trials, and explain why that is the weaker of the two estimates. Option C — PhET Energy Skate Park. The PhET simulation is at phet.colorado.edu/sims/html/energy-skate-park/latest/energy-skate-park_all.html. On the Intro screen, turn on the bar graph, the speedometer and the grid, and set friction to zero. Release the skater from 1, 2, 3 and 4 m and record the speed at the bottom each time. Graph v2 against h and fit a line through the origin: with no friction and no spinning wheels the slope should come out near 2g = 19.6 m/s2. Then set friction to a value you write down, repeat all four heights, and report the new slope as an efficiency (new slope ÷ 19.6). Answer every analysis question from those two sets, and in the sources-of-error question explain what the simulation leaves out that a real rolling ball does not. Cite the sim and the date you used it.
Use the illustrative data table, then your own.
Write up the lab in your notebook.
Post your v2-versus-h graph and slope. Explain in 4-6 sentences whether the sliding model (2g) or the rolling model (10g/7) fits your data better, state your uncertainty, and name the largest source of error with the direction it would push your result.
Define your system for the ramp lab and its boundary. Write the algebraic energy equation for the start and the bottom, including a term for thermal energy. Use your data to find that thermal term for one height.
Efficiency is a measurement with an uncertainty, not a guess. Next lesson: where does the “missing” energy really go?
Exit ticket: one assumption in the ramp model, and how your data show it is not quite true.
How confident are you that you can I can measure speed and height on a ramp, compare mgh with kinetic energy, and report an efficiency with its uncertainty.
Materials: see the lab list. One ramp per team of three or four.
Timing: Poly ran this lab over two sessions (100 minutes). In a 50-minute period, run two heights per team and pool class data, or let this lesson span two periods.
Listen for: h measured along the slope; timing on the ramp while the ball still speeds up; “energy was lost” with no destination.
Support / stretch: give a pre-labeled spreadsheet with formulas for v, v2 and the energies. Stretch: fit the slope and compute the efficiency against both models.