answer our driving question with evidence from the unit and reflect on how I grew as a reader and writer of informational texts.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Look at our class map and timeline. Write one sentence that answers our driving question, “How did steel and the people who made it build the Mon Valley?”, using one place and one date.
In Spring’s time, where did much of the iron ore for Pittsburgh-area furnaces come from?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Back to our driving question. At the start of this unit you saw a blast furnace on the wall. Since then you have read a poet, researchers, a chemist, a steel owner and workers who spoke for themselves. Today you put it together.
Things and people came together. Spring’s passage shows one reason the mills grew here: ore was cheaper to ship to the coke and to the market than coke was to ship to the ore. Our other sources show the people who came too: workers from Europe, Black workers from the South, families who built homes beside the mills. The Mon Valley was built where materials, transport and people met.
Hard truths belong in the story. Our sources also show twelve-hour days, the long turn and a row of houses with one pump. A full answer to the driving question includes the work and the cost of the work.
Worked example 1: Gabriel writes a cause-and-effect answer. Because ore from Lake Superior was cheaper to ship to the coke than the other way around, furnaces grew in the Pittsburgh district. Those furnaces needed workers around the clock, so people came from Europe and the South, and towns like Braddock grew around the mills. He names his sources: Spring, Fitch, Epstein and Carnegie.
Worked example 2: Mia reflects on her writing. Mia compares her first opening with her final one. The first said, This label is about the town pump. The final one begins, Imagine carrying your drinking water down seventy-five stairs. She writes: I learned that the first sentence decides whether a visitor keeps reading.
Read Spring on your own first, then answer.
Reflect on your growth.
Writing reflection: compare your first draft and your final label. Name two changes (from your revision log) that made it better, and the checklist item each one improved.
Reading reflection: which text in this unit taught you the most, and which author’s view did you question? Explain with one quotation. Then choose an informational book or article to read next and say why.
The steel valley’s story is still being told, and now part of it is in your words.
Exit ticket: finish the sentence “Before this unit I thought … Now I know …” about our area’s history.
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, independent reading 8, mini lecture 6, guided practice 12, reflections 8, closure 2.
Source note: the passage is from Spring’s chapter II; Part 1 read other parts of his book (chapter IV and production data). Cut: one sentence claiming that Native people had no knowledge of the ore deposits, which Spring does not support and which is not needed; the brief opening anecdote is also left out. If students ask, note that Ojibwe and other Native nations lived in the Lake Superior region long before the mines. “Pittsburg” is an older spelling used in some printings of the time. The summary’s mention of Minnesota comes from the chapter’s opening, outside the passage.
Likely misconceptions: that Pittsburgh had its own iron ore mines for its big mills (Spring says the ore came from Lake Superior); that coke and coal are the same (coke is made from coal); that the driving question has one cause.
Supports: students may read the passage with a partner if independent reading is still developing; note this for CC.1.2.7.L. Provide a sentence frame for the driving-question paragraph (“Steel built the Mon Valley because … The people who made it … It cost …”).
Answer guide: sample paragraph: “The Mon Valley grew where materials and people met. La Verne W. Spring explains that iron ore from Lake Superior ‘is taken to the coke and limestone, and to the market for the product,’ so furnaces grew near Pittsburgh. Those furnaces ran day and night, and Fitch found furnace crews working twelve-hour days. Workers came from Europe and, as Epstein reports, from the South. Steel built towns like Braddock, but it also cost workers long hours and, at places like Painter’s Row, safe homes.” Accept other well-supported answers.
Project Gutenberg, Non-technical Chats on Iron and Steel by La Verne W. Spring (Frederick A. Stokes, 1917), eBook #73090 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
This passage comes from chapter II of La Verne W. Spring’s 1917 book, “The Raw Materials.” Making iron takes three main ingredients: iron ore, coke (a fuel made by baking coal) and limestone. In Spring’s time, much of the nation’s ore came from the Lake Superior region of Michigan and Minnesota. Spring tells how those deposits were found and why the first plan, making iron near the mines, failed.
As you read, look for causes and effects, and think about what this tells us about why the mills grew where they did.
Words to know: a deposit is a natural layer of a mineral in the ground; a surveyor measures and maps land; a solar compass is a compass that uses the sun to find true north; the sod is grass and the soil just under it; a forge is a furnace or shop where metal is heated and shaped; smelted means melted to get the metal out; deterioration means getting worse; preclude means to make impossible.
CHAPTER II
THE RAW MATERIALS
As the copper deposits are mostly along the shore of the lake and the great iron ore beds occur seven or more miles inland, the latter were not discovered until Sept. 19, 1844, when William A. Burt, a Deputy United States Surveyor, noticed that the needle of a solar compass of which he was the inventor became unreliable. In looking about to discover the magnetic source which must be the cause of the variation, members of his party discovered ore just beneath the sod near what is now Negaunee, Michigan. Inventor-like, Burt’s only concern was to devise some preventive for future interference by stray magnetic currents. He simply noted in his book that there was here a deposit of iron ore and neither he nor any of his party profited or apparently attempted to profit from the discovery.
[…]
The first plan was to build forges and manufacture iron near the mines. So there was established on Carp River a forge to which the ore was hauled in winter when the ground was frozen. It turned out, however, that while very good bar iron was manufactured here, it could not be delivered in Pittsburg at a cost less than $200 a ton. As the market rate for iron then was but $80 a ton the plan was not financially successful.
Attention was turned to the shipping of ore to furnaces better located as regards coke supply and market. It was possible to make this a profitable undertaking only through cheap ore handling and transportation. So, to-day, the ore which is better adapted than the other raw materials for handling by labor-saving devices and transporting without deterioration, is taken to the coke and limestone, and to the market for the product. While the weight of coke used is but half that of the ore smelted, its greater bulk, loss by breakage when handled in quantities, and deterioration upon exposure preclude its manipulation in the way which would be necessary to get it to the ore.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Non-technical Chats on Iron and Steel by La Verne W. Spring (Frederick A. Stokes, 1917), eBook #73090 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)