review the reading skills of Unit 1 (theme, evidence, setting, point of view and word choice) on a short poem and connect them to my own narrative.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. List the five reading moves we have practiced this unit: finding a theme, citing evidence, explaining how setting shapes a character, comparing points of view and interpreting word choice. Put a star by the one you feel strongest in and a question mark by the one you want to practice today.
A worried traveler asks someone about a long uphill road. What do you predict the answers will be like?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Review: five moves, one poem. Today is a practice round before the unit check. Poems are short, so every word carries weight.
Setting shapes the questions. The road winds “up-hill all the way,” and the journey lasts “From morn to night.” Because the road is long and hard, the traveler worries about the end: will there be a “resting-place,” will the darkness hide it, will there be a bed? The place creates the worry, just as the woods in “A White Heron” create Sylvia’s choice.
Contrasting points of view. The traveler is unsure and a little afraid (“May not the darkness hide it from my face?”). The answerer is calm and certain (“You cannot miss that inn.”) and calls the traveler “my friend.” The answerer does not pretend the road is easy, but always promises rest and company.
Word choice, structure and figurative meaning. Most of the answers are short, plain lines (“Yes, to the very end”), so they sound steady and final next to the longer, worried questions. The poem works on two levels: literally, it is about a day’s walk to an inn; figuratively, many readers hear the road as a whole life, hard work “to the very end,” and the inn as rest when life is over. Both readings are supported by the words.
Worked example 1: Elena states a theme. Elena first writes “Theme: travel.” That is a topic, not a theme. She revises: A hard road is easier to face when we know that rest and company wait at the end. She cites “Yea, beds for all who come” and explains that the last answer promises a place for everyone.
Worked example 2: Kofi reads like a writer. Kofi notices that Rossetti tells the whole poem in questions and answers, with no narrator explaining anything. In his own narrative he rewrites his crossroads scene as a quick exchange of questions between two characters, so the reader feels the worry without being told about it.
Discussion. In your group, each person answers one question, and the next person must build on that answer before adding a new idea.
Work with your group. Answer each question from the poem, then discuss your reasons.
Practice a short response, then connect the poem to your writing.
Short response (review for the unit check): How does Rossetti develop the theme across the poem? State the theme, cite two lines as evidence and explain how the setting and the two points of view develop it.
Reading like a writer: name one move from the poem (questions and answers, short steady lines, a setting that creates worry, a meaning on two levels) and show where you will try it in your anthology narrative. Write the new or revised sentence.
The road winds uphill to the very end; so do our anthology stories, through revision and publishing.
Exit ticket: which reading move felt strongest today, and which one will you review before the unit check? Write one question you still have.
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, two readings aloud 5, mini lecture 9, group practice 14, short response 10, closure 3.
Flex lesson: this is the review lesson. Use the guided practice results to form small groups for reteaching (theme vs. topic; point of view; figurative vs. literal) while others continue revising.
Text choice: “Up-Hill” replaces Frost’s “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening,” which students read in ELA 5. The Gutenberg edition prints the American spelling “labor.”
Likely misconceptions: that one person speaks the whole poem (the answers come from a second voice); that the inn must mean death (it is one reasonable figurative reading, often read as rest after a life of work, and the literal reading stands too). Handle the life-and-death reading gently; some students may have recent losses.
Supports: provide a four-column organizer (theme, evidence, setting, point of view). Read the poem aloud in two voices for students who need it. Stretch: who might the answerer be? Support the idea with two lines.
Answer guide: sample short response: “Rossetti shows that a hard road is easier to face when we know rest waits at the end. The setting is a road that winds ‘up-hill all the way,’ so the traveler keeps asking about the night: ‘May not the darkness hide it from my face?’ The calm answerer never says the road is easy, but promises, ‘You cannot miss that inn,’ and ends with ‘Yea, beds for all who come.’ The contrast between worried questions and steady answers develops the theme of comfort at the end of a hard journey.” Quiz keys: 1 = D, 2 = A, 3 = C, 4 = B, 5 = A.
Project Gutenberg, Poems by Christina G. Rossetti (Little, Brown, Boston, 1906), eBook #19188: "Up-Hill" · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
Christina Rossetti (1830-1894) was an English poet who lived in London. “Up-Hill” first appeared in 1861 and was collected in her first book, Goblin Market and Other Poems (1862). The Gutenberg file is a Boston edition of her poems (Little, Brown, 1906) that reprints her revised 1876 American edition.
The poem is a conversation between two voices. In each stanza, the first and third lines are questions from a traveler about a road, a long day’s journey and a place to rest at night. The second and fourth lines are the answers. Notice how the questions and the answers sound different.
Notice the sound too. Each stanza has four lines, and the lines rhyme in a pattern: the first with the third, the second with the fourth.
Words to know: morn means morning; wayfarers are travelers on foot; travel-sore means sore and tired from traveling; labor means hard work, and its sum is the total amount of it; yea is an old word for yes.
UP-HILL.
Does the road wind up-hill all the way?
Yes, to the very end.
Will the day’s journey take the whole long day?
From morn to night, my friend.But is there for the night a resting-place?
A roof for when the slow dark hours begin.
May not the darkness hide it from my face?
You cannot miss that inn.Shall I meet other wayfarers at night?
Those who have gone before.
Then must I knock, or call when just in sight?
They will not keep you standing at that door.Shall I find comfort, travel-sore and weak?
Of labor you shall find the sum.
Will there be beds for me and all who seek?
Yea, beds for all who come.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Poems by Christina G. Rossetti (Little, Brown, Boston, 1906), eBook #19188: "Up-Hill" (gutenberg.pglaf.org)