connect my ideas with transitions and write a concluding section that tells a visitor why my topic matters.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Read these sentences: “The company fixed the mill. The company did not fix the houses.” Join them with one word that shows contrast. Then write what a reader should think about that contrast.
Which joining word best shows the contrast?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Cohesion means sticking together. A label is cohesive when each sentence connects to the one before it. Transitions are the glue. They “clarify the relationships among ideas,” as our standard says: time, contrast, cause, addition or example.
A transition toolkit. Time: first, by 1909, later, today. Contrast: but, however, while, instead. Cause: because, as a result, so. Addition: also, in addition, even. Example: for example, such as. Vary them; a label of five “and then”s sounds like a list.
Crowell’s contrast. Notice her repeated “When”: “When the Carnegie Steel Company took over Painter’s Mill, it renovated the plant…. When it took over Painter’s Row, it did nothing.” The parallel sentences make the contrast impossible to miss, and the short second sentence lands hard.
A concluding section answers “So what?” Your last sentence or two should not simply repeat your first. It can connect the past to the visitor’s life today, point to what changed afterward, or name the meaning of your facts. The survey director does this when he writes that the survey had “a very serious purpose in detailing the facts.”
Worked example 1: Owen adds transitions. Owen’s draft: The pump was in the mill yard. It was 360 steps from the farthest apartment. Families carried water home. Revised: The only pump stood in the mill yard, 360 steps from the farthest apartment. As a result, families carried every drop of drinking water home from the yard.
Worked example 2: Sofia writes a so-what ending. Sofia’s first ending repeats her opening: So that is what Painter’s Row was like. She revises to connect to change: Reports like Crowell’s helped Pittsburgh see conditions it had ignored, and later the tenements were torn down. Clean water at the turn of a faucet was once out of reach for a whole Pittsburgh neighborhood. Each fact comes from the Survey’s report and captions.
Read Crowell closely, then practice transitions and endings.
Revise your own draft for cohesion and a strong ending.
Highlight every transition in your draft. Add or change at least three so that you use at least three different kinds (time, contrast, cause, addition, example).
Write two possible concluding sentences for your label: one that connects to visitors today and one that tells what changed later. Choose one and explain why.
Crowell’s facts became part of the record because she connected them clearly.
Exit ticket: write your best so-what sentence. What should a visitor feel or understand after reading it?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 9, mini lecture 8, guided practice 11, revision 7, closure 2.
Source note: the passage is the opening of Crowell’s article and the first sentence of the second paragraph of the director’s note, which the magazine printed inside her article (signed “Director of the Survey”). The rest of the note, cut here, says other companies owned houses as bad, praises the company’s better housing elsewhere and argues that employers who rent homes must bear a landlord’s responsibilities. Share this so students see the survey’s fuller, fairer framing. Sofia’s ending relies on the 2.18 caption “Where the tenements were torn down”; the claim that reports “helped Pittsburgh see” conditions is her own conclusion, reasonable from the captions but not a sourced fact, so a label should word it carefully.
Care with the content: describe crowding and poverty with respect for the families; do not invite jokes about the conditions.
Likely misconceptions: that more transitions are always better; that a conclusion must begin “In conclusion”; that an objective summary may include the reader’s feelings.
Answer guide: sample revision: “The row stood right beside the mill, so the air was full of soot. In addition, trains ran on tracks above the top row. As a result, the noise never stopped.” A proficient conclusion moves beyond repetition to meaning or change and stays accurate to the sources.
Project Gutenberg, Charities and the Commons: The Pittsburgh Survey, Part II: The Place (February 6, 1909), eBook #46025, article by F. Elisabeth Crowell · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
F. Elisabeth Crowell, a former hospital superintendent, spent several days in the winter of 1908 studying Painter’s Row, a group of houses owned by the Carnegie Steel Company on Pittsburgh’s South Side. The company was part of the United States Steel Corporation, which owned many mills. Her report appeared in the Pittsburgh Survey in February 1909.
The first two paragraphs set out what she found and describe the place. A note from the director of the survey, printed inside her article, then explains why the survey published these facts. Watch how Crowell uses “When” to line up a contrast, and how the director states the purpose.
Words to know: constituent means forming part of a whole; employes is an older spelling of employees; renovated means repaired and improved; ventilation means fresh air moving through a space; dearth means a lack; a palisade here is a line of steep cliffs; sidings are short railroad tracks beside the main line; animosity means strong dislike.
PAINTER’S ROW
THE UNITED STATES STEEL CORPORATION AS A PITTSBURGH LANDLORD
F. ELISABETH CROWELL
The United States Steel Corporation owns property on the South Side of Pittsburgh just beyond the Point Bridge. Here is located the old Painter’s Mill, which is one of the plants of the Carnegie Steel Company, which in turn is one of the constituent companies of the United States Steel Corporation; and here, also, stands what remains of Painter’s Row, where the company has housed certain of its employes, mostly immigrants. When the Carnegie Steel Company took over Painter’s Mill, it renovated the plant so as to turn out the sort and quantity of output which the Carnegie name stands for. When it took over Painter’s Row, it did nothing. When, a little over a year ago, and several years after the purchase of the property, I made a detailed investigation of the place, I found half a thousand people living there under conditions that were unbelievable,–back-to-back houses with no through ventilation; cellar kitchens; dark, unsanitary, ill-ventilated, overcrowded sleeping rooms, no drinking water supply on the premises; and a dearth of sanitary accommodations that was shameful.
Painter’s Row was originally a succession of six rows, some brick, some frame, built on the side of a hill that slopes from the foot of a lofty palisade down to the Ohio. Houses and mills immediately adjoin and tenants are even housed in an old brick building, in another part of which some of the mill offices are located. Sluggish clouds of thick smoke hang over the cluster of roofs and the air is full of soot and fine dust. Noise presses in from every quarter,–from the roaring mill, from the trolley cars clattering and clanging through the narrow street which divides mill and rows into two sections, from the trains on the through tracks above the topmost row and from the sidings which separate the lowest row from the river bank and which are in constant use for the hauling of freight to and from the mills.
[…]
We have no animosity in singling out one corporation; but we have a very serious purpose in detailing the facts as to this row of company houses.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Charities and the Commons: The Pittsburgh Survey, Part II: The Place (February 6, 1909), eBook #46025, article by F. Elisabeth Crowell (gutenberg.pglaf.org)