determine two central ideas in the opening of John A. Fitch’s 1909 report on Pittsburgh steel workers, trace how they develop, and begin an objective summary.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A visitor walks through a steel mill for ten minutes. What would the visitor learn about the workers? What would the visitor miss? Write one idea for each.
In 1909 a researcher wrote about Pittsburgh steel workers. Whose point of view do you predict he will present?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Central ideas grow. A writer does not state a central idea once and drop it. The idea is introduced, supported with details and often repeated in new words. Tracing it means following it from paragraph to paragraph.
Two strategies. First, look for sentences that tell what the writer will do or what something means: So I shall…, But…, This is…. Second, notice what the details have in common.
Worked example 1: details that point to an idea. Amira lists the people in paragraph 1: Hungarians and Poles, English, German and Scandinavian workmen, and Americans whose families go back to Washington’s troopers. She writes a central idea: The steel workers came from many nations and backgrounds.
Worked example 2: a turning word. Ben notices “But” in the last paragraph: “But a workman is not merely a workman.” The sentences before it describe what a quick visitor sees. The sentences after it say Fitch will let the men talk. Ben writes: Fitch argues that workers are whole people whose own views deserve to be heard.
Objective summary. An objective summary tells the central ideas and key details in your own words, in order, without your opinions. Here is my model: John A. Fitch reports that 70,000 to 80,000 men made steel in Allegheny County in 1909, many of them immigrants. He says most were unskilled, but skilled men gave the industry its character. Fitch explains that a quick visitor sees only tired, dirty workers, so he will let the men describe their own lives.
What does not belong. “I feel sorry for them” and “Fitch is a great writer” are opinions. Save them for a response, not a summary.
Annotate: CI beside a sentence that states a central idea, D beside a supporting detail.
Central ideas and a first summary.
Make a two-column chart. Left: two central ideas in the passage. Right: two quoted details for each. Then write one sentence explaining how the first paragraph prepares for the last.
Write an objective summary of the passage in 3-4 sentences. Checklist: (1) names the author and topic, (2) states both central ideas, (3) uses your own words, (4) contains no opinions.
Fitch promised to let the men speak. Next we listen to one of them and draw inferences from what he says.
Exit ticket: which mill town in paragraph 1 is closest to our school, and how does Fitch describe it?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, chart and summary 9.
Text note: the cut skips the paragraph on seeing the men at home and a paragraph that sorts skilled workers by national origin. “Homestead of Pinkerton fame” refers to July 6, 1892, when Pinkerton guards hired by the Carnegie company fought locked-out workers (lessons 2.09-2.10). The double hyphens (–) are how the file shows dashes.
Context: the Pittsburgh Survey was a major early study of an American industrial city; this magazine issue introduced it. Fitch later expanded his work into the book The Steel Workers (1910).
Likely misconceptions: that the first sentence is always the central idea; that a long list of places is itself a central idea; that a summary may include the reader’s feelings.
Supports: highlight the word “But” and the phrase “So I shall.” Stretch: Fitch writes about skilled men. Whose voices might be missing, and why does that matter?
Answer guide: central ideas: (1) steel workers came from many nations and lived throughout the district; (2) workers are whole people whose own views matter, which is why Fitch lets them talk. Guided open question: before: “faces reddened by the glare”, “the visitor passes on and forgets them”; after: “let them talk to you, as they talked to me.”
John A. Fitch, in Charities and the Commons, vol. XXI, no. 14 (January 2, 1909): The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I, The People, Project Gutenberg eBook #46029 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #46029
About the text. In 1907 and 1908 a team of researchers called the Pittsburgh Survey studied how people lived and worked in the steel district. John A. Fitch, one of its researchers, wrote about the steel workers. His article appeared in the magazine Charities and the Commons on January 2, 1909. In the same report he says he lived among the workers for nine or ten months.
What to notice. The first paragraph names mill towns along our river. The middle gives a number about skill. The last paragraph explains Fitch’s purpose. Underline the sentence where he tells you what he will do.
Words to know. Homestead of Pinkerton fame points to 1892, when guards from the Pinkerton detective agency fought strikers there. Kossuth and Kosciusko were heroes of Hungarian and Polish freedom, so their “countrymen” are Hungarian and Polish immigrants. Begrimed means covered with grime. Materially means in an important way. A standpoint is a point of view.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big ideas and once with a pencil.
It is estimated that between 70,000 and 80,000 men are employed in the manufacture of steel in Allegheny county. Their homes are clustered about the mills along the rivers, they are clinging to the bluffs of the South Side, and they are scattered over Greater Pittsburgh, from Woods Run to the East End. Up the Monongahela valley are the mill-towns,–Homestead of Pinkerton fame, Braddock with its record-breaking mills and furnaces, Duquesne where the unit of weight is a hundred tons, and McKeesport, home of the “biggest tube works on earth.” Here are countrymen of Kossuth and Kosciusko, still seeking the blessings of liberty, but through a different channel,–high wages and steady employment. Here are English, German and Scandinavian workmen, full of faith in the new world democracy; and here are Americans,–great-grandsons of Washington’s troopers, and sons of men who fought at Gettysburg.
Fully sixty-five per cent of these men are unskilled, but the remaining thirty-five per cent, the skilled and semi-skilled, are the men who give character to the industry. This is the class from which foremen and superintendents and even the steel presidents have been recruited, and it is the class that furnishes the brains of the working force.
[…]
The visitor in a steel mill sees only faces reddened by the glare of fire and hot steel, muscles standing out in knots and bands on bare arms, clothing frayed with usage and begrimed by machinery. The men do not differ materially from other workmen, and the visitor passes on and forgets them. The world is full of men in greasy overalls. But a workman is not merely a workman, any more than a business man is merely a business man. He is also a man, whether he works in a mill or sits at a desk. So I shall introduce some of these men and let them talk to you, as they talked to me. Bear in mind that the things they talk about could be taken up from another point of view. In the following interviews I am making no interpretation of the workers from the employer’s standpoint. These are the issues of life as seen by the men themselves.
Source: John A. Fitch, in Charities and the Commons, vol. XXI, no. 14 (January 2, 1909): The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I, The People, Project Gutenberg eBook #46029 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)