determine and trace central ideas in the close of Fitch’s report, cite evidence for inferences, and complete a reading check on the unit’s informational reading skills.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at your Wonder Board from 2.01. Star one question you can now answer and write the answer with a source.
Fitch interviewed more than a hundred skilled workers. How many do you predict praised the company the way George Hudson does?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Pulling the unit together. In this part we found central ideas (Fitch, Kellogg), cited evidence for inferences (Flinn), traced interactions (Byington, Carnegie), read technical and figurative words (Spring, Sandburg), evaluated charts and tables (Epstein, Spring), compared page and audio (Carnegie) and compared authors (Carnegie and Burgoyne, Spring and Fitch).
How authors frame an opinion. Fitch lets Hudson speak at length, then tells us he is “the exception.” Including a view you do not share, and saying how common it is, can make a writer seem fair while still guiding readers.
Worked example 1: evidence for an inference. Priya infers that the company tried to keep workers loyal with money benefits. She cites three details from Hudson: loans to build homes, a savings department that “pays five per cent,” and company houses rented “at thirty per cent or more below” other rents.
Worked example 2: a central idea across the whole report. Carlos connects the opening (2.03), where Fitch said workers are whole people and not just workmen, to the conclusion: “these men are more than workers; they are thinkers, too.” The same idea opens and closes the report, developed through every interview in between.
The reading check. Today’s check has two parts: the guided questions and two short written responses. Use the passage and your notes. Quote exactly and explain every quotation.
Reading check, part 1. Work on your own.
Reading check, part 2: two short responses.
Response A (objective summary and central ideas): Write an objective summary of today's passage in 4-5 sentences. Then name one central idea of the passage and trace how it develops from the Hudson interview to the conclusion, with two quotations.
Response B (comparing sources): Choose two authors from this unit who present steel work differently (for example Carnegie and Burgoyne, or Spring and Fitch). In 6-8 sentences, explain how each presents or interprets the facts, with at least two quotations from each, and say what a fair museum label should include from both.
Part 1 is complete. In Part 2 we turn our reading into writing: object labels, a map and a timeline for our exhibit.
Exit ticket: name the source from this unit you most want to use in a museum label, and the fact you would take from it.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 8, mini lesson 5, reading check part 1 10, part 2 13.
Text note: the first cut removes one sentence of the Hudson paragraph that uses an ethnic slur for Eastern European laborers. The second cut skips the rest of Fitch’s interviews (on churches, unions and politics). The third skips his note that these are skilled men, his list of mill men who rose to public office and a list of the types he interviewed.
Assessment: this is a formative check of the Part 1 codes; Part 2 assesses them again through the label set and a unit reading check. Scoring (20 points): guided quizzes, true/false and fill-in 6 x 1 = 6; guided open question 2; Response A 6 (summary objective and complete 3, central idea traced with two accurate quotations 3); Response B 6 (presentation of each author 2, evidence 2, fair-label reasoning 2). Use independent-reading logs for CC.1.2.7.L and the 2.09 chart for CC.1.2.7.G.
Likely misconceptions: that Hudson’s view is Fitch’s view; that one enthusiastic interview cancels a hundred others; that a summary should judge who is right.
Supports: allow notes and the passage; offer sentence frames for Response B. Stretch: Fitch calls the others “the serious, clear-headed men, rather than the irresponsibles.” How might that phrase affect his fairness?
Sample Response A: Fitch presents George Hudson, a skilled worker who praises the Steel Corporation for promotions, home loans, a savings plan and low company rents. Fitch then explains that Hudson is the exception: not over three of more than a hundred men he interviewed agreed. He concludes that skilled steel workers must be taken seriously as thinkers. The idea grows from his remark that he chose “the serious, clear-headed men” to his last words, “they are thinkers, too, and must be reckoned with.”
Answer guide (guided open question): because Fitch calls Hudson the only one who “gave them such full expression” and says few shared his views, readers weigh his claim lightly.
John A. Fitch, in Charities and the Commons, vol. XXI, no. 14 (January 2, 1909): The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I, The People, Project Gutenberg eBook #46029 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #46029
About the text. This is the end of John A. Fitch’s 1909 report, which we have read since 2.03. Right before this passage, Jim Barr (2.11) criticized the company’s plan for selling stock to workers. Now Fitch introduces George Hudson, who holds a similar job but has very different views.
What to notice. Hudson praises the company with specific numbers. Then Fitch tells readers how typical Hudson is and states what all his interviews show. Watch how the author frames Hudson’s opinion.
Words to know. Perseverance means not giving up. Discontented means unhappy with things. Employes is an older spelling of employees. Sentiments are feelings or opinions. Representative means typical of a group. Reckoned with means taken seriously.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big ideas and once with a pencil.
Now, just by way of contrast, listen to the story of George Hudson, who occupies a position similar to that of Barr, and has been in mill work about the same length of time. After having tried another line and found it unsatisfactory, Hudson came to the mills at about thirty years of age.
[…]
Being a man of perseverance and some education, he worked up very rapidly until he now occupies a skilled position.
“The Steel Corporation is a fine one to work for,” said Hudson to me with enthusiasm. “It gives every man a chance for promotion, and listens to every workman who has a plan for improvement. All the intelligent men are satisfied. If you can find any dissatisfied men, you will find that they are men who would be discontented anywhere you put them. Take the way they loan money to men who want to build homes. A good many men have their own cottages now just because the company helped them. The company has a savings department too, and it pays five per cent on all deposits, and that is more than the savings banks pay. Then, on the other hand, it charges only five per cent interest on the money that is loaned, and that is a lower rate than you can get anywhere else. The company owns houses which it rents to employes at thirty per cent or more below what other people charge. I pay twenty-five dollars rent, and I’ve got a friend in a company house which is better than mine, and he only pays eighteen.” Hudson is ambitious and he was very proud that his department during recent months had succeeded in beating all previous records known.
[…]
So these are the steel workers. I have not chosen extreme cases; on the contrary, it has been my aim to select men who are typical of a class,–the serious, clear-headed men, rather than the irresponsibles,–and with one exception, each case is fairly representative of a large group. The exception is the man whom I called Hudson. Not over three men out of the hundred and more with whom I talked at length indicated like sentiments, and he is the only one who gave them such full expression.
[…]
It is highly significant that there are such men as these in the Pittsburgh mills. In a discussion of the labor problem in the steel industry, it must be borne in mind that these men are more than workers; they are thinkers, too, and must be reckoned with.
Source: John A. Fitch, in Charities and the Commons, vol. XXI, no. 14 (January 2, 1909): The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I, The People, Project Gutenberg eBook #46029 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)