show what I have learned in Unit 1 by reading a new passage closely, writing a short scene and turning in my final anthology narrative.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take a slow breath. You have read like a reader and written like a writer for weeks. Read the passage twice: once for the story, once with your pencil. Underline anything you might use as evidence, and box any word you do not know.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to read closely and use evidence from the passage.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
How this check works. Part A is a reading check on the passage. Part B is a short on-demand scene. Part C is your final anthology narrative with your checklist and revision log. Take your time and use evidence.
Reminders for Part A. When a question asks for evidence, quote exactly and put the words in quotation marks. A theme is a full sentence about life, not one word. An objective summary tells the main events without opinions. For point of view, ask what each character wants and what the narrator knows that they do not.
Worked example 1: Imani cites and explains. A practice question asks how the young man feels at the start of the passage. Imani writes, “He is eager and hopeful. The text says he ‘hurried to dress himself’ and was ‘sure’ Sylvia had seen the heron, so he expects good news.” She quotes exactly, then explains.
Worked example 2: Caleb interprets a phrase. Caleb reads that the great world “puts out a hand to her.” He writes, “The world cannot really hold out a hand. This is figurative: the stranger, his money and his friendship are the first offer the outside world has ever made to Sylvia.”
Reminders for Parts B and C. Use our ten-item checklist. A strong scene has an opening that orients the reader, dialogue or inner thoughts, precise sensory details, clear transitions and an ending that follows and reflects.
| # | Writer’s checklist | Standard |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | My opening establishes the context (place, time, situation), the point of view and the narrator or main characters. | N |
| 2 | A setting forces a real choice: my character stands at a crossroads, and the reader understands why the place matters. | M |
| 3 | Dialogue reveals how characters think, feel and disagree. | O |
| 4 | I use precise words, relevant descriptive details and at least three kinds of sensory language. | O |
| 5 | I control pacing: I slow down at the crossroads moment and move quickly through the in-between parts. | O |
| 6 | Events unfold logically, and varied transitions signal shifts in time or setting. | P |
| 7 | My conclusion follows from the events and reflects on the choice. | P |
| 8 | My language is precise and concise; my sentences vary; my voice stays consistent. | Q |
| 9 | Dialogue punctuation, commas, verb tense, pronouns and spelling are correct, with no fragments or run-ons. | R |
| 10 | I planned, revised after feedback and kept a revision log that names my purpose and audience. | T |
Constraints: 500 to 900 words. School-appropriate. If your story is true and includes other people, change their names or ask their permission. Your title and your first name (or a pen name) will appear in the anthology. Our audience: students, families and teachers who borrow the book from the school library or hear it at family reading night.
Part A: Reading check. Work alone. Answer each question from the passage.
Parts B and C.
Part B (on-demand writing, about 15 minutes): Write a short scene (150-250 words) told from the young man’s point of view as he waits in the doorway for Sylvia to answer. Open by orienting the reader to the place and time, use at least three kinds of sensory detail, use two transitions, slow down the moment he realizes she will not tell, and end with a line that reflects on the choice. Keep the characters true to the passage.
Part C: Submit your final anthology narrative (500-900 words) with your checklist marked and your revision log. In two sentences at the top of the log, name your purpose and audience and the change you are proudest of.
Like Sylvia in the doorway, every writer reaches a moment to choose: speak or keep silent. Your story is finished, and next it goes out to readers.
Exit ticket: which question on the check felt strongest for you, and which skill do you want to keep practicing?
Pacing: warm-up and two readings 10 minutes, brief reminders 3, Part A 17, Part B 12 (finish during the next lesson if needed). Collect Part C at the end.
Coverage: Part A covers CC.1.3.7.A (question 1 and the objective summary in the short response), B (question 2 and the short response), C (questions 4 and 8: the setting and the loss of a friend shape Sylvia’s choice and the ending), D (question 3: contrasting points of view), F (questions 5-7: figurative language, context clues and the effect of a tense shift) and K (reading a new passage independently). Part B and the final narrative (Part C) are scored with the rubric below for CC.1.4.7.M-R and T. Peer-conference notes from 1.22 and the publishing-night discussion in 1.26 complete CC.1.5.7.A.
Content note: the last paragraph describes birds the hunter shot, “stained and wet with blood.” The word dumb is Jewett’s older use for “unable to speak”; it is glossed, and students should not use it about people. If a student finds the material upsetting, offer a quiet place and a check-in.
Supports: read the passage aloud for students with reading accommodations (Part A then measures comprehension, not decoding). Allow typed responses. Rebukes is deliberately left out of the words to know and the glossary, so question 6 tests context clues.
Scoring Part A (12 points): questions 1-8 are 1 point each. The short response is scored 0-4: 1 for an accurate, opinion-free summary, 1 for a clear theme statement, and 1 for each of two accurate quotations that are explained. 10-12 = meets the standard; 7-9 = approaching; 6 or below = reteach the weakest skill in a small group.
Narrative rubric (Part C; use rows 1, 3, 4 and 6 for Part B). Score each row 4 (exceeds), 3 (meets), 2 (approaching) or 1 (beginning).
| Row (standard) | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Opening (CC.1.4.7.N) | Context, point of view and narrator are clear at once, with a hint of the pressure | Context and narrator are clear | Some of where, when or who is missing | The reader cannot tell where, when or who |
| 2. Crossroads narrative (CC.1.4.7.M) | A setting clearly forces a meaningful choice that drives the whole story | A setting creates a clear choice | The choice could happen anywhere, or is told rather than shown | No clear choice |
| 3. Techniques (CC.1.4.7.O) | Dialogue reveals character; precise words and three or more kinds of sensory detail; pacing slows at the crossroads | Some dialogue, precise detail and slowed pacing | Little dialogue or detail; pacing is even throughout | No dialogue or description |
| 4. Sequence and conclusion (CC.1.4.7.P) | Logical order, varied transitions for time and setting shifts, a conclusion that follows and reflects | Clear order, some transitions, a fitting conclusion | Order sometimes confusing; the ending stops suddenly | Hard to follow; no conclusion |
| 5. Style (CC.1.4.7.Q) | Precise, concise language; varied sentences on purpose; a consistent voice | Mostly concise, some variety, steady voice | Wordy or repetitive; voice slips | Hard to read; no clear voice |
| 6. Conventions (CC.1.4.7.R) | Few or no errors; dialogue punctuated correctly | Minor errors that do not get in the way | Frequent errors | Errors make it hard to read |
| 7. Process (CC.1.4.7.T) | The log shows real revisions from feedback, with reasons tied to purpose and audience | The log shows some revisions | Few changes from the first draft | No revision log |
A total of 21-28 meets the standard for the anthology. Below 21, confer and allow one more revision before publishing.
Answer key: 1 = C (index 2), 2 = A (0), 3 = D (3), 4 = B (1), 5 = C (2), 6 = D (3), 7 = A (0), 8 = B (1). Sample short response: “When Sylvia comes home from the pine, her grandmother and the young hunter ask her where the heron is. She stays silent, and he leaves disappointed. Jewett shows that loyalty to a place we love can outweigh a reward. At the moment of choice, ‘The murmur of the pine’s green branches is in her ears,’ so the woods themselves seem to hold her back. She ‘cannot tell the heron’s secret and give its life away,’ even though the money would help her poor family, which shows that what the place means to her matters more than ten dollars.” Sample Part B: “The kitchen still smelled of milk and woodsmoke when the girl finally came through the door. Pine pitch streaked her torn dress. I knelt so my eyes were level with hers. ‘Well, Sylvy?’ I asked. Behind me the old woman tapped her foot. The girl looked at me, then past me, toward the woods. For a long moment I heard only the thrushes. Then I understood. She was not going to tell me, and no amount of money would change that. I picked up my gun and my bag, and for once the woods felt like they belonged to someone else.”
Project Gutenberg, The Best Stories of Sarah Orne Jewett, Volume II (Houghton Mifflin, 1925), eBook #74980: "A White Heron" · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
You know Sylvia from “A White Heron” (1886): a shy girl who moved from a crowded town to her grandmother’s farm in the woods. A young hunter who collects birds has promised ten dollars to anyone who shows him the nest of a rare white heron. At dawn Sylvia climbed the tallest pine, watched the sun come up over the sea, and saw the heron fly to its nest near a dead hemlock tree by the green marsh. This passage is the end of the story. She has just come home.
Read it as you would any new passage. Think about what each character wants, how the setting affects Sylvia’s choice, and what the narrator’s word choices suggest.
Words to know: a husk bed is a mattress stuffed with corn husks; a frock is a dress; pitch is the sticky sap of a pine; dumb is an old word here for unable to speak, not for “stupid”; a pang is a sudden sharp pain; a report is the bang of a gun; piteous means sad to see.
“Sylvy, Sylvy!” called the busy old grandmother again and again, but nobody answered, and the small husk bed was empty, and Sylvia had disappeared.
The guest waked from a dream, and remembering his day’s pleasure hurried to dress himself that it might sooner begin. He was sure from the way the shy little girl looked once or twice yesterday that she had at least seen the white heron, and now she must really be persuaded to tell. Here she comes now, paler than ever, and her worn old frock is torn and tattered, and smeared with pine pitch. The grandmother and the sportsman stand in the door together and question her, and the splendid moment has come to speak of the dead hemlock-tree by the green marsh.
But Sylvia does not speak after all, though the old grandmother fretfully rebukes her, and the young man’s kind appealing eyes are looking straight in her own. He can make them rich with money; he has promised it, and they are poor now. He is so well worth making happy, and he waits to hear the story she can tell.
No, she must keep silence! What is it that suddenly forbids her and makes her dumb? Has she been nine years growing, and now, when the great world for the first time puts out a hand to her, must she thrust it aside for a bird’s sake? The murmur of the pine’s green branches is in her ears, she remembers how the white heron came flying through the golden air and how they watched the sea and the morning together, and Sylvia cannot speak; she cannot tell the heron’s secret and give its life away.
Dear loyalty, that suffered a sharp pang as the guest went away disappointed later in the day, that could have served and followed him and loved him as a dog loves! Many a night Sylvia heard the echo of his whistle haunting the pasture path as she came home with the loitering cow. She forgot even her sorrow at the sharp report of his gun and the piteous sight of thrushes and sparrows dropping silent to the ground, their songs hushed and their pretty feathers stained and wet with blood. Were the birds better friends than their hunter might have been,—who can tell? Whatever treasures were lost to her, woodlands and summer-time, remember! Bring your gifts and graces and tell your secrets to this lonely country child!
Source: Project Gutenberg, The Best Stories of Sarah Orne Jewett, Volume II (Houghton Mifflin, 1925), eBook #74980: "A White Heron" (gutenberg.pglaf.org)