develop my topic with relevant facts, concrete details, a definition of a technical word and an accurate quotation.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A visitor reads, “The furnace was very hot and had lots of parts.” Rewrite the sentence so it teaches the visitor something real. You may invent nothing: use note card C.
Which kind of detail will help a visitor most?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Developing means teaching. After your opening, the body of your label must teach. Our standard names the tools: “relevant facts, definitions, concrete details, quotations, or other information and examples.” Relevant means each one serves your purpose statement.
Facts and concrete details. A fact can be checked: a date, a number, a name, a place. A concrete detail is something a visitor can picture: “a ladle six feet high.” Replace general words (big, hot, a lot) with facts and details from your sources.
Definitions inside the sentence. Spring rarely stops for a dictionary entry. He tucks the meaning in: the “cast house,” “as the huge structure which houses the lower part of the furnace is called.” You can do the same with a comma phrase: The tuyères, L-shaped pipes, shot hot air into the furnace. Define every technical word a visitor needs.
Quotations. Quote when the exact words matter: a worker’s voice, a vivid phrase or a claim you must not change. Copy every word exactly, use quotation marks and say who wrote or said it. Keep quotations short; a label is mostly your own words.
Worked example 1: Darnell builds a detail sentence. Darnell starts with “The stoves heated the air.” From the passage he adds a number and a definition: Four stoves, heated by the furnace’s own hot gases, warmed the incoming air to as much as 1400 degrees F. Every part comes from Spring.
Worked example 2: Imani chooses a quotation. Imani wants to explain why the hot blast mattered. She could paraphrase, but Spring’s exact claim is strong: the hot blast “revolutionized the blast furnace industry.” She writes, According to steel chemist La Verne W. Spring, the hot blast, first tried by James Neilson about 1830, “revolutionized the blast furnace industry.” She names the source and copies the words exactly.
Check yourself. Underline every fact in your draft. Can you name the source of each one? If not, find it or cut it.
Read the passage closely. Use exact words as evidence.
Gather and use evidence for your own label.
Make a research chart for your label: three facts or details, one technical word with its definition and one quotation. For each, name the source (author and year).
Draft the body of your main label (about 100 words) after your opening. Underline every fact and write the source’s initial above it.
A visitor should leave your label knowing something exact.
Exit ticket: copy the strongest fact in your draft and its source. Why will a visitor remember it?
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 9, mini lecture 8, guided practice 11, research chart 6, closure 2.
Source note: the passage comes from Spring’s chapter IV. Spring writes as a visitor on a tour, and the superintendent’s explanation is set in quotation marks. One cut paragraph explains chemistry with a romance comparison and is not needed. Spring describes a typical plant, not a named Mon Valley mill; remind students not to claim his tour took place in Braddock or Duquesne. Spring’s spelling “sulphur” is the older form of sulfur.
Likely misconceptions: that a quotation needs no source; that more quotations make a better label (keep them short and few); that copying a source’s sentence without quotation marks is a paraphrase.
Supports: provide a three-column research chart (fact, source, how I will use it). Pre-teach tuyère (pronounced “twee-YAIR”). Stretch: integrate a quotation in the middle of your own sentence rather than as a separate sentence.
Answer guide: sample Do Now revision: “Inside the furnace, the hot blast reached 800 to 1400 degrees F. It entered through the tuyères, L-shaped pipes that, in La Verne W. Spring’s words, ‘shoot it directly into the furnace.’” Research charts are proficient when every fact has a named source and the definition matches the text.
Project Gutenberg, Non-technical Chats on Iron and Steel by La Verne W. Spring (Frederick A. Stokes, 1917), eBook #73090 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
La Verne W. Spring was chief chemist and metallurgist, a scientist of metals, at a Chicago company. In 1917 he published a book that explains the iron and steel industry in “non-technical” language for general readers. In this chapter, he takes readers on a tour of a blast furnace, the giant furnace that melts iron out of iron ore. He does not name a city; he is describing a typical plant of his time.
In this part of the tour, a furnace superintendent explains the parts of the furnace. Spring often puts a technical word in quotation marks and defines it right in the sentence. Watch for those definitions.
Words to know: slag is the melted waste that floats off the iron; a ladle is a huge bucket for melted material; lurid means glowing with a fiery red light; fused means melted together; accumulated means built up; revolutionized means changed completely; encircles means goes around.
CHAPTER IV
THE BLAST FURNACE
Once below again with our breath regained, things are more interesting. The red-hot molten slag which has just been tapped out is running from the furnace along a long trough into a ladle six feet high resting upon a car on the railway track alongside the “cast house,” as the huge structure which houses the lower part of the furnace is called. This smoking, molten slag stream gives off a powerful sulphur smell and throws a lurid glare over everything round about.
[…]
“This immense furnace is simply a strong steel shell lined two or three feet thick with fire bricks. At the ‘bosh,’ which is the region where the greatest heat is produced, hollow bronze plates are inserted among the bricks of the lining through which circulating cold water keeps the bricks from being fused.
“The hot gases which are led from the upper part of the furnace through that brick-lined ‘downcomer’ are burning in three of those ‘stoves’ to heat them, while cold, clean air from the blowing engines is coming through the other stove, which, ten minutes ago, when it was put on blast, was the hottest of the four. It is now giving up part of its accumulated heat to the blast on its way to the furnace. Switching the cold incoming air every little while from a partially cooled stove through a hotter one while allowing the former to reheat, provides continuous blast of a temperature of 800° to 1400° F. The ‘hot blast’ idea originated about 1830 with James Neilson, a gas engineer of England, and its introduction revolutionized the blast furnace industry and made the highly efficient modern practice possible.
“This big pipe above our heads which encircles the furnace is the ‘bustle pipe.’ It also has to be lined with fire bricks. The hot blast is distributed by this ‘bustle pipe’ to the tuyères here—these L-shaped pipes—which shoot it directly into the furnace. Through the peep-holes in the tuyères you can get a glimpse of the dazzling interior of the furnace. The blast of heated air is causing the coke to burn fiercely there so that it melts the iron, which farther up in the furnace has been forced to part from the oxygen, as I explained to you.”
Source: Project Gutenberg, Non-technical Chats on Iron and Steel by La Verne W. Spring (Frederick A. Stokes, 1917), eBook #73090 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)