cite several pieces of textual evidence to support what Fitch’s report says directly and to support inferences and a generalization about the length of the working day.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A school day is about seven hours. Imagine a work day of twelve hours, every day. What would you have no time for? List three things.
In 1909, some steel jobs had eight-hour shifts and others twelve-hour shifts. Why might one hot job have shorter shifts?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three levels of reading. What the text says directly (explicit). What you infer from clues. What you generalize: a broad statement that fits many details. A strong reader supports all three with several pieces of evidence, not just one.
Citing evidence. Quote exactly, keep it short and introduce it: Fitch reports that… or Flinn says…. Then explain how it supports your point.
Worked example 1: explicit. Sofia asks how long the steel pourer works. The text says it directly: he “works eight hours a day for six days in the week.” No inference is needed; she quotes and moves on.
Worked example 2: inference. Jamal reads that Flinn “speaks lightly of the danger of accidents” even though molten steel burned him so badly he could not turn over in bed for six weeks. The text never says Flinn hides how dangerous his job is, but Jamal infers it from the gap between the injuries and the word trifles.
From inference to generalization. Put several details together: the men who started with Flinn “are nearly all dead”; his strength is “not up to what it was”; burns that kept him in bed for six weeks count as “the minor ones.” A generalization: Steel work wore men down, even the well-paid ones. Several pieces of evidence make it believable.
A model paragraph. Fitch shows that the length of the work day shaped the steel workers’ lives. Flinn says the eight-hour men “get a lot more pleasure out of life than the twelve-hour men do” because they can go to “entertainments and social affairs.” He also notes that twelve-hour men work beside “all three crews” of eight-hour men. Hours decided not only how tired a man was but whether he had a life outside the mill.
Mark S for says, I for inference clue. Every answer needs a line number or a quotation.
Evidence response.
Prompt: What can you infer about the dangers of steel pouring, and how did Flinn feel about them? Write 5-7 sentences. Checklist: (1) a claim, (2) at least three short quotations, (3) one sentence that separates what Fitch says from what you infer, (4) an explanation for each quotation.
Museum thinking: write a one-sentence label fact about Bessemer steel pourers that a visitor could trust. Then write the quotation that proves it.
Hours, heat and danger shaped men’s lives. Next we see how a whole town grew around one mill.
Exit ticket: write one sentence that is explicit and one that is an inference about Jerry Flinn.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 8, guided practice 10, response 9.
Text note: the passage begins right after Fitch’s interview with a furnace boss, which is not used because it repeats an ethnic slur. “The furnace man” in the first sentence means a blast-furnace worker like him. The cut skips one more accident (a crane dropped a stopper on Flinn, burning him and breaking his leg); share it orally if students ask.
Likely misconceptions: that a single quotation proves a generalization; that Flinn’s word trifles means the injuries were small; that eight-hour men worked fewer days.
Care note: the passage describes serious burns and early deaths. Some students may have family members hurt at work; allow a quiet option.
Supports: a three-box organizer (says / infer / generalize). Stretch: Flinn’s twelve-hour coworkers overlap with three eight-hour crews. Draw a timeline of one day to show it.
Sample response: Steel pouring was very dangerous, but Flinn treats the danger as normal. Molten steel burned his legs so badly that “for six weeks afterwards, he was unable to turn over in bed,” and sparks “lodge in his nose or his ears.” He “nearly lost the sight of an eye.” Fitch says these facts directly. What I infer is Flinn’s attitude: because he “refers to these things as trifles,” I think he has lived with danger so long that he no longer counts it.
John A. Fitch, in Charities and the Commons, vol. XXI, no. 14 (January 2, 1909): The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I, The People, Project Gutenberg eBook #46029 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #46029
Where we are. Fitch now lets the workers talk. Jerry Flinn started as a laborer and worked his way up to steel pourer, the skilled worker who controls the flow of melted steel from a huge ladle into molds. He works in the Bessemer “converting department,” where iron is turned into steel.
What to notice. Some sentences tell you facts directly: hours, ages, injuries. Others make you infer, such as how Flinn talks about his accidents. Mark one of each. Then ask what the details add up to.
Words to know. A Bessemer converter is a huge vessel that turns melted iron into steel. A stopper plugs the hole in the bottom of the giant bucket that pours the steel. A mold is a container that gives the steel its shape. A shift or crew is a group that works the same hours. Trifles are small, unimportant things.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big ideas and once with a pencil.
There is a considerable difference between a blast furnace foreman and a Bessemer steel pourer. The furnace man gets rather low wages, while the steel pourer is well paid and works eight hours a day for six days in the week. It was Jerry Flinn who told me how he had worked up from his first job as laborer, to a position as steel pourer. I met him just as he got home from the mill one day, and I asked how he managed to work only an eight-hour shift when other men had to work twelve. He told me that attempts have been made to introduce a twelve-hour day in the converting department but without success. Two Pittsburgh mills have tried it and both went back to eight hours because the heat is so great as to make it impossible for the men to work that long.
“It must be hard,” said Flinn, “for the twelve-hour men to have to work alongside of us eight-hour men. During the twelve hours of their day they work with all three crews of the eight-hour men. One crew gets through and goes home soon after the twelve-hour men come out, the next crew works its eight hours and goes home, and the third crew comes out before those twelve-hour fellows can quit. The eight-hour men get a lot more pleasure out of life than the twelve-hour men do. We can go to entertainments and social affairs as we couldn’t if we had to get up next morning and go to work at six o’clock.”
Flinn is fifty-two years old, and tells you his strength is not up to what it was, say fifteen years ago. The men who went to work with him as young men are nearly all dead, and to-day he is one of the oldest men in his mill. He speaks lightly of the danger of accidents, and says that he has encountered only the minor ones.
[…]
At another time he failed to lower the stopper in time, and the stream of molten steel struck the edge of a mold as the train was shifted; it splashed onto the platform, burning his legs so severely that, for six weeks afterwards, he was unable to turn over in bed. It is a common thing for metal to fly that way; the sparks strike his face, they lodge in his nose or his ears, and once he nearly lost the sight of an eye. He refers to these things as trifles.
Source: John A. Fitch, in Charities and the Commons, vol. XXI, no. 14 (January 2, 1909): The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I, The People, Project Gutenberg eBook #46029 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)