analyze how a corporation, an event and the growth of a mill shaped the town of Homestead and the lives of its people, using Margaret Byington’s 1909 account.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Think of a big business near us: a hospital, a warehouse, a school campus. Name two ways it changes the streets and people around it.
Thirty years before 1909, what was on the land where the Homestead mill stood?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Interactions. In informational texts, people, events and ideas influence one another. A company’s decision (an event) can shape how families live (individuals). An idea, such as judging a company by the homes it helps create, can change how we see an event.
Chain mapping. Draw boxes and arrows: cause → effect → next effect. Label each box as a person or group, an event or an idea. Then quote the words that prove each arrow.
Worked example 1: a decision shapes lives. Olivia finds this sentence: the corporation, “through its practically unquestioned decisions as to wages and hours of labor, has in large measure determined the conditions under which the men shall live.” Her chain: company decides wages and hours → families’ living conditions.
Worked example 2: growth changes a place. Kwame traces the mill: two farms → a mill built in 1881 → a mill stretching “for over a mile along the river” → the town “shut off from the water front.” He adds a branch: smoke → wash day must “wait for a west wind.”
An idea that judges events. Byington offers an idea: the town is “a product of the steel industry,” just like rails and armor plate. So she says a company’s success should be measured partly by “creating the homes and moulding the lives of the workers.” Her idea changes the question from How much steel? to What kind of town?
A model sentence. Because the mill grew without a plan, it took over the riverfront and filled the air with smoke, which turned ordinary chores like washing clothes into a daily struggle for Homestead’s mothers.
Build a cause-and-effect chain as you answer.
Map the interactions.
Draw a chain with at least four boxes showing how the mill shaped Homestead. Label each box (person or group / event / idea) and write a quotation under each arrow.
Write a paragraph (5-6 sentences): How did one company shape the lives of Homestead's families? Use at least three pieces of evidence and the words because or as a result.
A mill changed a river, the air and a town. Next we climb inside a blast furnace and study the words that describe it.
Exit ticket: what is one question a museum visitor might ask about Homestead after reading Byington?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 8, guided practice 10, chain and paragraph 9.
Context: “Seventeen years ago” is 1892: the Homestead lockout and strike, in which armed Pinkerton guards and workers fought on July 6 and people died on both sides. Lessons 2.09-2.10 return to it. Byington’s article goes on to describe crowded housing for Slavic immigrant families near the mill; it is not shown here.
Local connection: the Homestead works stood in Homestead and Munhall; the Pump House from 2.01 is part of the old site.
Likely misconceptions: that an interaction is any two facts next to each other; that “the men failed” means the workers were lazy (it means they lost the 1892 fight).
Supports: pre-drawn chain with the first box filled (“Two farms”). Stretch: Byington writes in 1909. What evidence would you need to know whether her judgment was fair?
Answer guide: chain: company decisions on wages and hours → living conditions; mill growth → riverfront shut off; smoke → gloomy days, laundry, dirty children and grass. Idea → judging the company by its town. Dominating connotes power over others, which fits the riverfront being taken and daily life set by the company.
Margaret F. Byington, in Charities and the Commons, vol. XXI, no. 14 (January 2, 1909): The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I, The People, Project Gutenberg eBook #46029 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #46029
About the text. Margaret F. Byington was an officer of a field department that helped organize charity work, and she joined the Pittsburgh Survey team. She studied Homestead, a mill town on the Monongahela River. Her article appeared in the same January 2, 1909, issue as Fitch’s.
What to notice. Byington mentions a famous fight between the workers and the Carnegie Steel Company “seventeen years ago” (in 1892). Then she shows how the mill has grown and what that growth did to the riverfront, the air and daily chores. Track causes and effects with arrows.
Words to know. A corporation is a large company owned by shareholders. Armor plate is thick steel for warships. Moulding (an older spelling of molding) means shaping. Dominating means controlling. A unifying force pulls things together. Klomans is Byington’s name for the builders of the Homestead mill in 1881.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big ideas and once with a pencil.
Seven miles from Pittsburgh, up the valley of the Monongahela River, lie the town of Homestead and the largest steel plant in the world. Seventeen years ago, Homestead was, for a time, the center of national interest, while the men and the Carnegie Steel Company fought to the finish one of the most dramatic battles in the history of the labor movement. The men failed,–public interest died out,–but the mill has gone on growing steadily and the town has kept pace, until now it numbers about 25,000. Throughout this time, the corporation, through its practically unquestioned decisions as to wages and hours of labor, has in large measure determined the conditions under which the men shall live. There is only one other industry in the town, the Mesta Machine Company, and little other work except in providing for the needs of the mill workers. We may consider then that the conditions resulting when a great organized industry creates about it, without a definite plan, a town dependent solely upon it for development, are fairly represented in Homestead. For, after all, the town is to be considered in part as a product of the steel industry, as well as the rails and armor plate shipped in the great freight trains that puff away down the river, and the success of the corporation must be estimated, in part, by its share in creating the homes and moulding the lives of the workers.
Thirty years ago, two farms occupied the land now covered by the vast plant and the homes of hundreds of workers. In 1881, when Klomans built the mill, now a part of the United States Steel Corporation, the change began. The very aspect of Homestead shows how during the twenty-seven years that have passed, the plant has been the unifying and dominating force in the town. The mill has now stretched itself for over a mile along the river and the level space between the river and a hill rising steeply behind, which was the original site of both mill and town, has been entirely shut off from the water front. The smoke from the many furnaces and from the two railroads which cross the town settles heavily, making the section gloomy even on the brightest days. Wash day for some must wait for a west wind, if the clothes are not to come in blacker than when they went into the tub, and mothers find it a problem to keep children even reasonably clean in a place where the grass itself is covered with oily dust.
Source: Margaret F. Byington, in Charities and the Commons, vol. XXI, no. 14 (January 2, 1909): The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I, The People, Project Gutenberg eBook #46029 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)