Museum label set
How did steel and the people who made it build the Mon Valley?
The mystery: A Library of Congress HAER photograph of a Mon Valley blast furnace, enlarged on the wall.
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
interpret figurative and connotative language in Carl Sandburg’s “Smoke and Steel” and explain how word choice sets the tone, then choose an independent nonfiction book for the unit.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Write one word that comes to mind for each: smoke, steel, blood. Compare with a partner. Did you pick words with a good feeling, a bad feeling or neither?
A poet in 1920 writes a poem called “Smoke and Steel.” What do you predict he will focus on?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Words carry more than meaning. The denotation of a word is its dictionary meaning. Its connotation is the feeling it carries. Smoke means gas from burning, but it can feel cozy (a log fire) or threatening (a burning building).
Figurative language says one thing to mean another. In personification, a thing acts like a person. Sandburg writes that smokes “swear: ‘I know you.’” Smoke cannot speak, so the line must mean something more.
Worked example 1: personification. Keisha asks what the swearing smokes mean. The smoke of farm fields and the smoke of “the finished steel” recognize each other “by the oath of work.” She decides Sandburg is saying that all work is related, on a farm or in a mill.
Worked example 2: connotation and tone. Diego counts the phrase “smoke and the blood of a man.” It appears again and again. Blood connotes life, pain and sacrifice. He decides the tone is serious and a little dark: Sandburg wants us to remember that every bar of steel cost human effort.
Tone is the writer’s attitude toward the subject: proud, angry, admiring, sad. Word choice creates it. Compare “they make their steel with men” to “they make steel from iron ore.” Both are true, but only the first puts people at the center.
Your reading life. This unit you will also read a nonfiction book or long article of your choice about work, industry, inventions or a community’s history. Choose one you can read on your own. Log your pages and bring one interesting fact to class each week.
Read the excerpt twice, once aloud with a partner.
Two jobs today: a word study and a book choice.
Word study: choose two phrases from the poem. For each, write its literal meaning, its connotation and the tone it creates. Then write one sentence: What is Sandburg's attitude toward steel work?
Reading life: choose your independent nonfiction book or article. Write its title and author, why you chose it and one question you hope it answers about work or industry. Read the first pages and check: can I read this on my own?
A poet showed us steel made “with men.” Next we meet some of those men in a 1909 report written by someone who lived among them.
Exit ticket: write one phrase from the poem that would make a powerful title for our exhibit, and explain its connotation.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, read-aloud 7, mini lesson 9, guided practice 10, word study and book choice 10.
Text note (important): do not hand out the full poem. A stanza inside the […] cut uses three ethnic and racial slurs. The excerpt was copied from the 1920 Harcourt, Brace and Howe scan on the Internet Archive; three garbled OCR line ends were checked against the Wikisource transcription of the same edition. The opening word appears in small capitals in print.
Context: Sandburg’s steel towns span the country: Pittsburgh and its Mon Valley neighbors, Youngstown (Ohio), Gary (Indiana) and Birmingham (Alabama). “The Works” is what mill towns often called the mill.
Likely misconceptions: that connotation is the same as a definition; that a poem’s tone must be only happy or only sad; that Sandburg is describing one real mill.
Independent reading: offer grade-level nonfiction about work, industry, immigration and invention from the school and public library. Keep the log simple: date, pages, one fact, one question.
Supports: a three-column chart (phrase / literal meaning / feeling). Stretch: why does the poem begin with farm smoke before mill smoke?
Answer guide: “with men” makes workers the true material of steel; tone serious, honoring and a little grim; supporting lines: “Smoke and blood is the mix of steel”; “always dark in the heart and through it, / Smoke and the blood of a man.”
Carl Sandburg, Smoke and Steel (Harcourt, Brace and Howe, 1920), Internet Archive scan smokesteel00sanduoft · Public domain in the U.S. (published 1920); Internet Archive scan
About the poem. Carl Sandburg was an American poet who wrote about working people and industrial cities. “Smoke and Steel” is the title poem of his 1920 book. You will read the opening and two later parts. Sandburg names real steel towns: Pittsburg (an older spelling of Pittsburgh), Youngstown in Ohio, Gary in Indiana, Birmingham in Alabama, and two towns near our school, Homestead and Braddock.
What to notice. Watch the word smoke change: first the smoke of fields and leaves, then the smoke of a mill. Notice repeated phrases and lines where smoke seems to act like a person.
Words to know. A funnel is a ship’s smokestack. An oath is a serious promise. Cinders are bits of burned material. A rudder steers a ship. A steering-gear steers a machine; Sandburg means an airplane.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big ideas and once with a pencil.
Smoke and Steel
Smoke of the fields in spring is one,
Smoke of the leaves in autumn another.
Smoke of a steel-mill roof or a battleship funnel,
They all go up in a line with a smokestack,
Or they twist … in the slow twist … of the wind.If the north wind comes they run to the south.
If the west wind comes they run to the east.
By this sign
all smokes
know each other.
Smoke of the fields in spring and leaves in autumn,
Smoke of the finished steel, chilled and blue,
By the oath of work they swear: “I know you.”Hunted and hissed from the center
Deep down long ago when God made us over,
Deep down are the cinders we came from—
You and I and our heads of smoke.[…]
A bar of steel—it is only
Smoke at the heart of it, smoke and the blood of a man.
A runner of fire ran in it, ran out, ran somewhere else,
And left—smoke and the blood of a man
And the finished steel, chilled and blue.So fire runs in, runs out, runs somewhere else again,
And the bar of steel is a gun, a wheel, a nail, a shovel,
A rudder under the sea, a steering-gear in the sky;
And always dark in the heart and through it,
Smoke and the blood of a man.
Pittsburg, Youngstown, Gary—they make their steel with men.In the blood of men and the ink of chimneys
The smoke nights write their oaths:
Smoke into steel and blood into steel;
Homestead, Braddock, Birmingham, they make their steel with men.
Smoke and blood is the mix of steel.
Source: Carl Sandburg, Smoke and Steel (Harcourt, Brace and Howe, 1920), Internet Archive scan smokesteel00sanduoft (archive.org)