analyze how Andrew Carnegie, Edgar Thomson, a farm owner and the geography of Braddock influenced one another in Carnegie’s account of founding the Edgar Thomson steel works.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. You are choosing where to build a giant steel mill in 1873. Raw materials arrive heavy and finished rails leave heavy. Rank these from most to least important: near a river, near railroads, near a big city, cheap land.
Carnegie named his new mill after a railroad president, Edgar Thomson. How do you predict Thomson first reacted?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A memoir is a primary source. Carnegie was there. That makes his account valuable, but it is also his point of view. He tells the story the way he remembers it and wants it remembered.
Three kinds of influence. Look for (1) individuals influencing events (a person’s choice makes something happen), (2) events influencing individuals (something that happens changes a person) and (3) ideas influencing both (a belief that drives a decision).
Worked example 1: a place shapes a decision. Rosa notices why Carnegie chose Braddock: it lay “between the Pennsylvania, the Baltimore and Ohio, and the river.” Two railroads and a river meant more than one way to ship. Geography influenced the choice.
Worked example 2: an idea changes a person’s mind. Ethan traces Edgar Thomson. At first he did not want his name on steel rails because American rails “had proved to be far from creditable.” Carnegie told him American rails could now be “as good in every particular as the foreign article,” and Thomson “consented.” An idea about quality changed an individual’s decision.
Events push back. The farm owner, Mr. McKinney, “had a high idea of the value of his farm,” so land expected to cost five or six hundred dollars an acre cost two thousand. Later the company paid five thousand an acre to grow. A person’s choice affected the company’s plans.
Then and now. The Edgar Thomson Works began making steel in 1875. The furnace photograph from 2.01 was taken in this same works more than a hundred years later.
Draw an influence web: names in circles, arrows for influence.
Interactions paragraph.
Prompt: How did people, a place and an idea work together to create the Edgar Thomson Works? Write 5-7 sentences. Checklist: (1) a claim, (2) at least two individuals and one idea, (3) three quotations, (4) words like because, led to or changed.
Museum thinking: draft a two-sentence label for “The Edgar Thomson Works, Braddock, 1875.” Use only facts from today's passage and lesson.
A site, a name and a promise of quality. Next we read Carnegie on a painful event and hear his words read aloud.
Exit ticket: whose point of view is missing from Carnegie's story of the site?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 5, reading 9, mini lesson 8, guided practice 9, paragraph 9.
Context: Braddock’s defeat (1755) was the defeat of British General Edward Braddock’s army by French soldiers and their Native allies near the Monongahela during the French and Indian War. Name it as a victory for the French and Native forces, and remind students that Native nations lived in and used this valley long before the mills. The cut skips Carnegie’s remarks on two Scottish soldiers killed in the battle and on how Pittsburgh got its name.
Point of view: Carnegie is a hero of his own story. Workers, the farm owner and Braddock’s residents do not speak here. Pair this with Fitch and Byington.
Likely misconceptions: that the mill was named after the town; that a memoir is neutral; that geography “decided” without people.
Supports: pre-printed influence web with names. Stretch: Thomson wanted the mill on his own railroad only. How does Carnegie’s choice of two railroads and a river show his business thinking?
Sample response: The Edgar Thomson Works grew from a place, people and an idea. Carnegie chose Braddock because it lay “between the Pennsylvania, the Baltimore and Ohio, and the river,” so the mill could ship several ways. The owner, Mr. McKinney, raised the price because he “had a high idea of the value of his farm.” Edgar Thomson only “consented” to lend his name after Carnegie argued American rails could be “as good in every particular as the foreign article.” Each person changed the plan, and the idea of quality steel tied it together.
Andrew Carnegie, Autobiography of Andrew Carnegie (1920), Project Gutenberg eBook #17976 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #17976
About the text. Andrew Carnegie came to Pittsburgh from Scotland as a poor boy and became one of the richest steel makers in the world. He wrote his memoirs late in life, mostly before 1914; they were published in 1920, after his death. In this chapter he and his partners have decided to make steel rails by the new Bessemer process. They need a place to build.
What to notice. Watch the people in the passage: Carnegie, his brother Tom, his partner Mr. Coleman, a farm owner named Mr. McKinney and Edgar Thomson, president of the Pennsylvania Railroad. Ask how each one affects what happens. Notice too what the site lies between.
Words to know. To reconcile myself means to accept. Braddock’s is the old name of the place, from a 1755 battle. Relics are objects left from the past. Erection here means building. Creditable means deserving praise. The foreign article means steel rails made in other countries.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big ideas and once with a pencil.
The question of location was the first to engage our serious attention. I could not reconcile myself to any location that was proposed, and finally went to Pittsburgh to consult with my partners about it. The subject was constantly in my mind and in bed Sunday morning the site suddenly appeared to me. I rose and called to my brother:
“Tom, you and Mr. Coleman are right about the location; right at Braddock’s, between the Pennsylvania, the Baltimore and Ohio, and the river, is the best situation in America; and let’s call the works after our dear friend Edgar Thomson. Let us go over to Mr. Coleman’s and drive out to Braddock’s.”
We did so that day, and the next morning Mr. Coleman was at work trying to secure the property. Mr. McKinney, the owner, had a high idea of the value of his farm. What we had expected to purchase for five or six hundred dollars an acre cost us two thousand. But since then we have been compelled to add to our original purchase at a cost of five thousand dollars per acre.
There, on the very field of Braddock’s defeat, we began the erection of our steel-rail mills. In excavating for the foundations many relics of the battle were found–bayonets, swords, and the like.
[…]
In naming the steel mills as we did the desire was to honor my friend Edgar Thomson, but when I asked permission to use his name his reply was significant. He said that as far as American steel rails were concerned, he did not feel that he wished to connect his name with them, for they had proved to be far from creditable. Uncertainty was, of course, inseparable from the experimental stage; but, when I assured him that it was now possible to make steel rails in America as good in every particular as the foreign article, and that we intended to obtain for our rails the reputation enjoyed by the Keystone bridges and the Kloman axles, he consented.
Source: Andrew Carnegie, Autobiography of Andrew Carnegie (1920), Project Gutenberg eBook #17976 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)