give and use specific feedback on a classmate’s label using our checklist, and plan my revisions.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Which comment would help a writer more? (A) “Good label.” (B) “Your number, 568 people, stopped me. I could not tell what a ‘tenement’ is; can you define it?” Write why.
What makes comment B more useful than comment A?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Every label needs a test reader. You know what you meant, so you cannot always see what a visitor will miss. Professional exhibit writers get feedback from other writers and from ordinary readers before anything is printed. Today you will be each other’s test readers.
Our conference steps. (1) The writer reads the label aloud while the partner times it. (2) The partner paraphrases: “Your label teaches that …” (3) The partner checks three checklist items the writer chooses and gives one glow and one grow, each tied to a checklist number. (4) The partner checks one fact against its note card or passage. (5) The writer asks a question, then writes a revision plan. Switch.
Discussion moves. Come prepared with your draft and checklist. Build on what your partner says (“I agree about the opening, and I also noticed …”). If the talk drifts, bring it back: “Can we look at item 7 now?” If your partner shows you evidence, be willing to change your mind.
Worked example 1: Nadia and Luis confer. Luis reads his label on the stoves. Nadia paraphrases: “Your label teaches that the stoves made the furnace hotter.” Luis frowns: he meant that the stoves heated the air. Now he knows his key sentence is unclear. Nadia’s glow (item 4): “You defined tuyère right in the sentence.” Her grow (item 8): “Your last sentence repeats your first. What should I remember?”
Worked example 2: Ben checks a fact. Ben’s partner, Chloe, reads that Painter’s Row had 568 households. She checks note card E: 568 was the number of people, in 91 households. Ben fixes it and writes in his log: Fact check caught a number error. In a public exhibit, one wrong number can make visitors doubt everything else.
The writer decides. Feedback is advice, not orders. Use what makes the label clearer and more accurate, and write a reason for any suggestion you do not use.
Read Kellogg closely, then practice feedback on the mentor label.
Hold your conference, then plan.
Record your conference: your partner’s paraphrase, the read-aloud time, their glow and grow (with checklist numbers) and the fact they checked. Was the paraphrase what you meant?
Write your revision plan with three numbered changes, each tied to a checklist item. Add one suggestion you chose not to use and explain why.
The Pittsburgh Survey was not one writer’s work. According to Kellogg’s introduction, a group of experienced researchers spent September 1907 in Pittsburgh, and their first diagnosis shaped a set of specialized investigations. Writers such as John Andrews Fitch, who studied steelworkers, and F. Elisabeth Crowell, who studied housing, each took one part.
The team also included artists. The 1909 issues credit photographs to Lewis W. Hine and drawings to Joseph Stella, and Kellogg promised that the text would be “reinforced” with photographs, maps, charts and tables. Before the issues were printed, the team showed wall maps, enlarged photographs and housing plans in a civic exhibit at the Carnegie Institute in November and December 1908.
Writers, photographers, artists and editors each saw what the others missed, and the public could see the findings in an exhibit before the special issues came out, much like the exhibit our class is building.
Think about it: How did people with different skills make the survey stronger than one writer could? What can our peer conferences borrow from the way the team worked?
The survey team showed its work to the public before it was finished printing. Today you showed yours to a reader.
Exit ticket: what did your partner notice that you would not have noticed alone?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 5, mini lecture 6, case study 6, guided practice 6, two conference rounds 12, plan and closure 2. Plans can be finished for homework.
Source note: the passage is two paragraphs of Kellogg’s introduction that Part 1 did not reprint. The case study’s exhibit facts come from the paragraph Part 1 showed in 2.12, which gives the dates as “November and December”; the year 1908 comes from the caption of the survey chart in the same issue (“From Pittsburgh Civic Exhibit, Carnegie Institute, November-December, 1908”). The Hine and Stella credits appear on photo pages and drawings in the January 2 and February 6, 1909 issues. “Different races” in 1909 often meant national and ethnic groups (Slavic, Italian, Jewish, Black and others); explain this so students do not misread it.
Assessment: score each draft at this stage with checklist items 1-9 (formative), using the partner’s notes and your own reading. Listen in on conferences for CC.1.5.7.A: building on a partner’s idea, returning talk to the topic and changing a view after seeing evidence.
Likely misconceptions: that feedback means only finding errors; that a glow should be general; that the partner owns the revision.
Supports: pair students thoughtfully and post sentence stems (“Your label teaches that …” “I could picture …” “I was unsure when …” “Item __ could be stronger if …”). Students anxious about reading aloud may hand the draft to the partner to read silently.
Answer guide: sample mentor feedback: “Glow (item 2): ‘Picture finishing a full day of work and then staying all night, too’ puts me in the scene. Grow (item 6): the caption could say where the drawing first appeared on the page, or the label could explain what an ingot has to do with the long turn.” Case study answer: specialists went deeper than one writer could, artists showed what words could not, and the exhibit let the public react; our conferences borrow the idea of checking a first draft with fresh eyes.
Project Gutenberg, Charities and the Commons: The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I: The People (January 2, 1909), eBook #46029, article by Paul U. Kellogg · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
This passage comes later in Paul Kellogg’s 1909 introduction to the first Pittsburgh Survey issue, which you met in Part 1. It explains how the survey worked. A group of experienced researchers spent a month in Pittsburgh and made a first judgment, which Kellogg calls a diagnosis, about what most needed study. Specialists then carried out deeper investigations. The staff included people from the many immigrant and other groups in the work force; Kellogg, using the language of 1909, calls them “different races.”
Kellogg then explains who the work was for: local groups trying to improve the city, and he lists changes already under way.
Words to know: established reputation means being well known and respected; a diagnosis is a judgment about what is wrong, as a doctor makes; projected here means planned; nascent means just beginning; graft means dishonest use of a public office for money; a census is an official count; endemic means always present in a place.
THE PITTSBURGH SURVEY
PAUL U. KELLOGG
The main work was set under way in September, 1907, when a company of men and women of established reputation as students of social and industrial problems, spent the month in Pittsburgh. On the basis of their diagnosis, a series of specialized investigations was projected along a few of the lines which promised significant results. The staff has included not only trained investigators but also representatives of the different races who make up so large a share of the working population dealt with.
[…]
From the first, the work of the investigations has been directed to the service of local movements for improvement. For, as stated in a mid-year announcement of the Survey, we have been studying the community at a time when nascent social forces are asserting themselves. Witness the election of an independent mayor three years ago, and Mr. Guthrie’s present fight to clear councils of graft. Within the field of the Survey and within one year, the Pittsburgh Associated Charities has been organized; the force of tenement inspectors has been doubled and has carried out a first general housing census, and a scientific inquiry, under the name of the Pittsburgh Typhoid Commission, has been instituted into the disease which has been endemic in the district for over a quarter of a century. A civic improvement commission, representative in membership and perhaps broader in scope than any similar body in the country, is now in process of formation.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Charities and the Commons: The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I: The People (January 2, 1909), eBook #46029, article by Paul U. Kellogg (gutenberg.pglaf.org)