review the reading skills of our unit by comparing how two authors present the hours of steel work, and use what I find to check my label.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. A company owner and a worker each describe the same job. List two reasons their descriptions might differ, even if both tell the truth.
A mill owner and a furnace worker both describe twelve-hour shifts. Whose account is more likely to describe how the hours feel?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Why review? The unit check asks you to read new passages on your own and use every skill from Part 1. Today we practice them together, on two texts about the same topic: how long steelworkers worked.
Two authors, same topic. Our standard asks how authors “present and interpret facts.” Ask three questions. (1) Which facts does each author choose? (2) Whose voice do we hear? (3) How does each author explain what the facts mean? Fitch quotes a worker at length; Carnegie speaks for the company in his own voice.
Read the words closely. “I am told” means Carnegie is reporting something he heard, not something he checked himself. “In my opinion” marks a judgment, not a fact. Words like these tell you how much weight a claim can carry in a museum label.
Worked example 1: Marcus states central ideas. Marcus writes: Text A’s central idea is that the twelve-hour day and the long turn leave Griswold too tired to enjoy his family. Text B’s central idea is that Carnegie saw his Braddock mills as fair to workers and believed shorter hours would come. Each is an objective statement, with no opinion of his own.
Worked example 2: Elena compares interpretations. Elena notes that both texts mention eight-hour days. Griswold wishes for them now: “if we had eight hours it would be different.” Carnegie says the men “prefer two to three turns” but that “Eight hours will be the rule” in the future. Same fact, two meanings: for Griswold, long hours are a hardship today; for Carnegie, they are the workers’ preference for now.
Use it in your label. If your label quotes an owner or a worker, say who is speaking and when. A visitor deserves to know whose view a quotation gives.
Answer from the texts. Then compare with a partner.
Review stations: choose two, then check your label.
Station 1 (central ideas and summary): write a three-sentence objective summary of Text A. Station 2 (evidence): list three facts from Text A that a museum label could use, each with an exact quotation.
Label check: find every quotation in your label. Next to each, write who said or wrote it, when, and whether it is a fact, an opinion or a secondhand report. Revise any sentence that hides whose view it is.
Researchers ask the same question of every source: whose view is this?
Exit ticket: which reading skill do you feel strongest in now, and which will you review before the unit check?
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 8, mini lecture 7, guided practice 12, stations 7, closure 2.
Source notes: Text A is from Fitch’s article in the January 2, 1909 issue. Fitch’s first sentence about Griswold is shown. The next sentence (a mocking word for newcomers) and the middle of Griswold’s own words (an ethnic slur and insults about Eastern European co-workers) are cut, marked […], and are not shown. If students read the full article, prepare them for this and discuss how prejudice against new immigrants divided workers. Part 1 read Fitch’s opening and his interviews with Flinn, Barr and Hudson; this lesson does not reprint them. Text B is from Carnegie’s chapter XVIII, “Problems of Labor.” The note that Fitch renamed some workers rests on his line “the man whom I called Hudson.”
Context: Carnegie sold his company in 1901; it became part of the U.S. Steel Corporation. Fitch’s 1909 interviews describe the industry after that sale, and Carnegie writes about “our day” and 1914. The two texts are about the same topic, not the same week or mill.
Supports: read Text A aloud; the dialect spellings are easier heard. Provide a two-column chart (Fitch / Carnegie) with rows for facts chosen, voice and interpretation.
Answer guide: sample short response: “Fitch lets a worker speak for himself. Griswold says, ‘I’m tired and sleepy all the afternoon,’ so readers feel what the long turn costs a family. Carnegie writes as an owner who calls the Edgar Thomson Mills ‘the ideal works’ and reports that the men ‘prefer two to three turns.’ He wants readers to see his company as fair and to trust that shorter hours would come.” Accept other supported comparisons.
Project Gutenberg, Charities and the Commons: The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I: The People (January 2, 1909), eBook #46029, John Andrews Fitch, “Some Pittsburgh Steel Workers”; with Project Gutenberg, Autobiography of Andrew Carnegie (1920), eBook #17976, Chapter XVIII · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
Text A. In Part 1 you read John A. Fitch’s interviews with steelworkers from the 1909 Pittsburgh Survey. This new section is his talk with a furnace boss he calls Jack Griswold (Fitch says later in the article that he gave some workers other names). Fitch describes Griswold as a Scotch-Irish immigrant who had worked at Pittsburgh blast furnaces for twenty years. His words are printed as he spoke them, with spellings like mornin’.
Text B. Andrew Carnegie, who built the Edgar Thomson Works in Braddock, wrote his autobiography by 1914; it was published in 1920, after his death. In this short passage he describes his Braddock mills. A turn is a work shift: two turns means two twelve-hour shifts a day; three turns means three eight-hour shifts.
Words to know: the long turn is a 24-hour shift; the missus means his wife; childer is an old word for children; saloons were bars; capital and labor means owners and workers; recreation means free time for fun or rest.
Text A: from John Andrews Fitch, “Some Pittsburgh Steel Workers,” 1909
SOME PITTSBURGH STEEL WORKERS
JOHN ANDREWS FITCH
Jack Griswold is a Scotch-Irish furnace boss who came to America and got a laborer’s position at a Pittsburgh blast furnace, when the common labor force was largely Irish.
[…]
I sat in Griswold’s sitting room in his four-room cottage one evening and he told me about the men who work at the furnaces, and about the “long turn.”
“Mighty few men have stood what I have, I can tell you. I’ve been twenty years at the furnaces and been workin’ a twelve-hour day all that time, seven days in the week. We go to work at seven in the mornin’ and we get through at night at six. We work that way for two weeks and then we work the long turn and change to the night shift. The long turn is when we go on at seven Sunday mornin’ and work through the whole twenty-four hours up to Monday mornin’. That puts us onto the night turn for the next two weeks, and the other crew onto the day. The next time they get the long turn and we get twenty-four hours off, but it don’t do us much good. I get home at about half past seven Sunday mornin’ and go to bed as soon as I’ve had breakfast. I get up about noon so as to get a bit o’ Sunday to enjoy, but I’m tired and sleepy all the afternoon. Now, if we had eight hours it would be different. I’d start to work, say, at six and I’d be done at two and I’d come home, and after dinner me and the missus could go to the park if we wanted to, or I could take the childer to the country where there ain’t any saloons.
[…]
I don’t want the kids ever to work this way. I’m goin’ to educate them so they won’t have to work twelve hours.”
Text B: from Andrew Carnegie, Autobiography, Chapter XVIII, written by 1914, published 1920
PROBLEMS OF LABOR
The Edgar Thomson Mills are, in my opinion, the ideal works in respect to the relations of capital and labor. I am told the men in our day, and even to this day (1914) prefer two to three turns, but three turns are sure to come. Labor’s hours are to be shortened as we progress. Eight hours will be the rule–eight for work, eight for sleep, and eight for rest and recreation.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Charities and the Commons: The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I: The People (January 2, 1909), eBook #46029, John Andrews Fitch, “Some Pittsburgh Steel Workers”; with Project Gutenberg, Autobiography of Andrew Carnegie (1920), eBook #17976, Chapter XVIII (gutenberg.pglaf.org)