compare how “The Gift of the Magi” and a scene from Little Women develop a theme about giving, citing several pieces of evidence from each.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Write the theme of “The Gift of the Magi” from memory as one full sentence. Then trade with a partner. Are your two theme statements the same, similar or different?
The March sisters notice their mother's slippers are worn out. Each sister has one dollar. What will they decide?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Comparing themes. Two texts can share a topic, like giving, but develop different themes about it. To compare, state each text’s theme, find evidence in each, then explain how they are alike and how they differ.
Worked example 1: what is alike. Ruby notices that both stories start with very little money: Della’s $1.87 and the sisters’ single dollar each. In both, characters give up what they want for someone they love. Della sells her hair; the sisters agree to “not get anything for ourselves.”
Worked example 2: what is different. Kai looks closer at Amy: “I’ll get a little bottle of cologne. She likes it, and it won’t cost much, so I’ll have some left to buy my pencils.” Kai writes: “Amy gives, but she keeps something for herself. Della gives everything. Alcott shows that people learn generosity in steps, while O. Henry shows a complete sacrifice.”
A comparison frame. Both texts show… In “The Gift of the Magi,” … In Little Women, … However, … This difference suggests…
A model paragraph. Both texts suggest that the best gifts come from giving up something for others. Della sells the hair that was one of the couple’s two greatest treasures, and the narrator calls the couple “the wisest.” Beth proposes that the sisters “not get anything for ourselves,” and the others quickly agree. However, the sacrifices differ in size. Amy plans to have “some left to buy my pencils,” so Alcott shows a family still learning to give, while O. Henry shows two people who have already given all.
Point of view and setting matter too. The sisters live in wartime with Father away, and Jo says she is “the man of the family now Papa is away.” Their situation, not just their kindness, helps explain why caring for Mother feels so important.
Use today’s passage and the “Gift of the Magi” passages from 1.05-1.07.
Write a comparison response.
Prompt: How do “The Gift of the Magi” and this scene from Little Women develop a theme about giving? Write 8-10 sentences. Checklist: a claim that names a shared theme; at least two quotations from each text; one clear difference; transitions (both, however, while); a closing sentence.
Two stories, one topic, two shades of a theme. Next we read a cold-read story and check everything we have learned.
Exit ticket: Which character's gift, Della's, Jim's or one sister's, would mean the most to you? Why?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 5, reading 7, mini lesson 9, guided practice 8, comparison response 11.
Text note: Jo’s line “I’m the man of the family now Papa is away” reflects the 1860s. Let students discuss how gender roles of the time shape her view without judging her.
Likely misconceptions: that two texts with the same topic must have the same theme; that comparison means summarizing each text separately; that Amy is selfish (she does give; she is younger and still learning).
Supports: a Venn diagram; the comparison frame in the mini lesson. Stretch: Meg’s idea comes “as if the idea was suggested by the sight of her own pretty hands.” What does that show about her?
Answer guide: alike: both show love through sacrifice (“not get anything for ourselves”; Della’s “Give it to me quick”). Different: Della and Jim give up their greatest treasures; Amy keeps money for pencils, and the sisters’ gifts are small. Sample claim: Both texts show that love means putting someone else first, but O. Henry shows a complete sacrifice while Alcott shows sisters learning to give.
Louisa May Alcott, Little Women (1868), Project Gutenberg eBook #514 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #514
Where we are. Later the same evening, the four March sisters are knitting by the fire and waiting for their mother, whom they call Marmee. Earlier, each one planned to spend her dollar on herself.
What to notice. A small object, a pair of old slippers, changes the conversation. Watch who suggests the new plan and what each sister chooses to give. Notice that Amy’s choice is a little different from the others’. Think about how this choice compares with Della’s and Jim’s.
Words to know. The hearth is the floor of a fireplace. Brightened means became more cheerful. The blaze is the fire. Provide means to supply what is needed. Soberly means seriously. Announced means said out loud for all to hear. Hemmed means with the edges folded and sewn. Cologne is a light perfume.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the story and once with a pencil.
The clock struck six and, having swept up the hearth, Beth put a pair of slippers down to warm. Somehow the sight of the old shoes had a good effect upon the girls, for Mother was coming, and everyone brightened to welcome her. Meg stopped lecturing, and lighted the lamp, Amy got out of the easy chair without being asked, and Jo forgot how tired she was as she sat up to hold the slippers nearer to the blaze.
“They are quite worn out. Marmee must have a new pair.”
“I thought I’d get her some with my dollar,” said Beth.
“No, I shall!” cried Amy.
“I’m the oldest,” began Meg, but Jo cut in with a decided, “I’m the man of the family now Papa is away, and I shall provide the slippers, for he told me to take special care of Mother while he was gone.”
“I’ll tell you what we’ll do,” said Beth, “let’s each get her something for Christmas, and not get anything for ourselves.”
“That’s like you, dear! What will we get?” exclaimed Jo.
Everyone thought soberly for a minute, then Meg announced, as if the idea was suggested by the sight of her own pretty hands, “I shall give her a nice pair of gloves.”
“Army shoes, best to be had,” cried Jo.
“Some handkerchiefs, all hemmed,” said Beth.
“I’ll get a little bottle of cologne. She likes it, and it won’t cost much, so I’ll have some left to buy my pencils,” added Amy.
“How will we give the things?” asked Meg.
Source: Louisa May Alcott, Little Women (1868), Project Gutenberg eBook #514 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)