write a short claim-evidence-reasoning response analyzing how Jerome’s word choices reveal a first-person narrator whose point of view the reader cannot trust.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A friend says, “I read a list of symptoms online, and now I am sure I have five different illnesses.” Do you believe them? What in their words makes you doubt?
A narrator reads a medical book in a library and decides he has almost every disease in it. How will the reader most likely react?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
First-person narrators. A first-person narrator tells his own story. We see only what he chooses to tell, in his words. That can make a story feel close and personal. It can also mislead us.
Unreliable narrators. A narrator is unreliable when readers have good reasons not to trust his version. Clues include claims that clash with the facts, reasons that do not make sense, and wild or exaggerated language. Some unreliable narrators are frightening; this one is funny, because the reader sees the truth that the narrator cannot.
Worked example 1: claims versus facts. Sofia notes the facts: he went to the library to read about “some slight ailment” and only turned pages. Then the claim: he “discovered that I had typhoid fever, must have had it for months without knowing it.” She writes: “Reading a list cannot give you a disease, so his conclusion does not follow from his evidence.”
Worked example 2: word choice. Ethan circles the dramatic words: “frozen with horror,” “the listlessness of despair” and “a decrepit wreck.” These are words for a disaster, but nothing has happened except reading. He also notices the dashes in the long typhoid sentence, which pile disease on disease like a panic that speeds up. The exaggeration tells us not to take the narrator at his word.
Two narrators in one. One sentence lets the older narrator step in: “I have since been induced to come to the opinion that it must have been there all the time.” The man in the reading-room thought his heart had stopped. The man telling the story, later, knows better, and he lets the reader in on the joke.
Writing a CER response. Claim: one sentence that answers the question. Evidence: two or more exact quotations. Reasoning: sentences that explain how each quotation proves the claim. Here is my model: The narrator of Three Men in a Boat cannot be trusted about his health. He says, “I could not feel my heart. It had stopped beating,” which cannot be true of a man who is still talking. He decides he has nearly every disease on the list just by reading about them, and the only one missing is “housemaid’s knee.” His fear, not the facts, shapes his point of view, so the reader cannot trust his conclusions.
Read the passage aloud with a partner, then answer. Underline every disease the narrator says he has.
Write your CER response.
Prompt: Is the narrator of Three Men in a Boat reliable about his health? Write a 6-8 sentence claim-evidence-reasoning response. Checklist: (1) a clear claim; (2) at least two exact quotations with lead-ins, at least one about word choice; (3) reasoning after each quotation; (4) a closing sentence that connects to point of view.
Contrast: how does Jerome's first-person narrator differ from the third-person narrator of “The Open Window”? Which one hides more from the reader? Then explain how the setting, a library reading-room, shapes the narrator's choices.
A narrator’s own words can give him away. Next we compare four sisters who each see the same Christmas differently.
Exit ticket: name one clue that tells a reader not to trust a narrator.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 3, reading aloud 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, CER response 11.
Text choice: this passage replaces Poe’s “The Tell-Tale Heart,” which students read in ELA 8. Jerome’s book was first published in England in 1889 and is in the U.S. public domain.
Content care: the humor is about a man who imagines he is ill. Keep the laughter aimed at the narrator’s panic, never at real illness. Some students live with health worries or have family members who are seriously ill; say plainly that real symptoms deserve a doctor’s care, and that worrying after reading symptom lists is common. Disease names (typhoid, cholera, diphtheria) need only the short gloss in the summary.
Likely misconceptions: that the narrator is Jerome himself; that a narrator who says “I” is always truthful; that an unreliable narrator must be lying on purpose (this one fools himself); that evidence means summary rather than quotation.
Supports: CER frame (I claim… / The narrator says… / This shows… because…). Stretch: find the one sentence where the older narrator admits he was wrong, and explain why Jerome put it there.
Answer guide: guided open question: the frightened man believed his heart had stopped; the older narrator, telling the story later, admits it was beating all along, so he shares the joke with the reader. Contrast answer: Jerome’s narrator misleads himself, and the reader sees through him at once; Saki’s narrator hides Vera’s plan until the end, so Saki hides more. Setting: the reading-room full of medical books gives him the lists that feed his fear (“I had walked into that reading-room a happy, healthy man”). Score the CER on claim, evidence and reasoning (see the sample in the mini lecture).
Jerome K. Jerome, Three Men in a Boat (To Say Nothing of the Dog), Project Gutenberg eBook #308 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #308
About the book. Jerome K. Jerome was an English writer of comic books and plays. Three Men in a Boat was first published in 1889; the Gutenberg file is the first edition (J. W. Arrowsmith, Bristol). It is told in the first person: the narrator says “I” and tells us about his own adventures.
What to notice. In the first chapter the narrator remembers a visit to the reading-room of the British Museum, a famous library in London. He went to look up one small problem. Watch what happens to him in that room, the dramatic words he chooses, and the reasons he gives for his conclusions. Do they convince you?
Words to know. Impelled means pushed. Virulent means severe and harmful. An ailment or a malady is an illness. Indolently means lazily. A distemper is an old word for a disease, and a scourge is something that causes great suffering. Premonitory means warning ahead of time. A fortnight is two weeks. Housemaid’s knee is a swollen knee from kneeling to scrub floors. Decrepit means weak and worn out. Typhoid fever, ague, cholera and diphtheria are serious diseases of Jerome’s time.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the story and once with a pencil.
It is a most extraordinary thing, but I never read a patent medicine advertisement without being impelled to the conclusion that I am suffering from the particular disease therein dealt with in its most virulent form. The diagnosis seems in every case to correspond exactly with all the sensations that I have ever felt.
I remember going to the British Museum one day to read up the treatment for some slight ailment of which I had a touch—hay fever, I fancy it was. I got down the book, and read all I came to read; and then, in an unthinking moment, I idly turned the leaves, and began to indolently study diseases, generally. I forget which was the first distemper I plunged into—some fearful, devastating scourge, I know—and, before I had glanced half down the list of “premonitory symptoms,” it was borne in upon me that I had fairly got it.
I sat for awhile, frozen with horror; and then, in the listlessness of despair, I again turned over the pages. I came to typhoid fever—read the symptoms—discovered that I had typhoid fever, must have had it for months without knowing it—wondered what else I had got; turned up St. Vitus’s Dance—found, as I expected, that I had that too,—began to get interested in my case, and determined to sift it to the bottom, and so started alphabetically—read up ague, and learnt that I was sickening for it, and that the acute stage would commence in about another fortnight. Bright’s disease, I was relieved to find, I had only in a modified form, and, so far as that was concerned, I might live for years. Cholera I had, with severe complications; and diphtheria I seemed to have been born with. I plodded conscientiously through the twenty-six letters, and the only malady I could conclude I had not got was housemaid’s knee.
[…]
Then I wondered how long I had to live. I tried to examine myself. I felt my pulse. I could not at first feel any pulse at all. Then, all of a sudden, it seemed to start off. I pulled out my watch and timed it. I made it a hundred and forty-seven to the minute. I tried to feel my heart. I could not feel my heart. It had stopped beating. I have since been induced to come to the opinion that it must have been there all the time, and must have been beating, but I cannot account for it.
[…]
I had walked into that reading-room a happy, healthy man. I crawled out a decrepit wreck.
Source: Jerome K. Jerome, Three Men in a Boat (To Say Nothing of the Dog), Project Gutenberg eBook #308 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)