analyze how Andrew Carnegie and Arthur G. Burgoyne present and interpret facts about the 1892 Homestead wage scale differently, and write a short comparison with evidence from both.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Your pay goes up when the store sells more, but the lowest it can drop is set in writing. Your boss offers a new deal: you get some of the money from a new machine, but the lowest pay can drop further. Is that a raise or a cut? Explain in two sentences.
A mill owner and a Pittsburgh writer both write about the 1892 wage offer. What do you predict?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Same topic, different presentations. Two honest-sounding authors can describe one event and leave readers with opposite pictures. They do it in two ways: by emphasizing different facts and by interpreting the same facts differently.
Ask four questions. What facts does each author include? What does each leave out? What words judge the facts? What does each author want readers to conclude?
Worked example 1: different facts. Lena compares numbers. Carnegie gives “sixty per cent more steel,” earnings up “almost sixty per cent,” and an offer of “thirty per cent greater.” Burgoyne gives a minimum of “$22 per ton, instead of $25.” Neither mentions the other’s numbers. Each picks the facts that support his view.
Worked example 2: different interpretations. Noah looks at judging words. Carnegie calls the offer “fair and liberal” and “generous.” Burgoyne describes it as announced “to the amazement of the men” and says “a serious reduction” would follow. He reports a claim by “many” that the low market was a “pretext.” Noah notes that Burgoyne attributes that claim to others rather than stating it as fact.
Staying fair. Our job is not to pick a winner. Each author had a stake: Carnegie was the owner defending his company; Burgoyne wrote for readers who sympathized with the workers. A museum label should present both and name them.
A model comparison. Carnegie and Burgoyne describe the same 1892 wage scale but lead readers to different conclusions. Carnegie emphasizes that new machinery raised output and that the firm offered the men “thirty per cent greater” earnings, which he calls “generous.” Burgoyne emphasizes that the minimum dropped from $25 to $22 a ton and predicts “a serious reduction.” By choosing different numbers, each author makes the offer look like either a raise or a cut.
Use a two-column chart: Carnegie / Burgoyne.
Short comparison response.
Prompt: How do Carnegie and Burgoyne shape their accounts of the 1892 wage scale? Write 6-8 sentences. Checklist: (1) a claim naming both authors, (2) one fact each emphasizes, (3) one judging word from each, (4) at least four accurate quotations, (5) reasoning about why their purposes differ, (6) no statement of who was right.
Draft a fair two-sentence museum label titled “Raise or Cut? 1892.” Name both authors.
Same facts, different stories. Next we compare a writer who saw efficiency with one who heard exhaustion.
Exit ticket: what is one question you would need answered to judge the 1892 offer yourself?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 8, guided practice and discussion 11, response 8.
Text note: both excerpts are copied from their Gutenberg files; the bold headings are ours. Carnegie’s cut skips his note on armor and exhibition contracts. Burgoyne’s cut skips the story of how the sliding scale began after an 1889 strike. Burgoyne’s other chapters describe the July 6 battle with Pinkerton guards in detail and are not used.
Historical accuracy: the numbers differ partly because the authors measure different things (total earnings with new machines versus the wage floor). Both can be true at once. In later negotiations the firm insisted on a $23 minimum (Burgoyne, later in the book). Several men died on both sides on July 6, 1892; the state militia then occupied Homestead and the union lost.
Nonpartisan note: labor disputes still stir feelings in our valley. Present both authors fairly and never tell students which side to take.
Likely misconceptions: that one author must be lying; that numbers are always neutral; that a reported claim (“it was claimed by many”) is the author’s own statement.
Supports: a chart with rows (facts / judging words / purpose). Stretch: Carnegie mentions 218 tonnage men. Why might that number help his argument?
Sample response: Carnegie and Burgoyne describe the 1892 wage scale so differently that it sounds like two events. Carnegie emphasizes the machinery, which made “about sixty per cent more steel,” and says the men’s earnings “would have been thirty per cent greater.” He judges the offer “generous.” Burgoyne emphasizes the wage floor, which dropped to “$22 per ton, instead of $25,” and says the men reacted with “amazement” and faced “a serious reduction.” Carnegie wrote to defend his company; Burgoyne wrote for workers who wanted their side told. Readers need both to understand the dispute.