evaluate how a 1917 author uses a table and the sentences around it to show the growth of iron making, and study his craft as a model for writing accurate museum labels with numbers.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Which is easier to remember: “Production grew a lot” or “Production grew from 565,000 to 31,000,000 tons”? Why? Which would you trust more on a museum label?
In what year do you predict the United States passed Great Britain in making pig iron?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Tables and sentences work as a team. A table holds many exact numbers in a small space. Sentences pick out the pattern and tell readers why it matters. Good writers do not repeat every number; they choose.
Spring’s craft moves. (1) He warns readers kindly that he will not overload them with statistics. (2) He gives one table with a clear title. (3) He states the big change in one sentence: from 565,000 to 31,000,000 long tons. (4) He names a turning point: 1887. (5) He ends with one striking record.
Worked example 1: checking the text against the table. Zoe checks Spring’s claim. In 1880 the table shows the U.S. at 3,835,000 tons and Great Britain at 7,749,000. In 1890: U.S. 9,000,000, Britain 7,904,000. The table supports a switch between 1880 and 1890, which fits Spring’s 1887.
Worked example 2: a footnote matters. Kai wonders why furnace height stops at about 100 feet after 1900. The footnote explains: “No advantage has been found in furnaces having a height of over 110 feet.” Small text features can answer big questions.
A model museum label (my own writing). Record Breaker: Duquesne. Blast furnaces grew from about 30 feet tall in 1850 to 90-100 feet by 1910. By 1917, a U.S. Steel furnace at Duquesne held the record: 900 tons of pig iron in one day. (Source: La Verne W. Spring, 1917.) Notice: a short title, two exact numbers, a date and a source.
Evaluating. Ask whether the table is clear, whether the sentences match it and what a reader still needs. Spring’s table shows output but not the workers who produced it; our labels can fill that gap.
Use the table and the paragraphs below it.
Write like a museum.
Write your own museum label (40-60 words) using numbers from Spring's table or from Epstein's charts (2.07). Checklist: (1) a short title, (2) one or two exact numbers with units and years, (3) one sentence on why it matters, (4) the source and year in parentheses.
Evaluate Spring's table in 3-4 sentences: What does it show well? What does it leave out that our exhibit should add?
Numbers, chosen well, tell a story. Next we bring our reading together and check what we have learned.
Exit ticket: write one number from this unit you would put on a label, and its source.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, label and evaluation 10.
Text note: the table is copied cell by cell from the Gutenberg file; the column headings are joined into one row and the footnote marker after “Height” is replaced by the footnote shown below the table. Blank cells are blank in the source. Spring’s “to date” means 1917 or shortly before.
Math check: 1880 U.S. 3,835,000 versus Britain 7,749,000; 1890 U.S. 9,000,000 versus Britain 7,904,000. Spring’s sentence calls the 1913 figure 31,000,000 long tons.
Likely misconceptions: that every number in a table must appear in a label; that the table measures steel (it measures pig iron); that a blank cell means zero.
Supports: highlight the U.S. column; label template on a card. Stretch: calculate about how many times U.S. production grew from 1850 to 1913 (about 55 times).
Sample label: Growing Giants. In 1850 an average American blast furnace made 29 tons of iron a day. By 1900 it made 600. Bigger furnaces helped the United States become the world’s top pig iron producer by 1887. (Source: La Verne W. Spring, 1917.)