cite several pieces of textual evidence to support an inference about a character, and explain how the weather and the dark help the author hide the truth.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A friend texts, “Fine.” and nothing else. What does the text say? What might you infer? What would you need to know before you were sure?
A tall man in a long overcoat, with his collar turned up to his ears, walks up to the waiting man. Who is he?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Several pieces of evidence. In grade 7 we do not stop at one quotation. A strong inference stands on two or three details that point the same way, like legs under a table.
Explicit or inferred? “About twenty minutes he waited” is explicit. Whether the tall man is really Jimmy is never stated in this passage, so any answer is an inference that you must support.
Worked example 1: stacking clues. Ana suspects the tall man. Clue 1: he asks, “Is that you, Bob?” doubtfully, as if he is not sure what Bob looks like. Clue 2: his collar is “turned up to his ears,” hiding his face. Clue 3: Bob says, “I never thought you were so tall by two or three inches.” Three clues, one inference.
Worked example 2: testing the other side. Ben argues it is Jimmy: the man knows Bob’s name and knows “The old restaurant’s gone.” Ana answers: the officer also knew the restaurant was gone, so anyone who knew the neighborhood could say that. Good readers weigh evidence on both sides.
Setting as a curtain. The rain and wind send people hurrying “with coat collars turned high.” That makes a turned-up collar look normal. The weather helps the author, and a character, hide a face.
A model paragraph. The tall man may not be Jimmy Wells. He asks “doubtfully” if it is Bob, his collar is turned up “to his ears,” and Bob notices he is taller than expected. Together these clues suggest the man is hiding his face and does not really know Bob.
Annotate as you go: S for stated, I for clues to an inference.
Make a three-column chart: The text says | So I infer | How sure am I?
Fill in three rows using exact quotations from the passage.
Write a 4-5 sentence response: What can you infer about the tall man? Checklist: a claim, at least two accurate quotations with lead-ins, an explanation for each, and a closing sentence.
We gathered clues the author planted. Next we read the ending and test our inferences.
Exit ticket: Which one clue convinced you most, and why?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 10, chart and response 9.
Do not confirm the answer yet. Students check their inferences against the ending in 1.04. Take a quick class vote and record it.
Likely misconceptions: that an inference is a guess with no support; that one quotation is “several pieces” of evidence; that explicit details cannot support an inference (they can).
Supports: pre-highlight the five key sentences; sentence frame “One clue is ___. Another clue is ___. Together they suggest ___.” Stretch: why might O. Henry have Bob notice the height difference but brush it off?
Answer guide: evidence that he is not Jimmy: asks “doubtfully”; collar “turned up to his ears”; “so tall by two or three inches”; he is vague (“a position in one of the city departments”). Evidence for Jimmy: he greets Bob by name, knows about the restaurant, and says “twenty years is a long time.” Sample response: The tall man is probably not Jimmy. He asks “Is that you, Bob?” doubtfully, which shows he is unsure of Bob’s face. Bob also says he never thought Jimmy was “so tall by two or three inches.” A man hiding behind a collar and unsure of his old friend’s face may be pretending.
O. Henry, The Four Million (1906), Project Gutenberg eBook #2776 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #2776
Where we are. The police officer has walked on. The man from the West, whose name we now learn is Bob, waits in the doorway in worse weather. Then a tall man hurries across the street.
What to notice. Some sentences tell you exactly what happens. That is explicit information. Other details make you figure something out, such as how the tall man asks his first question. That is an inference. Put an S beside explicit details and an I beside clues for an inference.
Words to know. A drizzle is a light, fine rain. Astir means moving about. A quarter here means a part of a city. Dismally means gloomily. Absurdity is foolishness. Doubtfully means in an unsure way. “Bully” is old slang for “great.” Moderately means fairly, not very.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the story and once with a pencil.
There was now a fine, cold drizzle falling, and the wind had risen from its uncertain puffs into a steady blow. The few foot passengers astir in that quarter hurried dismally and silently along with coat collars turned high and pocketed hands. And in the door of the hardware store the man who had come a thousand miles to fill an appointment, uncertain almost to absurdity, with the friend of his youth, smoked his cigar and waited.
About twenty minutes he waited, and then a tall man in a long overcoat, with collar turned up to his ears, hurried across from the opposite side of the street. He went directly to the waiting man.
“Is that you, Bob?” he asked, doubtfully.
“Is that you, Jimmy Wells?” cried the man in the door.
“Bless my heart!” exclaimed the new arrival, grasping both the other’s hands with his own. “It’s Bob, sure as fate. I was certain I’d find you here if you were still in existence. Well, well, well!—twenty years is a long time. The old restaurant’s gone, Bob; I wish it had lasted, so we could have had another dinner there. How has the West treated you, old man?”
“Bully; it has given me everything I asked it for. You’ve changed lots, Jimmy. I never thought you were so tall by two or three inches.”
“Oh, I grew a bit after I was twenty.”
“Doing well in New York, Jimmy?”
“Moderately. I have a position in one of the city departments. Come on, Bob; we’ll go around to a place I know of, and have a good long talk about old times.”
Source: O. Henry, The Four Million (1906), Project Gutenberg eBook #2776 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)