use details from a Library of Congress article about photographs of a New York street around 1900 to explain how a setting can shape characters’ choices.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Picture the same city block at 10 p.m. in cold rain and at noon on market day. List three differences. Which version would make it easier to slip away unseen? Which would make it easier to find help?
A photograph of Mulberry Street in New York around 1900 shows crowds, vehicles and shop signs. What language or languages do you predict on the signs?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Why read an informational text in a fiction unit? Real sources show us what places were actually like. Writers of historical stories study photographs and records so that their settings feel true.
Setting as a force. A setting is not just scenery. Who is around, how much light there is, what people can see and hear: all of these make some choices easier and others harder.
Worked example 1: comparing two streets. Gabe compares O. Henry’s avenue with Mulberry Street. O. Henry’s streets were “de-peopled” at night, with businesses “long since been closed.” Mulberry Street in the photographs is crowded, with markets and carts. Gabe infers: “On Mulberry Street at noon, Bob could never wait alone in a doorway unnoticed, and Jimmy could not have recognized him by the light of one match.” Change the setting and the plot cannot happen.
Worked example 2: from source to scene. Priya uses the article’s details, signs in two languages and blurred figures in motion, to imagine a character. A girl selling bread must choose between answering a customer in Italian or a policeman in English, all at once. The real setting gives her character a real kind of pressure.
Careful with sources. Use only what the source shows. The article tells us the signs were in Italian and English and the markets were crowded. It does not tell us any one person’s thoughts. Any character we create is our own invention, and we label it that way.
A model paragraph. A crowded setting can push a character toward a public choice. On Mulberry Street around 1900, crowds filled the markets and wheeled vehicles moved through the street, according to a Library of Congress blog post. A character there would be seen by many neighbors, so a choice like returning a dropped coin, or keeping it, would happen in front of witnesses. That is the opposite of O. Henry’s empty, rainy avenue.
Use the reading and the O. Henry passages from 1.01-1.04.
Plan a setting for your anthology story.
Write a 5-6 sentence paragraph comparing O. Henry's night avenue with Mulberry Street as described by the Library of Congress. Checklist: a claim about how each setting shapes what characters can do; one quotation from “After Twenty Years”; one detail from the article; reasoning for each.
Anthology seed: describe a real place you know (a street, a store, a park, a bus stop) at a specific time. What choice could that setting force a character to make?
Real places make real pressures. Next we compare two stories about giving and the choices behind them.
Exit ticket: in one sentence, how can the same place push a character toward different choices at different times of day?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, comparison and anthology seed 10.
Source note: the article was opened 2026-11-20. It shows Detroit Publishing Company images (det.4a08193, det.4a31829, det.4a09035, det.4a27268, det.4a27271); project them from loc.gov if possible. The item record for “Mulberry Street, New York City” (loc.gov/item/2016794146) states no known restrictions on publication. Check each item’s rights statement before printing any image in the anthology.
Respectful framing: present the neighborhood as a lively community of immigrant families and workers; avoid stereotypes in student stories, and remind students that invented characters set there should be people with full lives, not types.
Likely misconceptions: that informational texts have no place in fiction study; that a photo tells us what people were thinking; that setting is only scenery.
Supports: a two-column chart (night avenue / market street). Stretch: how might a writer use the blurred figures in a story?
Answer guide: sample comparison: O. Henry’s avenue is “de-peopled” by cold rain, so Bob can wait alone and Jimmy can study his face by one match. Mulberry Street, a Library of Congress blog post shows, was full of crowds and vehicles. In that setting a secret meeting would be seen by many people, so the empty night street is what makes the arrest possible.
Library of Congress, Picture This blog (Prints and Photographs Division), Melissa Lindberg, Views of Mulberry Street in Little Italy, June 13, 2024 · Library of Congress staff writing, a U.S. government work; the Detroit Publishing Company photographs it shows each carry their own rights statement at loc.gov
A Library of Congress expert, Melissa Lindberg, wrote about several photographs of Mulberry Street in New York City from around 1900 to 1910. The Detroit Publishing Company made them. The street was in the heart of a neighborhood known for its Italian influence, its immigrant community and its lively markets.
One photograph began as a glass negative, a photograph recorded on a sheet of glass. The company then made a color print called a photochrom. To make it, the photo was moved onto a printing surface, and each color was added with its own stone. Some detail was lost, but the color brought the scene to life. Up close, the negative shows the texture of clothing, people’s faces and wheel tracks in the dirt street.
In the pictures, Italian and English signs share the shop windows and street signs. Crowds fill the markets, and wheeled vehicles move through the street. In one view of a clam seller, a boy and a man are blurred because they were moving, a sign of how busy the street was.
Source: Library of Congress, Picture This blog (Prints and Photographs Division), Melissa Lindberg, Views of Mulberry Street in Little Italy, June 13, 2024 (blogs.loc.gov)