choose a graphic that helps visitors understand my topic, write a caption with a credit line, and add an entry to our class map and timeline.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Imagine a museum photograph of a row of old houses with no caption at all. Write two questions a visitor would have that a caption could answer.
What should a museum caption do that the photograph cannot do alone?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Graphics do work words cannot. Our standard asks you to “include graphics and multimedia when useful to aiding comprehension.” The key word is useful. A graphic earns its place when it shows something the visitor needs: what a furnace looked like, where a mill town sits on the river, or when events happened.
A strong caption has three parts. (1) What the visitor is looking at, with the place and date if known. (2) One fact or detail that explains why it matters. (3) A credit line: who made or owns the image and where it was published. Exhibit credit lines are often set in capital letters with a slash between the source and the maker, for example CHARITIES AND THE COMMONS, 1909 / JOSEPH STELLA. The Park Service’s style guide, which we use in 2.24, asks for credits in “All caps, small size, simple style,” and its examples put a slash between the owner and the maker (LIBRARY OF CONGRESS / EDWARD CURTIS).
Our class map. Each student adds one place label to a map of the Monongahela River valley: the town’s name, what happened there and the source. Braddock, Duquesne, McKeesport and Homestead all sit along the Monongahela. Our own East Allegheny communities lie nearby, along Turtle Creek and close to the Monongahela. Keep each map label to one sentence.
Our class timeline. Each student adds one dated entry. Use the present tense and a short sentence: 1907 Pittsburgh Survey researchers begin their study. Put entries in order; a timeline is organized by time, which is a kind of formatting that aids comprehension.
Worked example 1: Ana writes a caption. Ana’s label is about mill-town housing. The Survey’s caption reads, “BRADDOCK. Rubbish in rear yard of Willow Alley; where the children play.” She writes her own: A back yard on Willow Alley in Braddock, where children played among rubbish. The 1909 report noted two hydrants for thirty apartments. CHARITIES AND THE COMMONS, FEBRUARY 6, 1909. Place, fact and credit, in under 40 words.
Worked example 2: Jonah adds to the map and timeline. Jonah’s label is about Carnegie’s company store idea (note card F). His map label: Braddock: workers started the Braddock’s Cooperative Society, a store they managed (Carnegie, 1920). His timeline entry needs a date his source gives. Card F has none, so he chooses another fact with a date, from card G: 1908 Survey exhibit opens at Carnegie Institute. Never guess a date.
Study the captions. Use exact words as evidence.
Choose and caption your graphic, then add to the class exhibit.
Name the image, map or drawing you will use and its source. Then write your caption (15 to 40 words): what it shows, one fact that matters, and a credit line.
Write your class map label (place, what happened, source) and your timeline entry (year plus a present-tense sentence). Name the source of each date.
A caption is the second thing many visitors read, right after the title.
Exit ticket: what question will your graphic answer for a visitor that your words alone could not?
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture 9, guided practice 10, captions and map labels 9, closure 2.
Source note: the captions are copied from the February 6, 1909 issue. Two captions on the photo page (Schoen and McKeesport) are left out for length; the Stella drawing credit appears in italics in the original (“Drawn by Joseph Stella”). The original photographs are in the printed issue and scans of it; the Gutenberg text file holds only the captions. If students want the images, use the scan your library or Part 1 provides, or the HAER photographs from Part 1.
Care with the content: these captions describe crowded, unsanitary homes. Some students may live with housing stress today. Keep the focus on the conditions and on the people who worked to change them, never on blaming the families; the cellar-bedroom caption itself notes how families kept up standards.
Likely misconceptions: that any picture is a good graphic (it must aid comprehension); that a credit line is optional; that a timeline date can be estimated. Students may need help with old meanings: closets here are water closets, that is, toilets.
Answer guide: the heading groups the photographs into categories (types) of one problem, so the reader compares them; choosing several towns shows the problem was widespread, not limited to one place. Sample caption: “Painter’s Row in spring 1908, company houses beside a Carnegie Steel mill on Pittsburgh’s South Side. About 500 people lived here. CHARITIES AND THE COMMONS, FEBRUARY 6, 1909 / JOSEPH STELLA.”
Project Gutenberg, Charities and the Commons: The Pittsburgh Survey, Part II: The Place (February 6, 1909), eBook #46025, photograph page and F. Elisabeth Crowell, “Painter’s Row” · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
The February 6, 1909 issue of the Pittsburgh Survey was about the place: streets, water, health and housing. It printed a page of photographs titled “Four Types of Housing Ills in Mill Towns,” with pictures from Duquesne, Braddock and other towns. It also printed F. Elisabeth Crowell’s report on Painter’s Row, a group of company houses on Pittsburgh’s South Side, with photographs and a drawing by the artist Joseph Stella.
Our text file shows the captions but not the pictures. Read the captions as a visitor would: what place, what detail, what fact? Notice that a caption often begins with a short heading in capital letters.
Words to know: a hydrant is an outdoor water faucet or pipe; vaults here means outdoor pit toilets; tenements are crowded apartment buildings; inspection means a careful official visit to check conditions; closets here means toilets; operatives means workers who run machines.
FOUR TYPES OF HOUSING ILLS IN MILL TOWNS
DUQUESNE: Filthy wooden-drain and yard hydrant.
BRADDOCK. Rubbish in rear yard of Willow Alley; where the children play. Two hydrants and two vaults are expected to equip thirty apartments.
PAINTER’S ROW
Drawn by Joseph Stella. PAINTER’S ROW AS IT STOOD IN THE SPRING OF 1908.
WEST CARSON STREET AT TIME OF FIRST INSPECTION. Tenements of Painter’s Row at left; nine families on first and second floors without toilet accommodations. One-family houses at right.
CELLAR BED ROOM. Windows entirely below passage level, showing how some households maintain standards against difficulties.
THE “TOWN PUMP.” Drinking water supply for 568 people living in Painter’s Row; and for the operatives in the mill.
WHERE THE TENEMENTS WERE TORN DOWN. Present site of row shown in picture on opposite page. Closets and sinks installed in topmost row, tenants of which formerly had to go 360 steps to get water.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Charities and the Commons: The Pittsburgh Survey, Part II: The Place (February 6, 1909), eBook #46025, photograph page and F. Elisabeth Crowell, “Painter’s Row” (gutenberg.pglaf.org)