revise my narrative for purpose and audience, then edit it for grade 7 conventions, especially dialogue punctuation, commas, verb tense and pronouns.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Find and fix the four errors: “Were going to miss it” said Maya, she grabbed her bag and runs for the door.
Which should a writer do first?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revise, then edit. Revising changes what the story says and how: adding a sensory detail, moving a scene, cutting a slow paragraph. Editing corrects conventions so nothing distracts the reader. Our audience will hold a printed book, so every comma counts.
Dialogue patterns from Saki. (1) Tag after: “I don’t agree with you,” said the bachelor. (2) Tag interrupting one sentence: “Once upon a time,” began the bachelor, “there was a little girl …”, with a comma before the tag, a comma after it and a lowercase there. (3) Question with a tag: “Was she pretty?” asked the bigger of the small girls. The question mark replaces the comma. (4) New speaker, new paragraph.
Five grade 7 edits to hunt for. (1) Fragments and run-ons: every sentence needs a subject and a verb, and two sentences need a period or a joining word, not just a comma. (2) Verb tense shifts: a past-tense story stays in the past. (3) Pronouns: make sure each he, she or it points to one clear person or thing, and do not shift from I to you. (4) Commas: use commas in a series and between coordinate adjectives (a hard, unsympathetic man), and use commas, dashes or parentheses around extra information. (5) Confused words: their/there/they’re, its/it’s, then/than, your/you’re.
A note on style. Saki’s list “She did all that she was told, she was always truthful, she kept her clothes clean …” joins several clauses with commas. In a spoken list inside quotation marks, it imitates a storyteller rattling off Bertha’s virtues. In your own narration, avoid comma splices unless you can explain the effect.
Worked example 1: Noah edits a dialogue line. Noah wrote: “If we take the shortcut” Jada said “We’ll beat the rain.” He adds a comma inside the first closing mark, a comma after the tag, and lowercase we’ll: “If we take the shortcut,” Jada said, “we’ll beat the rain.”
Worked example 2: Sara fixes a vague pronoun and a tense shift. Sara wrote: When Mom and Aunt Lin argued about the move, she slammed the door, and I run outside. Who slammed the door? And run shifts to present. She revises: When Mom and Aunt Lin argued about the move, Aunt Lin slammed the door, and I ran outside.
Edit each item, then use the same moves on your own draft.
Revise, then edit, your own anthology narrative.
Revision pass: reread your draft with your revision plan from 1.22 and the checklist. Make at least two revisions for purpose and audience (for example, add a sensory detail at the crossroads, cut a slow paragraph, sharpen the reflection). In your revision log, write each change and why a family reader will benefit. Check that your voice stays consistent from the first line to the last.
Editing pass: read your draft aloud, one sentence at a time, starting from the end. Fix every dialogue line, run-on, fragment, tense shift, vague pronoun and confused word. Copy three sentences you edited (before and after) and name the rule for each.
A clean draft lets readers notice your story, not your mistakes.
Exit ticket: which convention did you fix most often in your draft? Write a one-sentence reminder to yourself for next time.
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture 10, guided practice 9, revision and editing passes 15, closure 2. Students who finish early can begin typing their final copy.
Flex lesson: this is the revision lesson. Confer with students whose drafts are missing a checklist item before they edit, and pull a small group for dialogue punctuation.
Likely misconceptions: that revising and editing are the same; that a comma can join two sentences; that every question in dialogue also needs a comma. Students may copy Saki’s comma list into their narration; discuss when a writer’s choice is deliberate.
Content note: the bachelor’s tale goes on to have a wolf eat Bertha, which the children love. That scene is not shown; the story’s ending is read in 1.26.
Supports: give an editing checklist with one row per convention and a dialogue punctuation card. Allow text-to-speech for the read-aloud pass. Stretch: find two places in your draft where a dash or parentheses could set off extra information, and try them.
Answer key: Do Now: “We’re going to miss it,” said Maya. She grabbed her bag and ran for the door. (Errors: Were for We’re, missing comma inside the quotation, comma splice, tense shift runs.) Quiz: 1 = B, 2 = D, 3 = C, 4 = A, 5 = B. Fill-in: we’re, its. The revision log and edited sentences assess CC.1.4.7.Q, R and T.
Project Gutenberg, Beasts and Super-Beasts by Saki (H. H. Munro) (1914), eBook #269: "The Story-Teller" · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
We return to Saki’s “The Story-Teller” (1914). On the hot train, the aunt has just told the children a dull story about a good little girl who was saved from a mad bull because everyone admired her. The children hated it. Now the silent bachelor in the corner finally speaks, and the aunt challenges him to do better.
As you read, look closely at punctuation: where the commas and quotation marks go when a tag interrupts a sentence, and how Saki punctuates a long list. Notice too the narrator’s dry, slightly mocking voice, which stays the same from the first sentence of the story to the last. British spellings such as defence and favour are correct in British English.
Words to know: bristled means became angry and defensive; retort means a quick, sharp reply; extraordinarily means unusually; momentarily means for a moment; a novelty is something new and unusual; commended itself means won approval.
“You don’t seem to be a success as a story-teller,” said the bachelor suddenly from his corner.
The aunt bristled in instant defence at this unexpected attack.
“It’s a very difficult thing to tell stories that children can both understand and appreciate,” she said stiffly.
“I don’t agree with you,” said the bachelor.
“Perhaps you would like to tell them a story,” was the aunt’s retort.
“Tell us a story,” demanded the bigger of the small girls.
“Once upon a time,” began the bachelor, “there was a little girl called Bertha, who was extraordinarily good.”
The children’s momentarily-aroused interest began at once to flicker; all stories seemed dreadfully alike, no matter who told them.
“She did all that she was told, she was always truthful, she kept her clothes clean, ate milk puddings as though they were jam tarts, learned her lessons perfectly, and was polite in her manners.”
“Was she pretty?” asked the bigger of the small girls.
“Not as pretty as any of you,” said the bachelor, “but she was horribly good.”
There was a wave of reaction in favour of the story; the word horrible in connection with goodness was a novelty that commended itself. It seemed to introduce a ring of truth that was absent from the aunt’s tales of infant life.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Beasts and Super-Beasts by Saki (H. H. Munro) (1914), eBook #269: "The Story-Teller" (gutenberg.pglaf.org)