analyze how Paul Kellogg’s introduction organizes the Pittsburgh Survey into major sections and graphics, and write an objective summary of it.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. An engineer’s blueprint shows a building before it is built. What would a “blueprint” of our town show? List three things.
In 1908 the Pittsburgh Survey team showed its findings to the public. What do you predict was the main feature of their exhibit?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Structure is a plan. Long informational texts are built from major sections. A good introduction tells readers the plan so they know how the parts fit together. Kellogg’s plan has three parts: I. The People; II. The Place; III. The Work.
Graphics are part of the plan. Kellogg promises “photographs, pastels, maps, charts, diagrams and tables” to give “substance and reality” to the facts. Graphics are not extras; they help prove and explain.
Worked example 1: what a section order tells you. Chloe notices that The People comes first, before The Work. She infers that the Survey wanted readers to meet the people before reading about industry, just as Fitch put the workers’ own voices first.
Worked example 2: an objective summary. Sam’s first try says, “Kellogg wrote a boring intro about a great survey.” Two opinions, no central idea. His revision: Paul Kellogg explains that the Pittsburgh Survey was a fast, close-up study of living conditions in the steel district, paid for mainly by the Russell Sage Foundation. Its findings would appear in three magazine issues on the people, the place and the work, supported by photographs, maps, charts and tables. The Survey also showed maps, photographs and housing plans in a public exhibit at Carnegie Institute.
Summary checklist. Names the author and text; states the central ideas in order; uses your own words; includes only key details; adds no opinions or extra facts.
Connecting to our project. Our museum label set is a small exhibit too. Like the Survey, it needs a clear plan of sections (objects, map, timeline) and graphics that support the words.
Number the parts of the passage, then answer.
Summary and exhibit plan.
Write an objective summary of Kellogg's passage in 4-5 sentences. Use the summary checklist and underline each central idea.
Exhibit plan: sketch the structure of our museum label set in three sections (objects, map, timeline). For each, name one graphic you would use and what it would help visitors understand.
A plan, three sections and graphics that prove. Next we study how a writer turns a table of numbers into clear sentences, as our labels must.
Exit ticket: which section of our label set will be hardest to make, and why?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, summary and plan 10.
Text note: the cuts skip the paragraph extending the blueprint comparison, the paragraph on who helped the Survey and what earlier studies missed, and the paragraph on local reforms. The file prints the three parts on separate lines; they appear on one line here. The last item is the caption of an illustration (“Scheme of the Pittsburgh Survey”) in the magazine; the picture itself is not in the text file.
Context: the full reports became six volumes (1909-1914), including Fitch’s The Steel Workers and Byington’s Homestead.
Likely misconceptions: that a summary retells everything; that “objective” means short; that graphics are decoration.
Supports: a summary frame (“In ___, ___ explains that ___. It also ___. Finally, ___.”). Stretch: Kellogg admits limits of time and money elsewhere in the introduction. Why might an honest writer state limits?
Answer guide: see Sam’s revised summary. Structure: people first signals that human conditions are the Survey’s focus; Fitch’s article in this same issue lets workers speak first.
Paul U. Kellogg, in Charities and the Commons, vol. XXI, no. 14 (January 2, 1909): The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I, The People, Project Gutenberg eBook #46029 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #46029
About the text. Paul U. Kellogg directed the Pittsburgh Survey. His introduction opens the January 2, 1909, issue that also printed the Fitch and Byington articles. He explains what the Survey is, who paid for it and how its findings will be published.
What to notice. Kellogg uses a comparison: the Survey is a blueprint of Pittsburgh. He lists the three parts of the report and the kinds of graphics it will use. He also describes a public exhibit. Number the parts of the passage as you read.
Words to know. Draughted is an older spelling of drafted, meaning drawn as a plan. The headwaters of the Ohio is where the Allegheny and Monongahela rivers meet at Pittsburgh. A ten league canvas is an enormous painting, a phrase Kellogg borrows from the writer Rudyard Kipling. Special numbers are special issues of a magazine. Pastels are chalk drawings. A civic exhibit is a public display about a city.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big ideas and once with a pencil.
God and man and nature,–whosoever you will,–have draughted a mighty and irregular industrial community at the headwaters of the Ohio; they have splashed, as Kipling puts it, at a ten league canvas with brushes of comet’s hair. Under the name of the Pittsburgh Survey, Charities Publication Committee has carried on a group of social investigations in this great steel district. In a sense, we have been blue-printing Pittsburgh. Our findings will be published in a series of special numbers of which this is the first, covering in order:
I.–The People; II.–The Place; III.–The Work.
Full reports are to be published later in a series of volumes by the Russell Sage Foundation and, throughout, the text will be reinforced with such photographs, pastels, maps, charts, diagrams and tables as will help give substance and reality to our presentations of fact.
[…]
The Pittsburgh Survey has been a rapid, close range investigation of living conditions in the Pennsylvania steel district. It has been carried on by a special staff organized under the national publication committee which prints this magazine. It has been financed chiefly by three grants, of moderate amount, from the Russell Sage Foundation for the Improvement of Living Conditions.
[…]
A display of wall maps, enlarged photographs, housing plans, and other graphic material was the chief feature of a civic exhibit held in Carnegie Institute in November and December, following the joint conventions in Pittsburgh of the American Civic Association and the National Municipal League.
[Illustration: SCHEME OF THE PITTSBURGH SURVEY.
From Pittsburgh Civic Exhibit, Carnegie Institute, November-December, 1908.]
Source: Paul U. Kellogg, in Charities and the Commons, vol. XXI, no. 14 (January 2, 1909): The Pittsburgh Survey, Part I, The People, Project Gutenberg eBook #46029 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)