write a title and an opening that introduce my topic clearly and preview what my label will explain.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Which title would make you stop at an exhibit? (A) “Information About Steel Furnaces” (B) “Fire That Never Went Out: Inside a Blast Furnace.” Write one reason.
What makes title B stronger than title A?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A visitor decides in seconds. Park Service writers told us that many visitors read only the title. So the title and the first sentences of your main label carry the most weight. Today you will write both.
A strong title does two jobs. It names the topic, and it makes the reader curious. Many exhibit titles have two parts joined by a colon: a short hook, then a clear subject. The Long Turn: When a Shift Lasted 24 Hours. The hook catches the eye; the subject tells what the label is about.
An opening introduces and previews. Our standard asks you to introduce the topic clearly and include “a preview of what is to follow.” A magazine can preview a whole issue, as the Survey editors do. In a 200-word label, the preview is usually one sentence that tells the visitor what the label will explain.
Three ways to hook a visitor. (1) A picture in the mind: Picture finishing a full day of work and then staying all night, too. (2) A surprising fact: 568 people shared one water pump. (3) A striking image, like the editors’ “corrugated floor” for Pittsburgh’s hills and valleys. Avoid openings such as “This label is about…”
Worked example 1: Mateo revises a flat opening. Mateo’s first draft begins, This label is about the stoves at a blast furnace. He tries a surprising fact from note card C instead: Before air ever reached the fire, it passed through a stove hotter than an oven: up to 1400 degrees Fahrenheit. Then he adds a preview: Here is how four giant stoves kept a furnace roaring day and night.
Worked example 2: Leah tests her title. Leah drafts three titles for her Painter’s Row label: Housing; A Bad Place to Live; 360 Steps for a Drink of Water: Life in Painter’s Row. The first is too vague and the second is an opinion. The third names the place and makes a reader curious, so she keeps it.
Look at the structure of the editors’ opening. Topic first (“physical necessities of a wage earning population”), then the subjects in a row, then what comes next. A reader knows what the issue holds before the first article begins.
Use the editors’ opening, then practice on sample openings.
Draft the top of your label.
Write three possible titles for your label, each using a different hook. Circle your best and explain why it does both jobs.
Write the first two or three sentences of your main label: a hook, a clear statement of the topic and a one-sentence preview. Label each part.
The editors previewed a whole magazine in one paragraph. You need one strong sentence.
Exit ticket: read your opening to a partner. Ask: what do you expect the rest of my label to explain? Write their answer. Did your preview work?
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 8, mini lecture 9, guided practice 10, drafting 7, closure 2.
Source note: the passage is the editors’ “Introductory to This Issue” and the issue’s headnote, from the February 6, 1909 issue. Cuts: the second sentence, which contrasts the city with what “primitive men have ready to hand” (dated framing, not needed); two paragraphs about city government; and a note on later school and playground studies. Part 1 read Kellogg’s introduction to the first issue (2.12); this part does not reprint it. The quiz options quote the openings of sentences; the full sentences are in the passage.
Likely misconceptions: that a preview must be a numbered list (in a short label, one sentence works); that a clever title can leave out the topic; that a question hook is always strong (a question the visitor cannot answer may lose them).
Supports: provide title frames (“___: How ___”; “___: The Story of ___”). Let students say their opening aloud before writing. Stretch: write an opening that previews two causes or two comparisons the label will explain.
Answer guide: a proficient opening names the topic within two sentences, hooks with a scene, fact or image drawn from a source, and previews what the label explains. Sample: “Imagine carrying your drinking water down seventy-five stairs. At Painter’s Row, some families walked 360 steps to the only pump. This label explains how one row of company houses on Pittsburgh’s South Side got all its drinking water from a single pump.” (Check that the number students quote, 360, matches note card E.)
Project Gutenberg, Charities and the Commons: The Pittsburgh Survey, Part II: The Place (February 6, 1909), eBook #46025, editors’ introduction · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
In Part 1 you read Paul Kellogg’s introduction to the first Pittsburgh Survey issue, “The People.” This passage opens the second issue, “The Place,” printed on February 6, 1909. The editors had a big job: to tell readers what a whole magazine issue about air, water, health and housing would cover, before any article began.
Notice how they work. One sentence names the topic. A long sentence then previews the subjects of the articles inside, joined by “thus we have.” The last lines preview the third issue and list all three. You will meet Painter’s Row, named here, in 2.18 and 2.20.
Words to know: wage earning means working for pay; a campaign is an organized effort to reach a goal; typhoid is a disease spread by dirty water; sanitary means clean and healthy; squatters are people living on land they do not own; traction here means streetcar lines; corrugated means folded into ridges, like cardboard; the gist is the main point.
PITTSBURGH SURVEY
INTRODUCTORY TO THIS ISSUE
This second Pittsburgh issue deals with certain physical necessities of a wage earning population.
[…]
Thus we have in Pittsburgh a smoke campaign, a typhoid movement and the administrative problems of the Bureau of Health in milk and meat inspection; thus we have the necessity for sanitary regulation of dwellings wherever people live dense or deep, whether squatters’ shanties such as those of Skunk Hollow or company houses such as those of Painter’s Row, whether city tenements or mill-town lodgings; and the necessity further for increased numbers of low-cost dwellings. Similarly, flood prevention, traction development, bridge building and the like are so many efforts to expand, or conquer the difficulties of, the town’s corrugated floor.
[…]
In the third and final issue of the series, that of March 2, the emphasis will be transferred from the civic to the industrial well-being of the wage-earning population,–the vital and irrepressible issues of hours, wages, factory inspection, accidents and the cost of living.
[…]
The second of three special issues of Charities and The Commons, presenting the gist of the findings of the Pittsburgh Survey, as to conditions of life and labor among the wage-earning population of the Pennsylvania Steel District.
I. JANUARY 2-THE PEOPLE. II. FEBRUARY 6-THE PLACE. III. MARCH 2-THE WORK.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Charities and the Commons: The Pittsburgh Survey, Part II: The Place (February 6, 1909), eBook #46025, editors’ introduction (gutenberg.pglaf.org)