revise my label for content, then edit it for grammar, punctuation, spelling and the Park Service’s exhibit style.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Find three errors: “In 1909 their were ninety-one households at painter’s row, they shared one pump.” Rewrite the sentence correctly.
Which is the correct version?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revise, then edit. Revising changes what you say: facts, order, words, ending. Editing fixes how it looks: grammar, punctuation, capitals and spelling. Do your revision first; there is no point polishing a sentence you are about to cut.
Follow the house style. Publishers choose rules and use them every time. Our exhibit follows the Park Service guide: a comma before and in a series of three or more; numbers one through nine spelled out and 10 or greater in figures, unless the number begins a sentence; commas in numbers over 999 but not in years; dates as month, day, year; timeline entries in the present tense, ending with a period.
Grade 7 grammar checks. (1) Pronoun shifts: do not switch from “workers” to “you.” (2) Verb tense shifts: history labels usually stay in the past tense. (3) Fragments and run-ons: every sentence needs a subject and a verb, and two sentences need a period or a semicolon, not a comma. (4) Confused words: there, their, they’re; its, it’s. (5) Commas around extra information: F. Elisabeth Crowell, a former hospital superintendent, studied the row.
Worked example 1: Aaliyah edits for style. Her sentence: On February 6 1909 the survey reported 568 people 91 households and 1 pump in the mill yard. She applies three rules. Dates: a comma after the day and after the year. Commas: a comma between items in the series, including before and. Numbers: 1 becomes one. Edited: On February 6, 1909, the survey reported 568 people, 91 households, and one pump in the mill yard.
Worked example 2: Devon fixes shifts. His draft: When a furnace worker finished the long turn, you are exhausted. Two problems: the pronoun shifts from worker to you, and the tense shifts from finished to are. Edited: When a furnace worker finished the long turn, he was exhausted.
Read aloud last. Read your label aloud with a timer. Your ear catches missing words and tangled sentences that your eye skips. Aim for about 60 seconds.
Use the style guide entries and the grammar checks.
Revise, then edit your label set.
Revision pass: use your revision plan from 2.22. Make each planned change and record it in your revision log (old version, new version, reason).
Editing pass: check your label, caption, timeline entry and map label with the style rules and the five grammar checks. Then read the label aloud with a timer and write the time.
Editors are the last readers before the public. Today you were your own.
Exit ticket: what was the most important error you caught today, and how did you catch it?
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture 8, guided practice 10, revision and editing 10, closure 2. Students who finish early can edit a partner’s caption.
Source note: entries are copied from the HFC Editorial Style Guide page; the guide is long, so only the entries shown are used. Its commas entry calls for the serial comma; our lesson prose elsewhere does not always use one, so explain that a publisher chooses a house style and an exhibit follows its partner’s rules. The guide’s entries also include “racist language: Do not use” and capitalize “Black” when it refers to culture or identity, which match the choices this unit made.
Likely misconceptions: that editing and revising are the same; that a comma can join two sentences; that historic quotations should be “corrected” (never change words inside quotation marks).
Supports: give a one-page editing checklist with the style rules and grammar checks. Let students edit with a colored pen, one rule per color. Stretch: write a short “house style” for our exhibit with five rules and an example of each.
Answer guide: edited caption: “The town pump served 568 people at Painter’s Row. In 1908, it was their only source of drinking water.” Changes: capital T and capital P; Painter’s needs an apostrophe; “the town pump, it” repeats the subject; the run-on is split into two sentences; a comma follows the introductory year (optional by the guide for short phrases). Crowell’s visits were in the winter of 1908, so 1908 fits.
National Park Service, Harpers Ferry Center: HFC Editorial Style Guide · U.S. government work (National Park Service), public domain
The writer-editors at Harpers Ferry Center keep this style guide for anyone who writes National Park Service exhibits, signs and brochures. The page says it aims to reduce distractions caused by inconsistent spelling, capitals and hyphens, and to remove derogatory, racist and outdated language. It is arranged like a dictionary, with one entry per topic.
We selected the entries our labels need most: commas, numbers, dates, dashes, quotations in exhibits and timeline format. Each entry gives a rule and sometimes an example. Read them as a checklist for editing.
Words to know: a conjunction is a joining word such as and or but; independent clauses are word groups that could stand alone as sentences; cardinal numbers are counting numbers (one, two, 15); chronology means events in time order; abbreviate means to shorten; a sentence fragment is an incomplete sentence.
Selected entries from the HFC Editorial Style Guide
+ commas Use a comma before the conjunction (and, or) in a series of three or more items (a style known as the serial or Oxford comma). Use a comma before words that join two independent clauses. Unless needed for clarity, omit comma after short introductory phrases.
numbers
In narrative text, spell out cardinal numbers one through nine; use figures for 10 or greater; spell out at the beginning of a sentence (regardless of amount), or rewrite. Sometimes OK to vary this rule, depending on context. Be consistent in the publication. See fractions, measurements in text, measurements on maps, percent.
Use commas in numbers greater than 999 (but not in dates). See dates.
dates Write dates in this order: month, day, year. Use a comma before and after the year in sentences with full dates; no comma if using only month and year in a sentence. No apostrophe in plural dates. See BCE, BP, CE, century, eras.
Em dash—Longer than en dash or hyphen, often called simply “the dash.” Indicates a sudden change in thought or adds emphasis. Do not put a space before or after the em dash.
En dash–Longer than a hyphen and shorter than an em dash. Means “to,” “up to and including,” or “through.” Do not put a space before or after the en dash.
quotations in exhibits Avoid italics. Use quotation marks instead, especially for quotations of more than a few words. When italics are used, be sure the italic font is easy to read. Quotes can also be distinguished from other text by using a different font, a different weight of the same font, a different color, or some other graphic treatment.
chronology or timeline format Capitalize first word and end with period—even if entry is a sentence fragment. Write in present tense. Abbreviate words and eliminate articles when possible without introducing confusion. Separate the year and content using your office’s preferred style. Unigrids use the style below.
1883 Organizes Black student school strike, first such response in United States to unequal treatment.
Source: National Park Service, Harpers Ferry Center: HFC Editorial Style Guide (nps.gov)