choose a topic for my museum label set, name my audience and purpose, and plan my label with advice from National Park Service exhibit writers.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think of the last sign you read at a museum, a park or a historic site. Did you read every word, or only the title and the picture? Write one sentence about what made you stop, or keep walking.
National Park Service exhibit writers plan for how long a visitor stays at an outdoor exhibit sign. What do you predict they plan for?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Writers, welcome to Build. In Part 1 you read like researchers: you found central ideas, cited evidence and compared how authors told the story of steel. Now you will write like museum professionals. Our class is creating an exhibit, Steel Valley: How Work Built Our Towns, which we will offer to the public library or a local historical society. Real visitors, many of them from families who worked in the mills, will read what you write.
Your task. Each of you will write one label set about one topic, object or image from the steel era: a title, a main label of 150 to 220 words, a caption with a credit line and a “Words to know” box. You will also add one dated entry to our class timeline and one place label to our class map. At Exhibit Day you will give a 60-second docent talk, the way a museum guide does.
What informative writing is. An informative text examines a topic: it explains what something is, how it worked and why it matters, using facts a reader can trust. It does not argue for one side, and it does not invent a story. Your purpose is to help a visitor understand.
Study our mentor label. A mentor text is a model we study to learn craft. Ours was written for this unit. Notice how it begins with a picture in the visitor’s mind, explains a cause, compares two jobs and ends by telling the visitor why the topic matters.
Mentor label set (written for our class)
Title: The Long Turn: When a Shift Lasted 24 Hours
Main label: Picture finishing a full day of work and then staying all night, too. In 1909, a blast-furnace boss whom researcher John A. Fitch calls Jack Griswold told Fitch that he had worked a twelve-hour day, seven days a week, for twenty years.
Griswold’s crew worked days for two weeks and nights for the next two. To switch, one crew worked the “long turn”: from seven on Sunday morning until Monday morning, 24 hours straight. Why not simply close the furnace at night? A blast furnace never stops. In 1917, steel chemist La Verne W. Spring wrote that loads of coke, iron ore and limestone go into it “day and night, month in and month out.”
Not every steelworker kept these hours. Fitch learned that Bessemer steel pourers worked eight-hour shifts, because the heat was too great for longer ones. Griswold wished for the same: “if we had eight hours it would be different.”
Today, many people expect an eight-hour workday. The long turn shows how hard the Pittsburgh district’s furnace crews once worked, and why so many of them wanted shorter days.
Caption: A man lit by the glow of a five-ton ingot, a block of hot steel. Artist Joseph Stella drew him for the Pittsburgh Survey’s “Pittsburgh Types.” CHARITIES AND THE COMMONS, JANUARY 2, 1909 / JOSEPH STELLA
Words to know: blast furnace, a tall furnace where a blast of hot air helps melt iron out of iron ore; long turn, a 24-hour shift worked when two crews traded day and night shifts.
Timeline entry: 1909 Pittsburgh Survey reports twelve-hour days, seven days a week, at blast furnaces.
Worked example 1: Darnell narrows his topic. Darnell starts with “steel mills,” which is far too big for 200 words. He asks the exhibit writers’ question: what can a visitor learn in under a minute? He narrows to one machine, then to one part: the “stoves” that heat the air for a blast furnace. Note card C gives him two facts. Now his label has a clear focus.
Worked example 2: Priya writes a purpose statement. The Park Service writers compare drafts to a purpose statement. Priya writes hers before drafting: Visitors will understand that the only drinking water for 568 people at Painter’s Row came from one pump, and why that mattered. Every sentence she writes later must serve that purpose.
Our sources and checklist. Use the note cards below and the readings in each lesson. Choose a topic from the bank. Our ten-item checklist is how visitors, partners and your teacher will judge every label.
| Card | What the source says (our words, with exact quotations in quotation marks) |
|---|---|
| A. Fitch, 1909 | A furnace boss Fitch calls Jack Griswold had worked a twelve-hour day, seven days a week, for twenty years. Every two weeks the crews switched between day and night shifts, and one crew worked a 24-hour “long turn.” He said, “if we had eight hours it would be different.” |
| B. Fitch, 1909 | Bessemer steel pourers worked eight hours a day, six days a week. Two Pittsburgh mills tried twelve-hour days in the converting department and went back to eight hours because of the heat. |
| C. Spring, 1917 | The blast furnace he describes is a steel shell lined two or three feet thick with fire bricks. Four “stoves” heat the air blast to 800 to 1400 degrees F. The hot-blast idea came from James Neilson about 1830. |
| D. Spring, 1917 | Coke, iron ore and limestone are loaded in turn, “day and night, month in and month out.” Laborers called buggy-pushers work twelve-hour shifts at the top. |
| E. Crowell, 1909 | At Painter’s Row, Carnegie Steel Company houses on Pittsburgh’s South Side, about 500 people lived in crowded rooms. Their only drinking water was an old pump in the mill yard, 360 steps from the farthest apartment, for 91 households (568 people). |
| F. Carnegie, 1920 | After a worker named Billy Edwards spoke up, the company paid the men every two weeks instead of monthly, sold them coal at cost and helped start the Braddock’s Cooperative Society, a store the men ran. He wrote, “No expenditure returned such dividends as the friendship of our workmen.” |
| G. Kellogg, 1909 | The Pittsburgh Survey began in September 1907 and studied living conditions in the steel district. A civic exhibit at Carnegie Institute showed its wall maps, enlarged photographs and housing plans in November and December 1908. |
| H. Epstein, 1918 | When European immigration stopped after the war began, steel mills and railroads recruited Black workers from the South. In twenty Pittsburgh-district industries, Black workers rose from 2,550 in 1915 to 8,325 in 1917. |
| Label topic | Note cards to start with |
|---|---|
| Inside the blast furnace: stoves, bustle pipe and tuyères | C, D |
| Twelve-hour days and the long turn | A, B, D |
| Company housing: Painter’s Row | E, G |
| Payday, coal and the Braddock’s Cooperative Society | F, E |
| The Pittsburgh Survey: researchers with cameras and sketchbooks | G, A, E |
| Coming north for steel work, 1915-1917 | H, G |
You may also choose a photograph or drawing from Part 1 of this unit, if you can find two sources about it.
| # | Label checklist | Standard |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | My title names my topic and makes a visitor curious. | B |
| 2 | My opening introduces the topic clearly and previews what the label will explain; my most powerful sentence is near the start. | B |
| 3 | I develop the topic with relevant facts and concrete details from at least two sources. | C |
| 4 | I define at least one technical word for my reader. | C |
| 5 | I include one short, accurate quotation in quotation marks and name who said or wrote it. | C |
| 6 | My graphic (picture, map or timeline) helps the reader, and its caption has a credit line. | C |
| 7 | I organize with a clear strategy: definition, classification, comparison and contrast, or cause and effect. | D |
| 8 | Transitions connect my ideas, and my last sentence answers “So what?” for a visitor. | D |
| 9 | I use precise words and topic vocabulary, vary my sentences and keep a consistent, formal voice. | E |
| 10 | Grammar, capitals, punctuation and spelling are correct, and my label can be read aloud in about 60 seconds. | F |
Constraints: main label 150 to 220 words; caption 15 to 40 words; two or three Words to know. Every fact must come from a source you can name. Your title and your first name will appear on the label. Also write one timeline entry and one map label for the class exhibit.
Use the reading and the mentor label. Talk with a partner before the open questions.
Plan your label set.
Choose your topic from the bank. Name the note cards you will start with. Then narrow your topic as Darnell did: big topic, smaller topic, focus.
Write your purpose statement: “Visitors will understand that …” Then list three questions a visitor might ask about your topic.
Some visitors will read only your title. Make it count.
Exit ticket: write a possible title for your label. Who in our audience might stop to read it, and why?
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 8, mini lecture with the mentor label 10, guided practice 10, planning 6, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that an informative label should include everything known about a topic (choose a focus); that a label is an opinion piece; that a visitor reads from top to bottom like a textbook. Confirm the exhibit partner (public library or local historical society) before students write for them, and tell students the exhibit dates.
Supports: let students choose topics in pairs and write separate labels on related parts. Give English learners a frame for the purpose statement. Students whose families worked in the mills may bring stories; welcome them, but remind students that every fact on a label must come from a source they can name. Stretch: write the purpose statement for two audiences (a child and a retired steelworker) and compare.
Answer guide: sample summary: “The Park Service’s wayside-writing page advises that exhibit writers must say something valuable quickly, because visitors may stop for 45 seconds or less. They should put key ideas in the main text, supporting details in captions, and their strongest sentence first.” Sample narrowing: steel mills, then blast furnaces, then the stoves that heat the air blast. The note cards paraphrase the unit’s sources: card A, Fitch’s Griswold interview (2.23); B, Fitch on steel pourers (Part 1, 2.04); C, Spring (2.17); D, Spring on charging the furnace (Part 1, 2.06); E, Crowell (2.18, 2.20, 2.25); F, Carnegie’s chapter XVIII (2.25; the coal-at-cost fact is in a paragraph the 2.25 passage cuts); G, Kellogg (2.22, and the exhibit paragraph Part 1 showed in 2.12); H, Epstein (2.19). If no partner is confirmed, present the labels as a school exhibit, as Part 1 suggests.
National Park Service, Harpers Ferry Center: Wayside Exhibit Writing · U.S. government work (National Park Service), public domain
This page comes from Harpers Ferry Center, part of the National Park Service. It gives advice for writing waysides: exhibit panels that visitors read while standing at a place, linked to the images and landscapes they can see there. We will use the same advice for our indoor museum labels.
The writers begin with a fact about their audience: people stop only briefly. So the text must be short, clear and connected to what the visitor sees. They also explain that visitors read in layers. Some read only the title and look at the picture, some read the main text and a few captions, and a few read everything. Finally, they advise moving your strongest sentence to the start.
Words to know: linger means to stay a while; fleeting means passing quickly; enhance means to improve; hierarchies means levels from most to least important; a sidebar is a small box of extra information beside the main text; an element is one part of a whole.
Wayside Exhibit Writing
Start with a place. Tell a short, engaging story. Leave readers wanting more. It sounds simple, but space is limited and the audience fleeting. Visitors may linger at a wayside for 45 seconds or less. Can something of value be read in that short time? Wayside text must connect with, support, and enhance the images and landscapes visitors see. The following guidelines for wayside writing are particularly important for visitors with cognitive and learning disabilities.
[…]
Put Text into Hierarchies
All wayside text is not created equal. Keep key thoughts in main text blocks, and supporting details in captions or labels. Some visitors only read the title and look at the main graphic. Others read the main text and some captions. A few read it all. Sometimes ideas that started out in the main text find a better fit as a sidebar or a caption. Sometimes a phrase can be cut out of main text and put to work as a direct label on an image. Keep each element focused.
The Most Powerful Sentence
Many writers find they need to work up to the heart of the matter, like a diver bounces on a diving board. It may take one, two, or three sentences to get there. After writing draft wayside text, find the best sentences. Try them out as the first sentence instead of leaving them in the middle or at the end.
Source: National Park Service, Harpers Ferry Center: Wayside Exhibit Writing (nps.gov)