analyze how Alcott develops and contrasts four sisters’ points of view about a poor Christmas, and write a comparison paragraph with evidence.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A family learns there will be no money for presents this year. Write what three different family members might say: one who complains, one who accepts it and one who looks for a bright side.
Four sisters in the 1860s learn there will be no Christmas presents. Their father is away with the army. Will they all react the same way?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
One situation, many views. Authors reveal character by letting different people react to the same event. Alcott opens Little Women with one problem, no presents, and four very different reactions.
Setting shapes the views. It is wartime, “going to be a hard winter for everyone,” and their father is “far away, where the fighting was.” That setting is why there are no presents. Each sister’s point of view is a different response to the same hard time.
Worked example 1: dialogue tags. Nia lines up the tags: Jo “grumbled,” Meg “sighed,” Amy spoke “with an injured sniff,” and Beth spoke “contentedly.” She notes that only Beth’s tag is positive. Before we know much else, Alcott has set Beth apart.
Worked example 2: a sister who is torn. Ivan studies Meg. She says they “ought to do it gladly,” then admits, “But I am afraid I don’t.” He writes: “Meg knows the right choice and agrees with it in her head, but she still longs for ‘all the pretty things she wanted.’ Her point of view is divided.”
Writing a comparison paragraph. Name both characters in your claim. Give evidence for each. Use transition words such as while, however, in contrast and both. Here is my model: Jo and Beth see the poor Christmas very differently. Jo complains that “Christmas won’t be Christmas without any presents,” while Beth reminds everyone, “We’ve got Father and Mother, and each other.” Jo measures Christmas by presents; in contrast, Beth measures it by family. Even so, both of them plan to spend their dollar on something they love, a book and music.
Make a four-box chart, one box per sister. Add a quotation to each as you go.
Write a comparison paragraph.
Choose two sisters. In 6-7 sentences, compare and contrast their points of view about the poor Christmas. Checklist: a claim naming both; at least one quotation for each sister; at least two transition words; reasoning that explains how Alcott develops each view (dialogue, tags or actions).
Which sister's point of view is closest to yours? Explain in 2-3 sentences.
The setting gave the sisters a shared problem; their points of view gave four answers. Next we look at a real street from the early 1900s.
Exit ticket: write one dialogue tag that would show a character is worried, without using the word worried.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading in four voices 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, comparison paragraph 10.
Text note: this Gutenberg edition prints Jo’s book as Undine and Sintran; other editions spell it Sintram. Quote it as shown. Family money troubles are central here; keep discussion on the characters.
Likely misconceptions: that point of view only means first or third person (here it means each character’s outlook); that Beth has no wishes of her own (she wants new music).
Supports: read the passage as readers’ theater with four students; a Venn diagram for two sisters. Stretch: how does Alcott use Beth’s sigh, “which no one heard but the hearth brush and kettle-holder,” to show something about Beth?
Answer guide: guided open question: the “hard winter” and “our men are suffering so in the army” are why Mother proposed no presents; Meg feels they “ought” to sacrifice, Jo argues their dollar “wouldn’t be much” help. Sample paragraph: Meg and Amy both feel the loss of pretty things, but differently. Meg says they should make “little sacrifices” and admits she does not do it gladly, while Amy says, “I don’t think it’s fair for some girls to have plenty of pretty things, and other girls nothing at all.” Meg struggles with her conscience; in contrast, Amy feels wronged by the world.
Louisa May Alcott, Little Women (1868), Project Gutenberg eBook #514 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #514
About the book. Louisa May Alcott published Little Women in 1868. It follows the four March sisters, Meg, Jo, Beth and Amy, in a New England town during the Civil War. Their father is away serving with the Union army, and the family has little money.
What to notice. Read the first four lines as a set: each sister speaks once. Then notice what each sister wants to buy with her dollar. Alcott develops each point of view through dialogue and through the dialogue tags, the words like “grumbled” and “sighed” that tell how a line is said.
Words to know. Contentedly means in a satisfied way. Proposed means suggested. Sacrifices are things given up for a good reason. Regretfully means with sorrow about a loss. A bookworm is someone who loves to read. Undine and Sintran is the title of a book of stories Jo wants. Faber’s was a brand of pencils. Decidedly means firmly.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the story and once with a pencil.
“Christmas won’t be Christmas without any presents,” grumbled Jo, lying on the rug.
“It’s so dreadful to be poor!” sighed Meg, looking down at her old dress.
“I don’t think it’s fair for some girls to have plenty of pretty things, and other girls nothing at all,” added little Amy, with an injured sniff.
“We’ve got Father and Mother, and each other,” said Beth contentedly from her corner.
The four young faces on which the firelight shone brightened at the cheerful words, but darkened again as Jo said sadly, “We haven’t got Father, and shall not have him for a long time.” She didn’t say “perhaps never,” but each silently added it, thinking of Father far away, where the fighting was.
Nobody spoke for a minute; then Meg said in an altered tone, “You know the reason Mother proposed not having any presents this Christmas was because it is going to be a hard winter for everyone; and she thinks we ought not to spend money for pleasure, when our men are suffering so in the army. We can’t do much, but we can make our little sacrifices, and ought to do it gladly. But I am afraid I don’t,” and Meg shook her head, as she thought regretfully of all the pretty things she wanted.
[…]
“But I don’t think the little we should spend would do any good. We’ve each got a dollar, and the army wouldn’t be much helped by our giving that. I agree not to expect anything from Mother or you, but I do want to buy Undine and Sintran for myself. I’ve wanted it so long,” said Jo, who was a bookworm.
“I planned to spend mine in new music,” said Beth, with a little sigh, which no one heard but the hearth brush and kettle-holder.
“I shall get a nice box of Faber’s drawing pencils; I really need them,” said Amy decidedly.
Source: Louisa May Alcott, Little Women (1868), Project Gutenberg eBook #514 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)