evaluate how the charts and explaining paragraphs in a 1918 study work together to show hours and wages of Black workers who moved from the South to Pittsburgh, and catch where text and chart do not match.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Look at the two bar charts before reading any sentences. In 30 seconds, write the biggest difference you see between Pittsburgh and the South.
During World War I, why did Pittsburgh's steel mills look for workers in the South?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Graphics are part of the argument. Charts, tables, maps and photographs are not decoration. They organize information so the reader can compare quickly. The paragraphs around them explain what matters. To evaluate them, ask: What does the chart show at a glance? What does the text add? Do they agree?
Reading a bar chart. Read the title, then the labels, then the numbers. Longer bars mean larger percents. Compare matching bars (Pittsburgh “10 HOURS” with South “10 HOURS”).
Worked example 1: chart and text agree. Grace reads Table X: 51% worked ten hours in Pittsburgh and 38% in the South. The paragraph says the same: “fifty-one percent as against thirty-eight percent.” The chart lets her see the gap; the paragraph names it.
Worked example 2: text and chart do not match. Tyrone reads the wage paragraph: “it appears from table number X.” He checks. Table X is about hours; the wage chart is Table XI. The numbers in the paragraph match Table XI, so he decides the author or printer made a small labeling slip. Careful readers always check.
What the text adds. The charts cannot tell you the average wage. The paragraph does: “$2.85 here; in the South it amounted to $2.15.” It also offers an explanation the chart cannot: more men worked over twelve hours in the South because many had been farm laborers.
Why this matters for us. Our museum labels will include a map and a timeline. Every graphic we make must match the words beside it.
Use the charts first, then check each answer in the paragraphs.
Evaluate and redesign.
Evaluate the section (5-6 sentences): How well do Tables X and XI and their paragraphs help a reader understand why migrants came and why some did not stay? Mention one strength, the labeling slip, and one thing you wish the study showed.
Museum design: sketch a simple bar chart for a label comparing average daily wages ($2.85 in Pittsburgh, $2.15 in the South). Write a one-sentence caption that names the source and year.
Charts and words checked each other, and we found a slip. Next we read Andrew Carnegie’s own story of choosing a site for a steel mill in Braddock.
Exit ticket: what is one question you would ask the workers Epstein interviewed, if you could?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 8, guided practice 10, evaluation 9.
Text note: the bars are Project Gutenberg’s text transcription of Epstein’s printed graphs, copied exactly; the percents are the printed numbers. The wage paragraph’s “table number X” is as printed in the file; its numbers match Table XI. The context in the summary (the war stopping European immigration, labor agents) comes from Epstein’s introduction in the same file.
Care with this source: use only this excerpt. Elsewhere Epstein repeats stereotypes common in 1918 and quotes a slur used by white workers who drove Black workers out of a glass plant. If students research further, preview pages first. Name plainly that Black workers were often kept in unskilled jobs and faced hostility; Epstein documents both.
Likely misconceptions: that the longest bar is always the important one; that a chart cannot contain a mistake; that “average” means what most people earned.
Supports: a two-column checker (chart says / text says). Stretch: 15% earned over $3.60 in the South but only 5% in Pittsburgh. What might explain that?
Answer guide: chart strength: the 10-hour and under-$2.00 gaps are visible at a glance; text adds averages and reasons (farm labor). A missing piece: the charts do not show which jobs were in steel mills.
Abraham Epstein, The Negro Migrant in Pittsburgh (University of Pittsburgh, 1918), Project Gutenberg eBook #67349 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #67349
About the text. In 1917, Abraham Epstein, a University of Pittsburgh economics student, interviewed hundreds of Black workers who had recently moved from the South. He published his study in 1918. He explains that World War I had nearly stopped immigration from Europe, so railroads and steel mills sent labor agents South. Many workers took jobs in the mills. This move was part of what historians call the Great Migration.
What to notice. Each bar chart compares Pittsburgh with the South. Each paragraph after a chart explains it. Check the numbers in the paragraphs against the charts. Do they always match?
Words to know. A migrant is a person who moves to a new place, often for work. Negro was the respectful term in 1918; today we say Black or African American. To disclose is to reveal. Comparative means comparing. An average is a typical value found by dividing a total.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big ideas and once with a pencil.
An examination of the kind and hours of work and wages received, discloses another reason why many of these people do not remain here.
TABLE NUMBER X
Comparison Between Hours of Work Per Day in Pittsburgh and in South
HOURS OF LABOR IN PITTSBURGH UNDER 10 ████████ 16% 10 HOURS ██████████████████████████████ 51% 10 TO 12 ██████████████ 28% OVER 12 ██ 4% NOT STATED █ 1% IN THE SOUTH UNDER 10 █████████████ 27% 10 HOURS ███████████████████ 38% 10 TO 12 ███████ 14.5% OVER 12 ███████ 14% NOT STATED ███ 6.5%A comparison between work hours of migrants in the South and in Pittsburgh, reveals another interesting feature. As against the twenty-seven percent who were working less than ten hours a day at home, only sixteen percent are working for a like period here. A greater number work a ten-hour day here than in the South, (fifty-one percent as against thirty-eight percent), and there seems to be a greater number working over twelve hours per day before coming North, than afterward. This is probably due to the fact that a considerable body of these men were farm laborers.
TABLE NUMBER XI
Comparison of Wages Received Per Day in Pittsburgh and in South
IN PITTSBURGH UNDER $2.00 ██ 5% $2.00 TO $3.00 ███████████████████████████████ 62% $3.00 TO $3.60 ██████████████ 28% OVER $3.60 ██ 5% IN THE SOUTH UNDER $2.00 ████████████████████████████ 56% $2.00 TO $3.00 ████████████ 25% $3.00 TO $3.60 ██ 4% OVER $3.60 ███████ 15%As to the comparative wages paid here and in the South, it appears from table number X, that the great mass of workers get higher wages here than in the places from which they come, fifty-six percent received less than two dollars a day in the South, while only five percent received such wages in Pittsburgh. However the number of those who said they received high wages in the South is greater than the number of those receiving them here. Fifteen percent said they received more than three dollars and sixty cents a day at home, while only five percent received more than that rate for twelve hours work here. Sixty-seven percent of the four hundred and fifty-three persons stating their earnings here, earn less than three dollars per day. Twenty-eight percent earn from three dollars to three sixty per day, while only five percent earn more than three dollars and sixty cents per day. The average working day for both Pittsburgh and the South is ten and four-tenths hours. The average wage is $2.85 here; in the South it amounted to $2.15.
Source: Abraham Epstein, The Negro Migrant in Pittsburgh (University of Pittsburgh, 1918), Project Gutenberg eBook #67349 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)