give and use specific feedback in a peer conference, building on my partner’s ideas, and make a revision plan for my purpose and audience.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Write down the most helpful comment anyone ever gave you about your work: a coach, a teacher, a friend. What made it helpful? Then write one comment that was not helpful, and why.
When should a writer first share a draft with real readers?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Writers need readers. You know what you meant to write; only a reader can tell you what you actually wrote. Today you will hold a peer conference: a short, structured conversation about each other’s drafts.
Come prepared. The discussion standard asks you to come to discussions prepared. Bring your full draft, your checklist and one question you want answered (“Is my crossroads moment clear?”).
The conference protocol (12 minutes per writer). (1) The writer reads aloud while the partner listens. (2) The partner paraphrases: retells the story in two or three sentences and names the setting and the choice. (3) The partner gives one glow, a specific strength with exact words quoted, and one grow, a specific suggestion tied to a checklist item. (4) The writer asks a follow-up question and records a revision plan.
Building on ideas and staying on topic. Strong discussion partners connect to what was just said: “Building on your point about the ending, what if …” If the talk drifts, bring it back with a question: “Can we go back to the middle? Where did you get lost?” If your partner gives evidence you had not considered, it is a sign of strength, not weakness, to say, “You’re right; I didn’t see that.”
Worked example 1: Marcus gives a useful grow. Marcus reads Aaliyah’s draft. A vague comment would be “Make it better.” Instead he says, “Checklist item 1: I didn’t know it was nighttime until the third paragraph. Could you put the time in your first sentence?” One place, one change, tied to a criterion.
Worked example 2: Aaliyah adjusts her thinking. Aaliyah first defends her ending: “It’s supposed to be sudden.” Marcus asks, “Did your character learn anything?” She rereads, notices that her last paragraph never reflects on the choice, and writes in her plan: Add one reflective line about the creek. She changed her mind because of evidence.
The writer decides. You do not have to make every change. But you must consider each suggestion and write why you accepted or rejected it. Your audience, family readers who do not know you, is the test.
Practice the protocol with “The Last Bus” before you confer about your own draft.
Hold your peer conference, then plan your revisions.
Conference notes (as reader): write your paraphrase of your partner’s story, one glow with exact words quoted, and one grow tied to a checklist item (opening, dialogue or conclusion). Write one question you asked to build on their idea.
Revision plan (as writer): list three changes you will make, each tied to a checklist number. For one suggestion you decided not to follow, explain why. Then explain how one change will help a family reader who does not know you.
Elizabeth Jane Cochran was born in 1864 in Cochran’s Mills, in Armstrong County, Pennsylvania. According to the Library of Congress, she began her career by answering an article in the Pittsburg Dispatch that condemned women who wanted an education or a job. She signed her reply “Lonely Orphan Girl.” The newspaper looked for the writer, and she joined the staff in 1885, writing under the pen name Nellie Bly.
Her first stories covered subjects many people then avoided, such as divorce and harsh conditions for women working in factories. When advertisers pulled money from the paper because of her articles, she was moved to stories about social events and fashion. She wanted to write stories that could change women’s lives, so after several years she left for New York, leaving a note: “I am off for New York. Look out for me. BLY.” In 1887 she joined Joseph Pulitzer’s New York World and became a famous investigative reporter.
Think about it: Bly’s first job came from writing a reply to something she disagreed with, and her editors’ choices pushed her to leave Pittsburgh. How did her readers and editors shape her path? What does her story suggest about listening to feedback and knowing when to disagree with it?
Professional writers trust readers to show them what the page really says.
Exit ticket: what did your partner understand differently from what you intended? What will you do about it first?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 6, mini lecture and model conference with the mentor text 8, case study 6, conferences 20 (two rounds of about 10), revision plan in the remaining time or as homework.
Likely misconceptions: that feedback means pointing out mistakes only; that agreeing politely is good discussion; that changing your mind is losing. Model a conference with a volunteer first, including one moment when you change your mind because of evidence.
Sources: reading from Digital.gov’s Plain Language Guide, “Test for understanding” (opened 2026-11-20). Case study facts and the quoted note are from the Library of Congress Headlines and Heroes blog, Amber Paranick, “Nellie Bly” post of November 8, 2022 (blogs.loc.gov/headlinesandheroes/2022/11/nellie-bly-blackwells-island/), and the Library of Congress research guide guides.loc.gov/nellie-bly (birth name and dates), both opened 2026-11-20. The newspaper spelled its name Pittsburg in those years. The blog post goes on to describe Bly’s undercover reporting inside a mental institution; we do not cover it here.
Supports: provide sentence stems (“When you wrote ___, I felt ___”; “Building on what you said …”; “Can we go back to …?”). Pair students thoughtfully; allow a teacher conference for students who are not ready to share a personal story. Stretch: lead a three-person conference and summarize the group’s agreements.
Assessment: the conference notes show CC.1.5.7.A:1a (prepared, builds on ideas) and serve as a check of the opening (N), dialogue (O) and conclusion (P) the drafts now contain.
Answer guide: sample paraphrase: “Nadia is waiting for the last bus to her first art class when she sees her little brother alone at the ball field. Because the path home is dark, she lets the bus go and walks him home. She joins the class the next week.” Sample grow: “Item 7: your last line says you learned family matters most. Could you show it with an image instead?”
Digital.gov (U.S. General Services Administration), Plain Language Guide: Test for understanding · U.S. government work (U.S. General Services Administration), public domain
This page from Digital.gov’s Plain Language Guide is about checking whether readers really understand what you wrote. It says testing should be part of the writing and planning process from the start, and that testing early can save time answering questions later.
The guide’s advice on timing is simple: start as soon as you have enough material to test. Do not wait for a finished product. Test, revise based on what you learn, and test again. It recommends planning for at least two rounds, and it calls this repeating cycle iteration.
It describes several methods. In paraphrase testing, you meet one reader at a time and ask them to explain a short text in their own words; it works well for short documents. Usability testing fits longer documents and websites. Focus groups are better for learning what an audience thinks before you write than for checking understanding.
A peer conference is a small paraphrase test. If your partner can retell your story and name the choice, your draft is working.
Source: Digital.gov (U.S. General Services Administration), Plain Language Guide: Test for understanding (digital.gov)