determine the technical meanings of blast-furnace words from context and interpret the figurative language a 1917 writer uses to explain how iron is made, analyzing its effect on tone.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Explain to a younger student how cooking an egg changes it. Then explain it again by comparing the egg to something else. Which explanation was easier to picture?
A blast furnace turns iron ore into iron. What is the main thing that has to be removed from the ore?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three kinds of meaning. A technical meaning is the exact meaning a word has in a field, like science or steelmaking. A figurative meaning compares or exaggerates to help you picture something. A connotative meaning is the feeling a word carries.
Context clues for technical words. Writers often define a term right beside it: the ‘hearth’ or bottom of the furnace. Watch for or, commas, dashes and examples.
Worked example 1: a technical word. Hannah meets “charging.” She keeps reading: “first coke, next… iron ores, then limestone,” pushed in buggies and dumped at the top. She decides that to charge a furnace means to load it with its raw materials. That is different from charging a phone or charging a fee.
Worked example 2: an extended metaphor. Luis notices that Spring treats the furnace as a living creature: it has “moods,” can “rebel,” is “gentle and obedient as a lamb” but becomes “a domineering fury when it has dyspepsia” because its “diet” was wrong. Luis explains: the materials are its food, and careless loading makes it dangerous.
Why mix them? The comparisons make a frightening machine easy to picture and create a tone that is both playful and uneasy. The superintendent’s “affinity” story turns chemistry into a romance: oxygen “deserts” iron for carbon. It is memorable, but it is still a comparison. The science underneath is that oxygen leaves the iron and joins with carbon.
A model explanation. Spring calls the furnace “this monster” and “this powerful creature,” which makes it sound alive and hard to control. The words create an uneasy tone that fits his point: the furnace is safe only when its workers are careful.
Use context for each word before you check the glossary.
Word work for our labels.
Make a mini glossary for museum visitors: define charge, hearth, slag and coke in plain words, using the passage. Under each, copy the context clue that helped you.
Rewrite the “affinity” explanation in 2-3 plain, accurate sentences for a museum label. Then explain in one sentence what is lost and what is gained without the comparison.
A monster, a lamb and a chemical romance: comparisons help, but labels need plain facts too. Next we read numbers in charts.
Exit ticket: write one technical word and one figurative phrase from today, and say which would help a museum visitor more.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, word work 9.
Text note: Spring wrote these chapters first for his company’s magazine, Valve World, in 1915-1916 (book foreword). The cut skips the stair climb and a paragraph in which the superintendent describes a furnace accident that killed a worker; share it only if useful. Quotation marks inside the passage are the superintendent speaking.
Science check: in the furnace, carbon (from coke) takes oxygen from iron oxide; limestone combines with impurities to form slag. Spring’s temperature (about 2800-3000 degrees F) is his figure.
Likely misconceptions: that figurative language is inaccurate or out of place in nonfiction; that “charge” has one meaning; that slag is a kind of iron.
Discussion note: the “affinity” comparison treats oxygen as a woman in an old romance story. Students may notice this; it is a fair point about 1917 writing.
Answer guide: alive words: “this monster,” “rebel,” “its moods,” “gentle and obedient as a lamb,” “domineering fury,” “its wrath.” Tone: playful but uneasy; it warns that the furnace is powerful and must be handled with care.
La Verne W. Spring, Non-Technical Chats on Iron and Steel (Frederick A. Stokes, 1917), chapter IV, Project Gutenberg eBook #73090 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #73090
About the text. La Verne W. Spring was the chief chemist and metallurgist of Crane Company, a manufacturing company in Chicago. In 1917 he published short “chats” to explain iron and steel to ordinary readers. Chapter IV takes readers on a visit to a blast furnace. First they ride an elevator to the top; then a furnace superintendent explains the process.
What to notice. Spring mixes two kinds of language: exact technical words (charge, hearth, slag) and figurative comparisons (a monster, a lamb, a romance between chemicals). Circle the technical words. Box the comparisons.
Words to know. Coke is a fuel made by baking coal. Ore is rock that contains a metal. Incessant means nonstop. Dyspepsia is an upset stomach. Remiss means careless about a duty. Metallurgical has to do with the science of metals. A buggy here is a small cart.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big ideas and once with a pencil.
Day and night, month in and month out, during the life of the fire-brick lining of the furnace, this routine of charging, first coke, next the theoretically correct charge of analyzed iron ores, then limestone, in rotation goes on. From 6 A.M. to 6 P.M. and from 6 P.M. to 6 A.M. on twelve-hour shifts, alternating gangs of laborers push the buggies across to the furnace top, dump and return them to the elevator already up with another load.
The incessant quiver of the iron plates beneath our feet with the rumbling and groaning from the inside of this monster are disquieting and the thought constantly recurs: “What if this powerful creature should just now rebel, as quite occasionally occurred in the old days when all of its moods had not been so well understood?” For this king of metallurgical devices, though gentle and obedient as a lamb under proper treatment, is a domineering fury when it has dyspepsia as occurs whenever its attendants are remiss in their attentions to its diet. “Those explosion doors just below the furnace top—are they in working order and would they be adequate?” But whether, as in recorded instances, the whole furnace top is torn off as evidence of its wrath, or its displeasure is exhibited in a milder way, we much prefer to be absent. The thought is disquieting and we are glad to leave.
[…]
“Oh yes,—where does the iron come from? Well, we often read nowadays of a man and his ‘affinity.’ Now the chemist has used that word ‘affinity’ for years to describe the liking or attraction of one chemical ‘element’ for another; in fact, that is where this recent colloquial use of the word originated. Iron ore is nothing more nor less than metallic iron, the element, chemically combined with oxygen, another element which constitutes one-fifth of the air we breathe. Under conditions produced in the blast furnace, though for centuries wedded to iron, oxygen deserts him for her ‘affinity’ carbon, which is best known to you as coke, coal, or charcoal. The iron, now free, becomes molten at the high temperature encountered (about 2800° to 3000° F.) and descends into the ‘hearth’ or bottom of the furnace, while oxygen and her new partner escape out of the top of the furnace in gaseous form. When molten iron has accumulated in the hearth to the extent desired it is tapped out as you will soon see.
“The limestone charged has ‘affinity’ for dirt and certain other impurities of the ore which it removes in molten form as the ‘cinder’ or ‘slag’ which is there running into the ladle.
Source: La Verne W. Spring, Non-Technical Chats on Iron and Steel (Frederick A. Stokes, 1917), chapter IV, Project Gutenberg eBook #73090 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)